Jewelry repair questions · Engraving & appraisals

How much does a jewelry or watch appraisal cost?

At JewelryRepair.com, a written insurance-replacement-value appraisal costs $105 for a piece of jewelry and from $115 for a watch, plus $30 round-trip shipping; stone origin or treatment checks add $20 each. Progressive's guide, citing The Knot, puts typical appraisals at $75 to $150. Look for a flat fee per item; the IRS bars percentage-of-value fees for donation appraisals.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$105Jewelry Appraisal, any item type
$115Watch Appraisal, most brands
about $1,500typical jewelry theft limit on a standard homeowners policy (Insurance Information Institute)
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • Here: a Jewelry Appraisal is $105 for any item type, a Watch Appraisal is $115 for most brands, and shipping is $30 round trip per order. Optional stone checks are $20 each.
  • Elsewhere: Progressive's guide to insuring jewelry, citing The Knot, says an appraisal may cost anywhere from $75 to $150, varying with the appraiser, the item and other factors.
  • The fee should follow the work, never the value. For donation appraisals, the IRS says that generally no part of the fee can be based on a percentage of the appraised value.
  • Why people pay for one: the Insurance Information Institute says a standard homeowners policy generally limits jewelry theft to about $1,500, and items must be professionally appraised before a floater is bought.
  • What it isn't: a lab grading report, or an offer to buy. JewelryRepair.com doesn't buy jewelry, so it has no stake in the number.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Appraisal from $105Written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, examined in hand: stones measured in their settings and weights calculated, color and clarity assessed, metal tested and marks verified, construction and condition documented. Stone origin +$20, treatment check +$20, rush +$50.
Watch Appraisal from $115Brand, model and reference, case metal and condition, bracelet, dial and movement type recorded, with serial and reference numbers where readable without invasive disassembly. $130 for Omega, Cartier and other $15-surcharge brands, $135 Longines, $215 Patek Philippe, $315 Rolex. No rush.
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks examined and the metal and karat tested and documented, for when you need to know what a piece is made of rather than what it's worth.

What the fee pays for

An insurance appraisal is a written description precise enough for an insurer, or a jeweler making a replacement, to identify the piece and price it. At JewelryRepair.com the appraiser examines the piece in hand, not from photos:

  • Stones are measured in their settings and their weights calculated from those measurements, since a set stone can't be weighed without taking it out.
  • Color and clarity are assessed under proper lighting.
  • The metal is tested and stamped marks are verified.
  • Construction and condition are documented and photographed.
  • The appraiser researches what it would cost to replace the piece at retail today and signs a photographed document in the format insurers use to schedule coverage.

For a watch, the appraisal records brand, model and reference, case metal and condition, bracelet, dial and movement type, with serial and reference numbers where they can be read without invasive disassembly.

Progressive's guide quotes one insurer's checklist (Lavalier's) of what an appraisal must include: your name and address, the appraiser's name and address, a description with weight, carat, stone types and any serial or model numbers, the estimated replacement cost, the appraiser's signature and printed name, and the date; insurers may also want photos. Your own insurer's list may differ, but a document with all of these will usually serve.

How appraisal fees are charged, and the one to avoid

Appraisers price their work in different ways, and Progressive notes that the cost varies with the appraiser and the item. What matters is what the fee is tied to. A flat fee per item, like the $105 here, is the same whether the ring is worth $800 or $8,000, so the appraiser gains nothing by pushing the number up. A fee calculated as a percentage of the value does the opposite. For donation appraisals the IRS treats it as disqualifying: generally, no part of the fee for a qualified appraisal can be based on a percentage of the appraised value, and an appraiser paid that way can't be the qualified appraiser for that property.

Before you book anywhere, ask:

  • Is the price per piece, and what counts as a piece?
  • Are stone origin or treatment checks extra, and does my insurer need them?
  • Will I get a signed, written appraisal with photographs, stating replacement value?
  • Is the piece examined in hand, or valued from photos?
  • Does the appraiser also buy jewelry? Someone who might bid on the piece has a stake in the number.

JewelryRepair.com doesn't buy jewelry and isn't a pawn service, so the appraisal is the whole transaction.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com, worked out

Prices from the live service pages, Nov 18, 2026. Shipping is $30 per order however many pieces are in the box; $100 of coverage is included each way, and full value up to $10,000 costs 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions.

