Jewelry repair questions · Mail-in, shipping & insurance

Will a jeweler repair jewelry I didn't buy from them?

Usually, yes. Most repair jewelers work on pieces bought anywhere, though some turn down costume metal, old lead-solder repairs or unfamiliar construction, and a piece still under its maker's warranty should go back to the maker. JewelryRepair.com works on pieces whoever made or sold them, by mail; plated or uncertain pieces start with a free quote or the $19 evaluation.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$19Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full toward the repair
$30round-trip UPS shipping per order, however many pieces
1 yearworkmanship guarantee on the work we do
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • Most repair jewelers will. A repair is work on your piece, and where it was bought rarely matters. What matters is what it's made of, how it's built and what has been done to it before.
  • Some turn down particular pieces: plated or base metal that can't take solder heat, old repairs made with lead solder, and constructions they can't stand behind, such as invisible settings.
  • A piece still under warranty goes back to its maker or seller first.
  • Expect a careful jeweler to document it: condition recorded before work, an estimate, and a receipt you keep until it comes back.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Mail-In Evaluation $19For a piece you know little about: a jeweler examines the whole piece under magnification, every joint, prong, clasp and stone, not just the symptom you noticed, and sends photos and an itemized quote. Credited in full toward approved work; a declined piece ships back with the photos and findings.
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked and the metal and karat tested and documented, for a piece with no paperwork. Inside a repair, choosing Not sure as the metal gets it tested at no charge.
Ring Resizing from $45The most common job on a ring bought online or from another store: the shank is cut, opened or closed to the new size, and new metal matched to the ring's karat and color is fitted for sizing up. Priced by metal, width, style and direction, shown before you pay; choose Not sure and the metal is tested at no charge. Check first whether the seller's resizing policy still applies.

Why a jeweler might turn a piece down

A refusal is usually about the piece, not about where you bought it. These are the common reasons, and what each one means for you.

  • The metal won't take the work. Costume and fashion pieces are often plated base metal, and heat and polishing can cut through the plating at a joint and expose the metal underneath. Many jewelers quote these case by case or decline them; see can costume jewelry be repaired?
  • An earlier repair used lead solder. Soft lead solder is a quick fix that causes real trouble later. In a Ganoksin Orchid forum discussion on removing it, one repair jeweler warns that any lead left on a piece will destroy the gold once the torch reaches gold-soldering temperatures. That jeweler removes the lead before any torch work, charges extra for it and tells the customer before the piece is left.
  • The construction is hard to stand behind. Some styles make outside work risky. Invisible settings are the classic case: in a 2004 Orchid discussion, one jeweler said he often refuses to size them when he isn't sure how they were made, and another noted that most manufacturers ask for that work to be sent back to them. See can an invisible-set ring be repaired?
  • Someone else still covers it. A piece under a maker's warranty or a store's protection plan may need to go back there; more on that below.
  • It's outside what that counter does. Not every store repairs on site, and not every bench does watches, pearls or engraving. Ask who will do the work and where. At JewelryRepair.com every repair is done at the bench in our New York studio, never outsourced.

Check the warranty or service plan first

If the piece is new, or came with a protection plan, read the terms before anyone else works on it. Jewelers Mutual, a jewelry insurer, notes that some jewelry stores require you to bring a piece in a certain number of times to keep its warranty up to date, and that some insurance policies require annual inspections to maintain coverage. Read the terms for who may repair the piece, too: outside work can void the coverage.

  • Still under the maker's or seller's warranty or service plan: check with them first. The same goes for watches; a watch under its manufacturer's warranty should go back to the manufacturer, since an outside overhaul can void it.
  • Warranty expired, or the seller has closed: any repair jeweler can take it on. Keep the original paperwork; it tells the next jeweler the metal, the stones and sometimes the maker.
  • Insured on a policy: ask your insurer whether it has repair or inspection rules before you book, especially if the repair is part of a claim.
  • Bought from Sky Jewelry? Those pieces have their own purchase warranty, handled by the same bench; see the Sky Jewelry warranty.

Our 1-year workmanship guarantee covers the work we do, for a year from the day the piece is delivered back to you. It doesn't take over a maker's warranty, and we're not affiliated with, authorized by or endorsed by any jewelry or watch brand.

What a careful jeweler does with a piece they didn't sell

A jeweler taking in someone else's work has the same worry you do: an argument later about what was already wrong. Good intake practice protects both of you, and it's worth asking for wherever you go.

  • Condition recorded before work. Existing wear, chips and loose stones are noted, ideally with photos. For a significant diamond, the American Gem Society suggests asking the jeweler to plot a diagram of the stone, since its inclusions identify it.
  • Specific instructions and an estimate. The AGS advises giving the jeweler precise repair instructions and asking for an estimate if cost matters to you.
  • A receipt and a value. Keep the receipt and claim tag until the piece is back. The AGS also warns that if you don't give the jeweler a general value, the piece won't be insured while it's there.
  • Approval before extra work. If the jeweler finds more wrong than you came in for, you should hear about it, with the price, before anything is done.

