Repair questions · Mail-in, shipping & insurance

Does jewelry insurance cover a lost diamond, a lost ring or a repair?

It depends on how the piece is insured. A scheduled ring is covered on an all-risks basis, which can include a lost ring or a stone that falls out. Unscheduled jewelry on a homeowners policy is covered only for listed perils, and wear is commonly excluded. Setting a replacement accent diamond starts at $20 in labor by mail.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$1,500typical jewelry theft limit on a standard homeowners policy (Insurance Information Institute)
$20setting labor for one small accent diamond in sterling silver ($5 + $15), plus the diamond
$105written insurance-replacement-value appraisal, from
50,000+repairs since 1989 at Sky Jewelry's New York studio

The short version

  • Coverage depends on how the piece is insured. IRMI, the insurance reference publisher, describes a personal articles floater as covering scheduled property on an all-risks basis; unscheduled jewelry on a homeowners or renters policy is covered only for listed perils such as fire and theft. The general rules are in how jewelry insurance works; this page is about what to do once something is lost.
  • Repairs for wear, such as re-tipping worn prongs or rebuilding a thin band, are upkeep, and insurers' descriptions of jewelry coverage commonly exclude wear and tear.
  • Before you repair or replace anything, call your insurer, then gather your appraisal, photos and an itemized repair quote.
  • JewelryRepair.com doesn't sell insurance or decide claims, but it can give you an itemized quote with photos to send your adjuster.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Diamond Setting from $20 one accent diamond, silverSetting labor: $5 per order plus $15 per side diamond or $60 per center diamond, plus metal and setting-style charges. The replacement diamond is matched and sourced for you and quoted separately for approval, or you supply it and pay labor only.
Gemstone Replacement from $23A lost colored stone matched and sourced; stone options come with a price for approval before anything is set.
Reset Loose Stone $89You found the stone: the seat is re-cut and the stone set back level.
Jewelry Appraisal from $105Written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, to update a scheduled value after a stone is replaced.
Mail-In Evaluation $19Every prong, stone and joint examined under magnification, with an itemized quote and photos you can send your insurer. Credited in full toward approved work.

Lost diamond, lost ring or repair: how each usually plays out

A diamond fell out of its setting. On scheduled coverage this is a common claim, and some insurers' descriptions of scheduled jewelry coverage name stones falling out or going missing as covered. On an unscheduled homeowners policy, a stone dropping out isn't fire or theft, so it may not be covered at all. Expect questions about upkeep: GIA notes that a loose diamond can wear through a prong over time. Jewelers Mutual adds that some policies require annual inspections to keep coverage in force.

The whole ring is gone. If it was stolen, the theft limit applies to unscheduled jewelry. If it's simply missing, with no sign of theft, insurers call that a mysterious disappearance, and whether it's covered is a question for your policy wording. Some scheduled coverage names disappearance explicitly. Report it promptly, with the date and place you last had it.

It needs a repair. Worn prongs, a thinned shank or sizing are maintenance, not a loss. Sudden damage, such as a prong snapped in a car door, is different: Jewelers Mutual notes that a standalone jewelry policy covers accidental damage, which an unscheduled homeowners policy may not.

Questions to ask your insurer before you file

  • Is this piece scheduled with its own listed value, or covered under my general personal property limit?
  • Is a mysterious disappearance covered, or only theft I can show?
  • Is a stone that falls out covered, and were there conditions I had to meet, such as regular inspections?
  • How is the claim valued: the scheduled amount, replacement cost, or actual cash value?
  • Do you pay cash, or arrange the replacement or repair? Can I use my own jeweler, and do you need a written estimate first?
  • What's my deductible? Setting one small accent diamond in 14K white gold is $57 in labor here ($5 + $15 + $33 + $4), plus the diamond, quoted for your approval; compare that total with your deductible before you file.

What to have ready for the claim

  • Your appraisal. Jewelers Mutual notes that the insurer refers to the appraisal to settle a claim, and that its description helps a jeweler replace the piece with one of the same kind and quality. If yours is years old, see how often jewelry should be reappraised.
  • Photos, receipts and any grading report, with the date and place of purchase; Triple-I notes that more information means a faster settlement.
  • The facts of the loss: when you noticed, where you'd been, and, for a theft, whether your insurer wants a police report.
  • An itemized quote with photos of the empty setting and the condition of the remaining prongs and stones.

