Stones

Jewelry appraisal

Gloved hands holding a diamond solitaire under a microscope for appraisal

A jewelry appraisal is a written document in which an appraiser identifies a piece, describes its metal, stones and condition, and assigns it a dollar value for a stated purpose. For insurance, that value is what it would cost to replace the piece at retail today, the figure an insurer uses to schedule coverage.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

What a jewelry appraisal includes

An appraisal is more than a number. A useful one describes the piece closely enough that an insurer, or a jeweler making a replacement, could identify it and match it: the metal and its karat, each stone's measurements and estimated weight, the color and clarity of the main stones, how the piece is made, what condition it is in, and photographs. The IRS, writing about appraisals for donated property, says the same thing in its own terms: gems and jewelry almost always need a specialized jewelry appraiser, and a stone's coloring, weight, cut, brilliance and flaws should be reported and analyzed.

Set stones can't be put on a scale without taking them out of the mounting, so an appraiser measures them in the setting and calculates the weight from those measurements. That is why an appraisal of a mounted diamond gives an estimated weight, while a lab report on a loose stone gives a measured one. The appraiser then researches what a comparable piece would cost to buy at retail today and signs the document.

Why it matters: insurance

The usual reason to get one is insurance. According to the Insurance Information Institute, a standard homeowners policy has a relatively low limit for jewelry theft, generally about $1,500, which may not replace a single engagement ring. To cover a piece for its full value you buy a floater and schedule the item on it, and the III notes that items must be professionally appraised before a floater is purchased. The appraised value becomes the amount the piece is insured for, so an appraisal that is too low leaves you underinsured. More in how jewelry insurance works.

Values drift. Gold, platinum and stone prices move, and a ring appraised years ago may now be insured for less than it would cost to replace. The American Gem Society advises yearly inspections and re-evaluations so coverage keeps pace. If your insurer sets its own update schedule, follow that. More in how often jewelry should be reappraised and do I need an appraisal to insure my ring?

Replacement value vs what it would sell for

Every appraisal is written for a purpose, and the purpose sets the kind of value. An insurance appraisal states retail replacement value: what it would cost to buy a comparable piece new, today. That is often more than anyone would pay you for the piece. Fair market value is a different standard, which the IRS defines as the price property would sell for on the open market, between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither forced to act; it is the standard for tax purposes such as charitable donations. So don't read an insurance appraisal as a resale price. See is an appraisal what jewelry would sell for?

Appraisals at JewelryRepair.com are insurance-replacement-value documents. An appraisal here is not a buying or pawn service, so there's no stake in the number.

Appraisal vs diamond grading report

The two get mixed up all the time. A grading report from a gem lab such as GIA describes a stone's quality: its 4Cs (carat weight, color, clarity and cut), measurements, shape and any known treatments. GIA is explicit that a report does not indicate a diamond's monetary value. An appraisal is the reverse: an estimate of what the finished piece is worth, and appraisers often start from a lab report's grades. The IRS likewise says GIA reports and color photos should be included with jewelry appraisals.

If your stone has a report, send a copy with the piece. An appraisal here is not a lab grading report or a GIA certificate. Two optional checks cover details that can change a stone's value: whether it has been treated, and its geographic origin, $20 each. More in is an appraisal the same as a GIA report?

How a mail-in appraisal works here

  • Book it. On the Jewelry Appraisal page, choose the item type: an unmounted stone, a ring, a pendant or charm, a necklace, a bracelet or anklet, or something else. All are $105. Add the stone origin or treatment check if your insurer asks for it, $20 each. Watches go to the Watch Appraisal instead.
  • Cover the trip. $100 of carrier coverage is included each way. Full value costs 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions, up to $10,000. Use your best estimate or the purchase receipt: a ring you believe is worth $5,000 costs $122.50 to cover (2.5% of $4,900). Over $10,000, contact the studio before shipping.
  • Ship it. The prepaid UPS label is waiting in your account. Pack the piece in a plain box with nothing on the outside naming the contents and drop it at any UPS location. Coverage runs from the first UPS scan until the package is signed for.
  • Get it back with the document. The piece is photographed on arrival, examined in hand rather than from photos, and returned by UPS with a signature required, along with a signed, photographed appraisal in the format insurers use to schedule coverage. Rush is $50 if your insurer is waiting.

Packing tips and what to send with the piece are in how to get jewelry appraised by mail.

What it costs here

A Jewelry Appraisal is $105 for any item type, with stone origin or treatment checks at $20 each. A Watch Appraisal is from $115, and Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item when you only need to know the metal. Shipping is $30 round trip by UPS per order. Brand surcharges, add-ons and worked totals are in how much a jewelry appraisal costs, and every option is under appraisals and testing.

Each piece is examined at the New York studio of Sky Jewelry, 354 Lenox Avenue (Malcolm X Blvd), New York, NY 10027: family jewelers on Lenox Avenue with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, who run JewelryRepair.com. It is an independent service, not affiliated with any jewelry or watch brand or with GIA.

Prices at a glance

Service Price What's included
Jewelry Appraisal from $105 A signed replacement-value document for your insurer, with photographs. The appraiser handles the piece itself: set stones measured and their weights worked out, color and clarity judged, metal and stamps checked, construction and condition recorded. Optional: stone origin +$20, treatment check +$20, rush +$50.
Watch Appraisal from $115 The watch is identified and described for your insurer (brand, model, reference, case metal, bracelet, dial, movement type and condition), with serial numbers noted when they can be read without taking the watch apart. Some brands add a charge.
Metal Testing & Verification $15 Stamps checked and the metal and karat tested, with the result written up: for when the question is what a piece is made of, not what it's worth.

Prices come from the live repair pages. Shipping is $30 round trip per order.

Questions

How much does a jewelry appraisal cost?
A jewelry appraisal is $105 at JewelryRepair.com for any item type, from a loose stone to a necklace, and stone origin or treatment checks add $20 each. A watch appraisal starts at $115. Round-trip UPS shipping is $30 per order, and full-value coverage for the trip costs 2.5% of the value above $100: covering a $2,500 ring costs $60 (2.5% of $2,400). Brand surcharges and add-ons are broken down on the appraisal cost answer page.
What does a jewelry appraisal include?
A description detailed enough to identify and replace the piece, plus a dollar value for a stated purpose. At JewelryRepair.com the piece is handled, not judged from photos: set stones are measured and their weights worked out, color and clarity judged, metal and stamps checked, construction and condition recorded, and the piece photographed. The signed document states insurance replacement value, for $105 per item.
How is a diamond's weight estimated when it's still set?
From its measurements. A set stone can't go on a scale without being taken out of its mounting, so the appraiser measures it in the setting and calculates the weight from those dimensions. That's why an appraisal of a mounted diamond gives an estimated weight, while a lab report on a loose stone gives a measured one. If your stone has a lab report, send a copy with the piece.
Is an appraisal the same as a GIA certificate?
No. A GIA grading report describes a stone's quality, its 4Cs, measurements and any known treatments, and GIA says a report does not indicate monetary value. An appraisal puts a dollar value on the finished piece, and appraisers often start from a lab report's grades. If your stone has a report, send a copy with the piece when you book an appraisal.
Can a watch be appraised the same way?
Yes, with its own service: a Watch Appraisal, from $115 for most brands. The appraiser identifies the watch by brand, model and reference and describes the case metal, bracelet, dial, movement type and condition, noting serial numbers when they can be read without taking the watch apart. Some brands cost more to appraise, such as Rolex at $315. You get a signed replacement-value appraisal with photographs.

All glossary terms · Repair questions · How online jewelry repair works

Sources