Jewelry repair questions · Mail-in, shipping & insurance

How does jewelry insurance work, and does homeowners or renters insurance cover jewelry, even while it's out for repair?

Home and renters policies cover jewelry as personal property, but theft is usually capped at about $1,500 on a standard policy (Insurance Information Institute). Full value means scheduling the piece on a floater, usually with an appraisal (from $105 here). Out for repair, ask your insurer; a JewelryRepair.com mail-in carries $100 UPS coverage each way, or full value to $10,000.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$1,500typical theft limit for jewelry on a standard homeowners policy (Insurance Information Institute)
$105written insurance-replacement-value appraisal, from
$100UPS coverage included each way on a mail-in repair
50,000+repairs since 1989

Four ways to insure jewelry

1. Under your homeowners or renters policy, unscheduled. The NAIC, the association of US state insurance regulators, notes that most homeowners and renters policies include jewelry as personal property, but that many set a limit and might not protect against all losses. The limit sits in the policy's special limits of liability, and for theft of jewelry Triple-I says it is generally about $1,500. It applies however high your overall personal property limit is. Coverage is for the perils your policy names, such as fire or theft, so a stone that drops out of its setting or a ring left behind at the gym may not be covered at all.

2. Raise the policy's special limit. Triple-I calls this the less expensive route, but the amounts stay capped per piece and overall, for example $2,000 a piece and $5,000 in total. It can suit a collection of modest pieces, not one valuable ring.

3. Scheduled on a floater, rider or endorsement. You list each piece with a description and a value, usually taken from an appraisal, and the NAIC notes that an item's value has the most influence on the premium and deductible. Triple-I describes a floater as the broadest protection for valuables, covering losses a home policy may leave out, accidental loss among them, and says items must be professionally appraised before you buy one. Insurers also call it a rider, endorsement or scheduled personal property, and in insurance terms it is inland marine coverage: the NAIC's glossary lists scheduled property, such as a homeowners personal property floater, under the inland marine line, which is why you may see that phrase on a quote.

4. A separate jewelry policy. If your policy's jewelry limit isn't enough for what you want to protect, the NAIC suggests a separate policy or an endorsement. The questions to ask are the same either way: what's covered, how a claim is settled, and what the deductible is.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Appraisal from $105Written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs: stones measured in their settings, metal tested, construction and condition recorded. Stone origin +$20, treatment check +$20.
Watch Appraisal from $115Written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, recording brand, model, case, dial and movement type. Brand surcharges apply on some brands (Rolex +$200).

How a claim is valued

The number on your policy and the payment after a loss aren't always the same. Triple-I's definitions:

  • Actual cash value pays what it takes to replace the item, minus depreciation.
  • Replacement cost pays what it takes to replace the item, without that deduction.

For a scheduled piece, ask before you buy: does a claim pay the scheduled amount, or the cost to replace the piece if that's lower? Can the insurer replace it through a jeweler of its choosing instead of paying cash? What's the deductible? The value on your appraisal sets the amount you schedule, so an appraisal that's years old can leave you underinsured if replacement prices have risen. The NAIC flags that some pieces, such as heirlooms, can gain value over time, and that some policies require periodic reappraisal.

What insurers usually ask for

The NAIC notes that in many cases insurers will require an appraisal, and it recommends a home inventory with details and photos of each piece. Useful to keep on file:

  • A written appraisal stating insurance replacement value.
  • Clear photos of each piece, including any inscription and hallmarks.
  • Receipts, and any lab grading report for a diamond or colored stone.
  • For watches, the brand, model, reference and serial numbers.

A Jewelry Appraisal at JewelryRepair.com (from $105) is a written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs. Stones are measured in their settings, color and clarity assessed, the metal tested and condition recorded. A Watch Appraisal (from $115) records brand, model, case metal, bracelet, dial and movement type, with serial and reference numbers where they can be read without invasive disassembly. Appraisals are not lab grading reports or GIA certificates, and not a buying or pawn service; send a copy of any grading report with the piece. See do you need an appraisal to insure a ring? and is an appraisal the same as a GIA report?