Getting a quote for your insurer at JewelryRepair.com

JewelryRepair.com is a repair studio, the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue in New York, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. It isn't an insurer and can't tell you what your policy covers. What it can give you is paperwork an adjuster can use.

  • A free quote from photos: send them through the on-site chat or the contact page, and a jeweler replies with an itemized quote within 1 business day. Nothing ships until you've seen the price.
  • An in-hand examination: the Mail-In Evaluation, $19 and credited in full toward approved work, checks every prong, stone and joint under magnification and sends an itemized quote with photos. Approve all, some or none.
  • A record of the piece: every piece is photographed on arrival and again before it ships back, and the photos stay in your account with the order.
  • An updated value: if the ring is scheduled, a new Jewelry Appraisal (from $105) after the replacement keeps the listed value current. It isn't a lab grading report.

What replacing a lost diamond costs here

On Diamond Setting, the listed price is setting labor: $5 per order plus $15 per side diamond or $60 per center diamond, plus a metal charge and a setting-style charge (pavé +$5, channel +$10). The replacement diamond is matched to its neighbors and sourced for you, lab-grown among the options where they fit, and quoted separately; nothing is set until you approve. If you supply the diamond, you pay labor only.

  • One prong-set accent diamond in sterling silver: $20 in labor ($5 + $15), plus the diamond.
  • Two pavé halo diamonds in 14K white gold: $77 in labor ($5 + $30 + $5 + $33 + $4), plus the diamonds.
  • Center diamond, prong set, 14K yellow gold: $78 in labor ($5 + $60 + $9 + $4), plus the diamond. In platinum: $223 in labor ($5 + $60 + $158).
  • A lost colored stone: Gemstone Replacement, from $23, with stone options and a price sent for approval.
  • You found the stone: Reset Loose Stone, $89 flat.

The prongs that let one stone go are often worn on the others, so fix them in the same order: Prong Re-Tipping starts at $29 for 1 to 4 prongs in silver. For a ring that's going back on your policy, cover it in full on the way: shipping is $30 round trip by UPS with $100 of coverage each way, and covering a $2,500 ring costs $60 (2.5% of the $2,400 above $100), one fee for both directions. The stone replacement cost guide breaks down labor against stone cost.

Keeping the next stone in place

Jewelers Mutual recommends professional inspections and cleanings twice a year, and checks every three to four months for engagement rings worn daily. A loose stone caught early is a tightening, not a claim: Stone Tightening starts at $50, and The Anniversary Service ($199) is a yearly deep clean and magnified inspection with loose-stone tightening and condition photos included. If a stone already moves, see what to do if your diamond is loose, and for halo and pavé rings, why halo diamonds go missing.

Questions

What is mysterious disappearance in jewelry insurance?
It's an unexplained loss: the ring is gone and you can't say how, when or where, with no sign of theft. Whether it's covered depends on the policy wording. Some scheduled jewelry coverage names it explicitly, while a homeowners policy that covers listed perils such as theft may not. Report it promptly, with the date and place you last had the piece, and ask your insurer directly.
Will insurance pay for a diamond that fell out of my ring?
Scheduled coverage often will; an unscheduled homeowners policy often won't. A stone dropping out isn't a listed peril like fire or theft, while scheduled jewelry is covered on an all-risks basis, and some insurers name stones falling out as covered. Have the other prongs checked when the stone is replaced.
Does jewelry insurance pay cash or replace the ring?
It depends on the policy, so ask before you need to claim. Some policies pay to replace the piece with one of like kind and quality, and the appraisal on file is what the insurer uses to settle. Ask whether a claim is paid at the scheduled amount, replacement cost or actual cash value, which Triple-I defines as replacement cost minus depreciation, and whether you can choose the jeweler.
I lost the diamond from my engagement ring and have no insurance. What are my options?
Replace the stone, not the ring. If the setting is sound, a new diamond can go into the existing mounting: center-diamond setting labor at JewelryRepair.com is $65 in silver ($5 + $60) or $78 in 14K yellow gold, plus the diamond, which is quoted for your approval, with lab-grown options where they fit. If you supply the stone, you pay labor only.
Do I need a new appraisal after a lost stone is replaced?
If the ring is scheduled, yes, it's worth updating. A replacement diamond won't have exactly the same grades as the one you lost, and the value on your policy comes from the old appraisal. Tell your insurer what changed and send the new figure. A written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs at JewelryRepair.com starts at $105.