Replacing a lost stone has two costs: the stone itself and the labor to set it. The labor is the predictable half — with us, setting a small side diamond starts at $20 and a center stone at $65, with the exact price shown online before you ship. The stone is the variable half, and an honest jeweler quotes it in writing before touching your piece.
This guide separates those two numbers, because most of the confusion (and most of the unpleasant surprises at local counters) comes from mixing them together.
Setting labor: the fixed, knowable part
Setting labor depends on three things: the stone's size class, the metal, and the setting style. Here is our 2026 pricing, straight from the same configurator you would use at checkout:
| Job | Per-stone labor | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Side / melee diamond (under 0.5ct) | $15 each | Plus $5 base and metal charge — from $20 all-in for silver |
| Center diamond (0.5–1ct) | $60 each | From $65 all-in for silver; larger stones quoted with options |
| Side colored gemstone | $18 each | From $23 all-in for silver |
| Center colored gemstone (0.5–1ct) | $70 each | From $75 all-in for silver |
Metal and setting style adjust that base. A few realistic examples, priced exactly as our configurator does:
- One melee diamond, prong-set in a sterling silver band: $20
- One melee diamond, prong-set in 14K white gold: $57
- Center diamond (0.5–1ct), prong-set in 14K yellow gold: $78
- Side sapphire, channel-set in 14K yellow gold: $49
- Center gemstone, bezel-set in platinum: $273 (platinum work runs hot and demands its own solders and skill — every bench charges accordingly)
Pavé, channel, bezel, flush, and invisible settings each add a modest style charge ($5–$40) because they require more metal manipulation than a simple prong seat. None of it is quoted after the fact: the configurator shows the number before checkout, and that number is the number.
Diamond replacement & setting — side stones from $20 →
Gemstone replacement & setting — from $23 per stone →
The stone itself: the variable part
Here is the honest framing most price lists skip: for small stones, labor usually costs more than the stone; for center stones, the stone usually costs more than the labor.
Melee and small side stones
Melee diamonds — the small accent stones under roughly 0.10 carat — are cut and traded in volume, and a single replacement is typically an inexpensive line item relative to the labor. The skill is in the match, not the purchase: your replacement must agree with its neighbors in millimeter size, color, and cut style, or it will read as a visibly "new tooth" in the row.
Center stones
Center stone prices scale steeply and non-linearly with carat weight, and for colored gems they swing further on origin and treatment. No honest jeweler quotes a center stone sight-unseen from a web form. Our process: you tell the configurator "source it for me," we assess the piece and your old stone's specs (from photos, remaining stones, appraisals, or the setting's dimensions), and we send you specific stone options with published prices — including lab-grown where it fits, which can cut the stone cost dramatically for diamonds. You approve a stone before we set anything. If you already have the stone, you pay labor only.
Lab-grown, natural, or something else: your real options
Replacing a stone is also a decision point, and it deserves a candid rundown of the choices:
- Natural diamond, matched. The default for keeping a piece exactly what it was. For melee, the premium over lab-grown is small in absolute dollars; for center stones it is substantial.
- Lab-grown diamond. Chemically and optically identical to natural, at a much lower price for the same size and grade — often the difference between replacing a center stone and not. The honest caveats: lab-grown resale values are lower and still moving, and if the piece is insured or appraised as natural, the documentation must be updated. In a row of melee, a lab-grown stone is visually indistinguishable.
- A colored gemstone stand-in. Some owners replace a lost accent diamond with a birthstone or sapphire on purpose. Setting labor is nearly the same ($18 per side stone); it changes the piece's story rather than restoring it, which is sometimes exactly the point.
- Not replacing yet. Legitimate too — but have the empty seat's neighbors checked and tightened first, because the same worn prongs that lost one stone are holding the rest.
Whichever direction you choose, the rule stands: you see the stone options and their exact prices in writing, and nothing is set until you approve one.
Matching color and cut: what "we'll match it" should mean
Ask any jeweler — including us — these questions before you hand over a piece:
- How will you match size? The answer should involve measuring the empty seat and the neighboring stones in millimeters, not eyeballing carats.
- How will you match color? Melee should be matched against the row under a grading light; a replacement two color grades whiter than its neighbors is a common and avoidable mistake.
- What about older cuts? Old European cuts, single cuts, and rose cuts in vintage pieces should be replaced in kind. Dropping a modern brilliant into an antique cluster looks wrong and hurts the piece's character and value. In-kind sourcing takes longer; a jeweler who does not mention this is planning to use a modern stone.
Fix the cause, not just the gap
A stone rarely falls out of a healthy setting. The usual culprit is prong tips worn thin over years, or one hard snag on a sweater. That has two practical implications. First, the empty seat often needs prong work before it can hold a new stone — prong re-tipping starts at $29 and is frequently part of the same job. Second, if one stone left, its siblings are probably loose. We check every stone under magnification as part of any replacement; as a standalone service, a full check-and-tighten starts at $50.
Stone check & tightening — from $50 →
When not to mail it (yet)
Two cases where the right move is to wait. If the piece is scheduled on an insurance policy, call the insurer before authorizing any repair — many policies cover lost stones, and some require their own documentation or estimate first; repairing first can complicate the claim. And if the piece is under a retailer's service plan or warranty, third-party work may void it; check the terms. Neither situation is rare, and a repair service that wants your long-term trust should say so up front.
How the mail-in process works
Configure the repair online and see the firm labor price before checkout. Your prepaid UPS label is ready in your account within minutes — two-way shipping is $30, with $100 of coverage included and full-value coverage available at 2.5%. Your piece is photographed on arrival and the photos shared with you; if the stone needs sourcing, you approve the stone and its price in writing before any setting work. The finished piece ships back insured, signature required, covered by a 1-year workmanship guarantee on the setting work. If you are not sure what your piece needs, a mail-in evaluation is $19 and the finding comes back with photos.
Worried about sending a diamond piece to a stranger at all? That fear deserves a straight answer, not a brush-off — we wrote Will a jeweler swap my diamond? to give it one.