Jewelry repair questions · Engraving & appraisals

How often should jewelry be reappraised for insurance?

Every two years is what Jewelers Mutual recommends; go sooner after a stone change or a big price move, and if you're adding a piece to a policy, check its age rule: one insurer cited by Progressive wants an appraisal no more than 12 months old when coverage starts. JewelryRepair.com appraisals by mail start at $105, examined in hand.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

2 yearshow often Jewelers Mutual recommends an updated appraisal
12 monthsthe oldest appraisal Lavalier accepts when coverage starts on a piece worth $5,000 or more (as cited by Progressive)
$105Jewelry Appraisal by mail; Watch Appraisal from $115
50,000+repairs since 1989 by the family behind JewelryRepair.com

The short version

  • Your policy comes first. The NAIC notes that some policies require periodic appraisal, and Progressive cites an insurer that won't accept an appraisal more than 12 months old when coverage starts on a piece worth $5,000 or more.
  • No rule in your policy? Jewelers Mutual, a jewelry insurer, strongly recommends an updated appraisal every two years.
  • Sooner after a change to the piece (a replaced or added stone, a new mounting) or a big price move in its metal or stones.
  • An inspection isn't an appraisal. Inspections keep stones in their settings; appraisals keep the insured value right.
  • Price here: Jewelry Appraisal from $105 and Watch Appraisal from $115, examined in hand.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Appraisal from $105A written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, from the piece in hand: stones measured in their settings and weights calculated, color and clarity assessed, metal tested and stamps verified, condition documented. Stone origin +$20, treatment check +$20, rush +$50.
Watch Appraisal from $115Brand, model and reference, case metal and condition, bracelet, dial and movement type, with serial and reference numbers recorded where accessible without invasive disassembly. $130 for Omega or Cartier ($115 + $15), $315 for Rolex ($115 + $200).
The Anniversary Service $199An inspection, not an appraisal: a yearly deep clean and magnified inspection of an engagement ring, loose-stone tightening, re-rhodium on white gold and condition photos.
Metal Testing & Verification $15When you only need the metal and karat documented, not a value.

What insurers and trade groups actually recommend

There's no single industry interval, because each source answers a slightly different question.

  • Jewelers Mutual recommends an updated appraisal every two years, on top of professional inspections twice a year. It also says most of its customers can start coverage without an appraisal, but need one, or other adequate documentation, at the time of a claim.
  • The American Gem Society published a 2013 article, written by Jessica VandenHouten of Jewelers Mutual, tying yearly re-evaluations to avoiding being underinsured.
  • Progressive says every few years, noting that your insurer may set its own schedule. It cites Lavalier, which requires an appraisal for jewelry worth $5,000 or more and wants it no more than 12 months old when coverage starts; under $5,000, a detailed receipt can do.
  • The NAIC, the association of state insurance regulators, says insurers often require an appraisal, that some policies require periodic appraisal, and that an item's value has the most influence on your premium and deductible.

The practical reading: the strictest rule that applies to you wins. Otherwise two years is a sensible default for scheduled pieces, and yearly suits a high-value piece whose metal or stones swing in price.

Why an appraisal goes out of date

An insurance appraisal states what it would cost to replace the piece at retail on one date. Three things move that number.

  • Metal prices. Wikipedia's article on gold as an investment records gold rising above $4,000 per troy ounce for the first time in October 2025. At that price pure gold is about $128.60 a gram ($4,000 ÷ 31.1035), so each gram of 14K gold, which is 14/24 gold, holds about $75 of it. Heavy chains, bangles and signet rings feel those swings most.
  • Stone prices, in both directions. Heirlooms can gain value, the NAIC notes, while JCK reported in November 2026 that midstream wholesale prices for lab-grown diamonds of 1 carat and up fell 13% during 2025, and 3-carat stones 47%. See can a lab-grown diamond be appraised?
  • The piece itself. Prongs wear, stones chip or get replaced, and the description an insurer replaces from goes out of date.

Too low and you may pay out of pocket after a loss, as the American Gem Society warns; too high and you may pay premiums on a figure a claim won't return. Progressive notes that some insurers apply an insurance value adjustment when you don't reappraise, so ask how yours settles a claim.

Reappraise sooner if any of these happen

  • A stone was replaced, added or reset, or the piece was redesigned.
  • The piece changed hands. An inherited ring often comes with an appraisal in someone else's name, and the appraisal details Progressive lists include the owner's name and address.
  • You're adding it to a policy or switching insurers, and the insurer has an age limit.
  • Your only appraisal came with the purchase. Jewelers Mutual advises checking that an appraiser has gemological and appraisal training and that the fee isn't a percentage of the value.