Repairs, wear and lost stones

Insurance and repair are different things. A policy responds to a covered loss or damage; re-tipping prongs that have worn down over years is upkeep. Whether a lost stone or a broken prong is covered depends on your policy's wording, and that question has its own page: does jewelry insurance cover a lost diamond?

Two habits help whatever your policy says. Keep the piece in good repair, because a worn or bent prong can end in a lost stone, and keep the appraisal current; see how often jewelry should be reappraised. And keep dated photos of its condition. The 1-year workmanship guarantee on repairs here covers the work that was done, not loss or new damage, so it isn't a substitute for insurance.

While it's out for repair: who covers what

A piece sent for repair passes through three stretches: on the way to the jeweler, at the jeweler, and on the way home. Your own policy may or may not follow it through all three. Before you ship, ask your insurer:

  • Does my policy cover the piece in transit, and does it set conditions such as a particular carrier, a tracking receipt or a signature?
  • Does it cover the piece while it's in a repair shop's care?
  • If I also buy coverage from the shipper, which one pays first?

A mail-in repair at JewelryRepair.com carries its own coverage, separate from your policy. Every order ships by UPS with $100 of coverage included each way. To cover the full value, choose "Insure the full value" on the repair page before checkout: it costs 2.5% of the declared value above $100, one fee for both directions, up to $10,000 per package. Covering a $1,000 piece costs $22.50 ($900 × 2.5%), and a $5,000 piece $122.50 ($4,900 × 2.5%). Coverage runs from the first UPS scan until the package is signed for, and under the terms of service the studio's liability for the piece is capped at that same declared value: $100, or the full value you covered. If a package goes astray, JewelryRepair.com files the claim with UPS for you. Over $10,000, contact the studio before shipping.

For the coverage to apply, the piece has to be padded in a rigid box sealed with the issued label, with nothing outside naming the contents. A signature is required at both ends, and the piece is photographed on arrival and before it ships back. The guide to how jewelry shipping insurance works covers declared value and claims in more depth.

What JewelryRepair.com does and doesn't do

JewelryRepair.com is a repair studio, not an insurer: it doesn't sell or recommend policies, and only your insurer can say what yours covers. What it can give you is paperwork an insurer can use: a written appraisal, and the intake and outgoing photos kept with each order. It's the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, at 354 Lenox Avenue (Malcolm X Blvd), New York, NY 10027, phone (212) 597-2899.

Questions

Does renters insurance cover jewelry?
Yes, as personal property, with the same catch as homeowners insurance: the NAIC notes that most renters and homeowners policies include jewelry but set limits and may not cover every loss. If a piece is worth more than your policy's jewelry limit, ask about scheduling it on a floater or buying a separate jewelry policy, which usually requires a written appraisal.
How do I add an engagement ring to my homeowners or renters insurance?
Call your insurer and ask to schedule the ring on a floater with its description and value. Most insurers will want a written appraisal, so have it ready with the receipt, any lab grading report and clear photos, and ask whether the ring is covered for accidental loss as well as theft. A written insurance-replacement-value appraisal by mail at JewelryRepair.com starts at $105.
Does a jewelry floater have a deductible?
It can, so ask before you buy. Deductibles vary by insurer and policy, and the NAIC notes that an item's dollar value has the most influence on both the premium and the deductible. Ask whether the floater has its own deductible separate from your homeowners policy, whether a claim pays cash or a replacement through the insurer's jeweler, and what proof of value it requires.
Is my jewelry insured while it's shipped for repair?
It depends on your policy, so ask your insurer before you ship. Separately, every JewelryRepair.com order carries its own UPS coverage, with $100 included each way and full value insurable up to $10,000; the costs and conditions are set out in the section on coverage while a piece is out for repair, and in the shipping and insurance page.