Jewelry repair questions · Mail-in, shipping & insurance

What happens if a jeweler loses or damages my jewelry?

What you recover depends on your state's law, the shop's written terms, its insurance and your proof, so report the loss or damage to the shop in writing right away, with photos, your receipt and any appraisal. At JewelryRepair.com, liability is capped at your order's coverage: $100, or the full value you declare, up to $10,000.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$100UPS coverage included each way on every JewelryRepair.com order
2.5%of the value above $100 covers the full value both ways, up to $10,000 ($22.50 on a $1,000 ring)
1 business dayusual time for a jeweler to review a JewelryRepair.com guarantee claim sent with a photo
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers

The short version

  • Put it in writing, fast. Tell the shop exactly what's missing or damaged and what you want done, and keep a copy. The FTC's advice for any dispute with a business starts there.
  • Your piece is in the shop's custody. Cornell Law School's Legal Information Institute defines a bailment as a non-ownership transfer of possession, which is what leaving a piece for repair is. What the shop owes you is set by your state's law and the terms you agreed to.
  • Read the take-in receipt. Shops often limit what they'll pay in their terms.
  • Ask about the shop's insurance. The American Gem Society notes that many jewelers block policies cover customers' jewelry held for repair, cleaning or appraisal.
  • Proof decides it: dated photos, an appraisal, the purchase receipt and a take-in slip that describes the piece.
  • At JewelryRepair.com, every piece is photographed on arrival and before it ships, and liability is capped at your order's coverage.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Appraisal from $105A written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, examined in hand. It gives you the value to schedule with your insurer and to declare whenever the piece is shipped.
Mail-In Evaluation $19A second look at a piece that came back wrong: examined under magnification, photographed, and quoted item by item for the repair. Credited in full toward work you approve; a declined piece ships back with the photos and findings.

Lost, damaged or swapped: what usually went wrong

  • Lost in the shop. A piece slipped into another customer's envelope, misplaced between benches, sent to another workshop untracked, or stolen. Ask for a search, a written incident report, the name of the shop's insurer, and whether your piece ever left the premises.
  • Lost in the mail. A carrier claim pays up to the value declared on that package, not what the piece is worth; see how jewelry shipping insurance works and whether it's safe to mail jewelry.
  • A stone cracked or chipped. GIA's study of gemstone durability notes that even a diamond can be damaged if a setter is heavy-handed bending a prong over it, and that torch heat can make inclusions expand until a stone fractures. It also notes that fractures or inclusions near the girdle make a stone more fragile, so a crack can grow from a flaw that was already there. Only a record made before the work settles which.
  • A scratched watch or ring: a case back opened with the wrong tool, a slipped spring bar tool, or a polishing wheel that rounded crisp edges. Compare with photos taken before the repair.
  • It doesn't look like your stone. Will a jeweler swap my diamond? shows how to document a diamond and check it after a repair.

What to do if it happens

  • Point it out before you leave. If you notice damage at pickup, show the jeweler and ask for a note on your receipt. If you find it later, contact the shop that day.
  • Photograph it beside your earlier photos, in similar light and from the same angles.
  • Gather your paperwork: take-in receipt, purchase receipt, appraisal, any grading report and photos. Send copies and keep the originals, as the FTC advises.
  • Write to the shop. The FTC suggests describing the problem, saying what you want (a repair, a replacement or payment), setting a deadline, keeping a copy and sending it with proof of delivery.
  • Don't have it fixed elsewhere yet. Once another jeweler repairs the damage, the evidence is gone.
  • Tell your insurer and ask how it handles a piece lost or damaged in someone else's care.
  • Escalate if you're stuck. The FTC points to your state attorney general or consumer protection office, the Better Business Bureau, and small claims court, which can resolve many money disputes, usually without a lawyer. For a valuable piece, a lawyer in your state can tell you what its law says. This page is general information, not legal advice.

Before you hand over any piece

  • Take photos from several angles, with close-ups of each stone, any engraving and the hallmarks. Jewelers Mutual, the jewelry insurer, suggests keeping a picture of each item with its appraisals, receipts and certifications.
  • Get a receipt that describes it: metal and stamps, number and type of stones with approximate sizes, engraving, and existing chips or worn prongs. "Yellow ring with white stone" protects nobody.
  • Ask three questions: Is my piece insured while you have it? Does any work go out to another workshop? What does your receipt say about your liability?
  • Know its value. A current written appraisal sets the number you schedule with your insurer and declare when it ships; a Jewelry Appraisal here starts at $105.