Why this matters: damage a jeweler causes is generally the jeweler's to put right, but only if you can show the piece's condition beforehand. That's the point of the AGS intake advice above: condition notes and photos taken at intake are that proof, in both directions. Our guide will a jeweler swap my diamond? shows how to document a stone before you hand it over.

How JewelryRepair.com handles jewelry from anywhere

JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in repair service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. We repair customers' own pieces, whoever made or sold them: rings, chains, bracelets, earrings, stones and settings, pearls, watches, engraving and appraisals, sent from any US address.

  • The price doesn't depend on where you bought it. Each repair page prices the job by service, metal and options and shows the total before you pay. Shipping is $30 round trip per order, however many pieces share the box.
  • Photographed on arrival. Before anything else, the piece is photographed, recording stones, condition and existing wear, and the photos appear in your account. It's photographed again before it ships back, so you can compare the two.
  • Unknown metal? Choose Not sure on the repair page and the metal is tested at no charge; the exact price is set once it's confirmed. Standalone Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item.
  • Plated, steel or titanium pieces that need solder work, and plated pieces that need polishing, go to a free quote first.
  • Scope changes need your yes. If the jeweler finds more, work pauses and you get photos, a plain-English explanation and an itemized update. Decline, and the piece ships back with nothing more to pay.
  • Old, worn or previously repaired pieces: if a requested repair looks unsafe for the piece, we say so before working.
  • One jeweler, then a second. A named bench jeweler does the work and a second jeweler checks it before it ships.

Before you hand over or ship a piece you didn't buy here

  • Tell the jeweler what you know: the maker, the stamp, the stones, any lab report, and any earlier repairs, especially soldered ones. Send copies of paperwork, not originals.
  • Photograph it yourself before you seal the box, so you have your own record of its condition to set beside our intake photos.
  • Declare its real value. $100 of UPS coverage is included; full value costs 2.5% of the value above $100, both directions ($22.50 for a $1,000 piece), and under the terms of service the same declared value caps liability while the piece is with us. More in how jewelry shipping insurance works.
  • Want a price first? Send photos through the contact page for a free itemized quote within 1 business day.
  • In New York? Walk in at 354 Lenox Avenue (Malcolm X Blvd), New York, NY 10027, Sunday to Thursday 10 AM to 7 PM, with early closing on Friday, or call (212) 597-2899.

Questions

Will a jeweler fix a ring I bought online?
Usually, yes. A ring bought online is repaired like any other, as long as it's metal that can take the work. Check first whether the seller's warranty or resizing policy still applies, since outside work can void it. JewelryRepair.com repairs rings from any seller by mail: Ring Resizing starts at $45 in silver, and an unknown metal is tested at no charge when you choose Not sure.
Do jewelers charge more to fix jewelry bought somewhere else?
Not usually for the repair itself, though a jeweler may charge extra for problems left by earlier work, such as stripping old lead solder before the torch touches gold. At JewelryRepair.com the price is set by the service, metal and options on the repair page, not by where the piece came from, and you see the total before you pay. Shipping is $30 round trip per order.
Will getting my jewelry repaired somewhere else void the warranty?
It can. Jewelers Mutual notes that some stores require you to bring a piece in a certain number of times to keep its warranty up to date, and some plans also specify who may repair it. Read your terms, and if the piece is still covered by its maker or seller, check with them before booking anywhere else. Once the warranty has lapsed, any repair jeweler can do the work.
Can a jeweler refuse to repair my jewelry?
Yes. A jeweler can decline any job they can't do safely or stand behind. Common reasons are base metal or plating that won't take solder, old lead-solder repairs, fragile constructions such as invisible settings, and pieces still under another company's warranty. A refusal is about the piece, not where you bought it. If you're unsure, JewelryRepair.com's $19 Mail-In Evaluation gives you photos and an itemized quote first.
Who pays if a jeweler damages jewelry I didn't buy from them?
Damage a jeweler causes is generally the jeweler's responsibility, but you'll need proof of the piece's condition beforehand, which is why intake photos matter. At JewelryRepair.com your piece is photographed on arrival and before it ships back, and liability is capped at the declared value covered by the order: $100, or the full value up to $10,000 if you add full-value coverage.
Will a jeweler repair costume or fashion jewelry?
Sometimes. Plated and base-metal pieces can't always take solder heat or polishing without exposing the metal underneath, so many jewelers quote them case by case. At JewelryRepair.com, plated pieces that need solder work or polishing start with a free quote, and the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full, covers anything you're unsure about. For an inexpensive piece, compare the repair price with replacing it.