  • One ring you believe is worth $5,000: $105 appraisal + $30 shipping + $122.50 to cover its full value (2.5% of $4,900) = $257.50. Add a treatment check and it is $277.50.
  • Three pieces in one box, worth $6,000 together: booked as three appraisals at $105, that is $315, plus $30 shipping and $147.50 of coverage (2.5% of $5,900), for $492.50 in all.
  • A watch: $115 for most brands; $130 for Bvlgari, Cartier, Concord, Ebel, Elgin, Gucci, Movado, Omega and Rado; $135 for Longines; $215 for Patek Philippe; $315 for Rolex. A Rolex worth $10,000 comes to $315 + $30 + $247.50 of coverage (2.5% of $9,900) = $592.50. Over $10,000, contact the studio before shipping.
  • Stone checks: determining a stone's geographic origin is $20, and whether it has been treated is $20; both details can change value.
  • Rush: $50 on a jewelry appraisal if your insurer is waiting; watch appraisals aren't rushed.
  • Already sending a ring for work? Add the $105 Jewelry Appraisal to the same order: it travels in the same box under one $30 shipping charge.

How often you'll pay for one

An appraisal is a snapshot of replacement cost on one date, and metal and stone prices move. Guidance on updating varies:

  • The American Gem Society, in a 2013 article, advises yearly inspections and re-evaluations so you aren't underinsured.
  • Progressive's guide says to have jewelry appraised every few years, and notes that insurers may set their own timing; one insurer it cites requires appraisals no more than 12 months old.
  • The NAIC says some policies may require periodic appraisal, and suggests keeping photos of each item and a copy of the appraisal with your home inventory.

The schedule in your own policy wins. More in how often should jewelry be reappraised?

When you don't need a full appraisal

  • You only need to know the metal. Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item: hallmarks checked, metal and karat tested and documented.
  • Your insurer only wants a receipt. In Progressive's guide, the insurer it cites requires an appraisal for items worth $5,000 or more and, below that, a receipt detailing the metal, the stones and their carat weight and quality. Ask yours before paying for an appraisal.
  • You want to know what it would sell for. An insurance appraisal states retail replacement value, which is a different figure from what a buyer would pay you. Fair market value, as the IRS defines it, is the price on the open market. See is an appraisal what jewelry would sell for?
  • You want a stone graded. A lab grading report describes a diamond's quality, and GIA states that a report does not indicate a diamond's monetary value; an appraisal is an estimate of worth. An appraisal here isn't a lab report or a GIA certificate, so if you have a report, send a copy with the piece. See is an appraisal the same as a GIA report?

JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989 with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. Pieces travel by UPS in a plain box with nothing on the outside naming the contents and a signature both ways, and are photographed on arrival at 354 Lenox Avenue (Malcolm X Blvd), New York, NY 10027, and again before they ship back. The service is independent, not affiliated with any jewelry or watch brand or with GIA.

Questions

How much does it cost to get a ring appraised?
$105 at JewelryRepair.com for a written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, whether the ring is a plain band or a diamond solitaire, plus $30 round-trip UPS shipping. Checks for a stone's geographic origin or treatment are $20 each. Already sending the ring for sizing? Add the $105 Jewelry Appraisal to the same order, and it travels in the same box under one $30 shipping charge.
How much does a watch appraisal cost?
$115 for most brands at JewelryRepair.com: $130 for Omega, Cartier and other brands with the $15 surcharge, $135 for Longines, $215 for Patek Philippe and $315 for Rolex. The appraiser records brand, model and reference, case metal, dial, movement type and serial numbers where they can be read without invasive disassembly. Shipping is $30 round trip per order.
Is it worth paying for a jewelry appraisal?
It is when a piece is worth more than your policy's jewelry limit. The Insurance Information Institute says a standard homeowners policy generally caps jewelry theft at about $1,500, and items must be professionally appraised before you can schedule them on a floater. For $105 at JewelryRepair.com, a ring worth several thousand dollars gets a written replacement value your insurer can schedule.
Do diamond appraisals cost more than other jewelry appraisals?
Not here: the Jewelry Appraisal at JewelryRepair.com is $105 for a diamond ring, a pendant, a bracelet or a loose stone. Extra charges come only from optional checks: $20 to determine a stone's geographic origin and $20 to determine whether it has been treated. Elsewhere, ask before booking; a fee that climbs with the stone's value is a red flag.
Why shouldn't an appraiser charge a percentage of the value?
Because it pays the appraiser more for a higher number. For donation appraisals, the IRS says that generally no part of a qualified appraisal's fee can be based on a percentage of the appraised value, and an appraiser paid that way can't serve as the qualified appraiser. A flat fee per item, like $105 at JewelryRepair.com, keeps the appraiser's pay independent of the result.
Can I get a jewelry appraisal online from photos?
Not here: at JewelryRepair.com the appraiser examines the piece in hand, because the figures an insurer relies on can't be read from a picture. Stones are measured in their settings and their weights calculated, color and clarity are judged under proper lighting, and the metal is tested and its marks verified. You mail the piece with a prepaid UPS label ($30 round trip), and the $105 appraisal comes back with photographs.