How JewelryRepair.com documents a piece in its care

JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in repair service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. A piece in our care is:

  • Photographed on arrival, before anything else, recording stones, condition and existing wear. The photos appear in your account.
  • Kept with one named bench jeweler, not passed between stations, and checked by a second jeweler; every bench is on camera.
  • Never worked past what you approved. If the jeweler finds more damage, or a repair looks unsafe for an antique or worn piece, work pauses and you get photos and an itemized update.
  • Photographed again before it ships back, so you can compare intake and outgoing photos yourself.

If our work causes a problem, the 1-year workmanship guarantee covers the work, the materials added and any damage the work directly caused: it's redone at no charge, or the repair price is refunded if a redo isn't possible. Send the order number and a photo through the contact page, and a jeweler usually reviews it within 1 business day. If a package goes missing, tell us as soon as tracking looks wrong; JewelryRepair.com files the claim with UPS for you.

The limit, in plain numbers

Under JewelryRepair.com's terms of service, liability for a piece, in transit or at the studio, is capped at the declared value covered by your order. Every order includes $100 of UPS coverage each way, so without added coverage, $100 is the most owed if a $2,000 ring is lost. Conditions you didn't disclose and that couldn't be detected on inspection are excluded.

"Insure the full value" on the repair page, before checkout, costs 2.5% of the declared value above $100, one fee for both directions, up to $10,000 per package: $22.50 for a $1,000 piece (2.5% of $900), $60 for $2,500 (2.5% of $2,400), $247.50 for $10,000 (2.5% of $9,900). Over $10,000, contact the studio first. Coverage runs from the first UPS scan until the package is signed for, and applies only if the piece is padded in a rigid box with nothing outside naming the contents; the shipping and insurance page has every rule. Questions: (212) 597-2899, 354 Lenox Avenue (Malcolm X Blvd), New York, NY 10027.

Questions

Is a jeweler responsible if they lose my ring?
It depends on your state's law and the terms you agreed to. Leaving a ring for repair puts it in the shop's custody, but many take-in slips limit what the shop will pay. Read yours, ask for the name of the shop's insurer, and put your claim in writing with photos, the receipt and any appraisal. For a valuable piece, a lawyer in your state can advise.
What if the jeweler says the damage was already there?
Then the condition record decides it. Ask to see the take-in receipt or intake photos and compare them with your own dated photos. Some damage really does come before the repair: GIA notes that fractures near a stone's girdle make it more fragile during setting. At JewelryRepair.com every piece is photographed on arrival, before any work, so you and the bench can both see what changed.
Does homeowners insurance cover jewelry lost at a repair shop?
It might; only your insurer can say for your policy. The Insurance Information Institute puts the usual theft limit for unscheduled jewelry at about $1,500 on a standard policy, while a scheduled piece gets broader coverage. Ask before you hand a valuable piece over; how floaters and repair-time coverage work is explained in how does jewelry insurance work.
How much does JewelryRepair.com pay if my piece is lost?
Up to the coverage on your order. Every order includes $100 of UPS coverage each way, and under the terms of service liability for a piece is capped at that declared value. To cover more, choose full-value coverage before checkout: 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions, up to $10,000. Covering a $2,500 ring costs $60.
What should a jewelry repair receipt include?
Enough detail to identify the piece and its condition: the metal and any stamps, the number and type of stones with approximate sizes, any engraving, and existing damage such as chips, worn prongs or loose stones. Add the work requested, the price and the promised date. Keep your own photos with it; a receipt that says only "yellow ring with stone" protects nobody.
Can I take a jeweler to small claims court?
Yes, if talking it through fails. The FTC notes that small claims courts can resolve many financial disputes, usually without a lawyer, and each state sets its own dollar limit. Before filing, send the shop a written complaint with copies of your receipt, photos and appraisal and a deadline to reply, and consider your state attorney general's or consumer protection office's complaint process.