Routine upkeep, such as cleaning, tightening a stone or re-tipping prongs, leaves the piece as described. For a first appraisal, see do I need an appraisal to insure my ring?

What a reappraisal involves

An update is a fresh examination, not a new date on old paperwork. At JewelryRepair.com the appraiser examines the piece in hand, never from photos: stones measured in their settings and weights calculated, color and clarity assessed, metal tested and stamps verified, condition documented, then a written replacement-value appraisal with photographs.

  • Send copies of the old appraisal and any grading report; see is an appraisal the same as a GIA report?
  • Afterward, send the new appraisal to your insurer and ask it to adjust your coverage, as the AGS article advises.
  • Store photos of each piece and a copy of the appraisal in a safe place, as the NAIC recommends.

What a piece would sell for is a different number: is an appraisal what jewelry would sell for?

Between appraisals: inspections

Jewelers Mutual recommends professional inspections twice a year, every three to four months for high-end pieces worn daily, and notes some policies require annual inspections. More in how often should an engagement ring be checked and cleaned?

  • The Anniversary Service, $199: a yearly deep clean and magnified inspection of an engagement ring, with loose-stone tightening, re-rhodium on white gold and condition photos.
  • Jewelry Spa: a clean with a written inspection report, $59 for a 14K yellow gold ring ($44 + $10 + $5).
  • Something looks wrong? The $19 Mail-In Evaluation is credited in full toward any repair.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

Prices from the live appraisal pages, Nov 18, 2026.

  • Jewelry Appraisal: $105 for a ring, pendant, necklace, bracelet or loose stone; stone origin or a treatment check adds $20 each; rush adds $50.
  • Watch Appraisal: $115 for most brands; $130 for Omega or Cartier ($115 + $15); $315 for Rolex ($115 + $200). JewelryRepair.com is an independent service, not affiliated with, authorized by or endorsed by any watch brand.
  • Spread over time: updating one ring every two years works out to $67.50 a year with shipping (($105 + $30) ÷ 2).
  • Several pieces at once: three appraisals in one box are $345 with shipping (3 × $105 + $30).

Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, US addresses only, with the prepaid label in your account. $100 of coverage is included each way; full value up to $10,000 costs 2.5% of the value above $100 for both directions, so a $5,000 ring is $122.50 (2.5% of $4,900). Appraisals are done at Sky Jewelry's New York studio; the family, jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, has over 50,000 repairs since 1989 behind it.

Questions

Do I need to get my jewelry reappraised every year?
Only if your policy requires it; check its terms first. Some insurers set an age limit when coverage starts: Progressive cites Lavalier, which wants an appraisal no more than 12 months old when you insure a piece worth $5,000 or more. That is a rule for starting coverage, not a yearly reappraisal. Otherwise, Jewelers Mutual recommends an updated appraisal every two years. Your policy's valuables section, or your agent, will say which applies.
Is the appraisal from when I bought my ring still good?
Possibly not, if it's more than two years old or came from the seller. Replacement cost moves: gold passed $4,000 a troy ounce for the first time in October 2025, and lab-grown diamond wholesale prices fell sharply in 2025, so an old figure can be too low or too high. A fresh in-hand appraisal at JewelryRepair.com is $105, plus $30 round-trip shipping per order.
Should I get jewelry reappraised after a repair?
Only if the repair changed what the appraisal describes. Cleaning, tightening stones and re-tipping prongs leave the piece as described. A replaced or added stone, a new mounting or a redesign doesn't, so update the appraisal to match what you now own. At JewelryRepair.com, an appraisal booked in the same order as the repair travels in the same box, under one $30 round trip.
How often should a watch be reappraised?
On the same schedule as jewelry: your insurer's rule first, otherwise about every two years, as Jewelers Mutual recommends. A watch appraisal records the brand, model, reference, case and condition on one date, so a replaced bracelet or a change in condition is also a reason to update it. Watch Appraisal at JewelryRepair.com starts at $115 for most brands.
Can an old appraisal be updated from photos?
Not at JewelryRepair.com. Every piece is examined in hand, because an update has to confirm that the stones, metal and condition still match the document, and a chip, a worn prong or a replaced stone may not show in a picture. Ship it with the prepaid UPS label from your account; $100 of coverage is included each way.