Jewelry repair questions · Engraving & appraisals

Is a jewelry appraisal the same as a GIA grading report?

No. A GIA grading report describes a diamond's quality: its measurements, carat weight, color, clarity and cut, with no dollar value. An appraisal states what the piece is worth, usually its insurance replacement value. GIA says it doesn't appraise. JewelryRepair.com's written appraisals start at $105 and aren't GIA reports.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$105Jewelry Appraisal, any item type
$145appraisal with stone origin and treatment checks ($105 + $20 + $20)
about $1,500typical homeowners theft limit for jewelry (Insurance Information Institute)
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • A grading report describes a stone. A gem lab issues it, recording the stone's identifying characteristics, measurements, carat weight, color, clarity, cut and any known treatments.
  • An appraisal puts a dollar value on a piece, usually what it would cost to replace, for insurance.
  • GIA doesn't appraise. Its own FAQ says it "does not certify or appraise any material submitted for analysis," and no appraisal value is stated on its reports.
  • "GIA certificate" is a nickname. GIA calls its documents reports, not certificates.
  • They work together. Appraisers often use a GIA report's grades when they assign a value, so send a copy of yours with the piece.
  • For insurance, you need the appraisal. Scheduling a ring on a policy generally requires one; a report supports it.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Appraisal from $105Written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, from the piece in hand, for an unmounted stone, ring, pendant, necklace, bracelet or other piece at the same base price. Determine stone origin +$20, determine if the stone is treated +$20, rush +$50. Not a lab grading report or GIA certificate.
Watch Appraisal from $115Written insurance-replacement-value appraisal of a watch with photographs; some brands carry a brand charge, shown before checkout. No rush option.
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked and the metal and karat tested and documented, when you need to know what a piece is made of rather than what it's worth.

What each document tells you

A GIA grading report is, in GIA's words, a blueprint of the diamond: its shape and measurements, carat weight, color, clarity and cut, proportions, finish and any known treatments, and its identifying characteristics. GIA describes it as an unbiased, scientifically based assessment, and is explicit that it does not indicate a diamond's monetary value. Because the grades describe the stone itself, a report stays a useful record unless the stone is damaged or recut.

An appraisal is a written opinion of value for a stated purpose. An insurance appraisal estimates what it would cost to replace the whole piece at retail: the stones, the metal, the setting and the workmanship. To do that, it documents what it's valuing. In a JewelryRepair.com appraisal, the stones are measured in their settings and their weights calculated, color and clarity are assessed under proper lighting, the metal is tested and stamped marks verified, and construction and condition are recorded. Because prices move, an appraisal goes out of date; the American Gem Society recommends yearly inspections and re-evaluations so you aren't underinsured.

Which one do you need?

  • Insuring a ring or adding it to a policy: an appraisal. The Insurance Information Institute notes that a standard homeowners policy has a relatively low limit for jewelry theft, generally about $1,500, and that items scheduled on a floater must be professionally appraised first. A GIA report strengthens the appraisal; it doesn't replace it. See do I need an appraisal to insure my ring?
  • Buying a loose diamond or confirming what you own: a grading report, which identifies the stone and grades it independently of whoever is selling it.
  • You have a report but no value: an appraisal that uses the report. Send a copy and keep the original.
  • Selling: neither document is a price offer. GIA's 4Cs blog notes that an appraisal doesn't guarantee a price that can be fetched on the market; see is an appraisal what jewelry would sell for?
  • Before a repair: either one documents the stone, and a laser-inscribed report number lets you check it's the same diamond afterward. Our guide will a jeweler swap my diamond? shows how to read one with a 10x loupe.

Why people search for a "GIA appraisal"

The phrase blends two documents that often travel together. A diamond sold with a GIA report and later appraised for insurance ends up with both in the same envelope, and it's natural to call the pair a GIA appraisal. Strictly, there's no such thing: GIA grades, appraisers value. What you can get is an appraisal that relies on GIA's grades, which is often the most dependable kind; GIA's 4Cs blog says most appraisers and insurance agencies regard its reports as the most accurate and highly regarded documents of diamond quality.

When there's no report, the appraiser grades the stone in hand. In a mounted ring that means measuring the stone in its setting and calculating its weight, rather than weighing it loose, so the appraisal records an estimate where a lab report would record a measured weight. That's normal and fine for insurance, and it's one more reason to send a copy of any report you have. If you're not sure your stone is a diamond at all, start with how can I tell if my diamond is real?

What a JewelryRepair.com appraisal is, and isn't

JewelryRepair.com's Jewelry Appraisal is a written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, prepared from the piece in hand, not from photos. It's $105 whether the piece is an unmounted stone, a ring, a pendant, a necklace, a bracelet or something else. Two add-ons answer questions a value alone doesn't: determine stone origin (+$20) and determine if the stone is treated (+$20), so an appraisal with both is $145 ($105 + $20 + $20). Rush is $50. Watches have their own Watch Appraisal, from $115.

What it isn't: a lab grading report or a GIA certificate, and it isn't a buying or pawn service. JewelryRepair.com isn't affiliated with GIA and doesn't issue GIA reports. If your stone has a report from GIA or any other lab, send a copy with the piece. JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry in New York, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

Before you ship

  • Copies, not originals. Put a copy of any grading report or earlier appraisal in the box and keep the originals at home. If the stone carries a laser-inscribed report number, mention it in your order notes so it can be checked against the report.
  • Mention any repair it needs. An appraisal records construction and condition as they are, so if the piece also needs work, say so in your order notes.
  • Cover the full value. $100 is included each way; full value is 2.5% of the value above $100, so $122.50 for a $5,000 ring, up to $10,000 per package. Above $10,000, contact the studio before shipping. How shipping insurance works has the details.
  • Ship it plain with the prepaid UPS label in your account. The piece is photographed on arrival at our New York studio and again before it ships back. US addresses only.

Questions

Does GIA do appraisals?
No. GIA's own FAQ says it does not certify or appraise any material submitted for analysis, and its reports state no appraisal value. GIA analyzes and grades stones; appraisers put values on them. For a dollar figure you need an appraisal, which may use your GIA report's grades. At JewelryRepair.com, a written insurance appraisal starts at $105, and it is not a GIA report.
Is a GIA certificate the same as a GIA report?
Yes, it's the same document under a different name. GIA calls its documents reports, not certificates, and its 4Cs blog notes that a report is not a certificate or a guarantee. People say certificate out of habit. Whatever you call it, it describes the stone's quality and states no monetary value, so it doesn't replace an insurance appraisal.
Can I insure my ring with just a GIA report?
Usually not on its own. A report describes the diamond but gives no dollar value, and the Insurance Information Institute says items scheduled on a jewelry floater must be professionally appraised first. Insurers set their own rules, so ask yours, but most will want an appraisal, and a GIA report makes that appraisal stronger. JewelryRepair.com appraisals start at $105.
Does a GIA report go out of date?
Not the way an appraisal does. A report records the stone's grades, measurements and identifying features, which don't change unless the stone is chipped or recut. An appraisal's value does change with prices, which is why the American Gem Society recommends yearly re-evaluations. Keep the report for good, and update the appraisal as prices move so your coverage keeps up.
How much does a GIA appraisal cost?
GIA doesn't do appraisals, so there's no GIA appraisal fee; GIA charges for grading reports, and an insurance appraisal is a separate document from an appraiser. At JewelryRepair.com, a written insurance appraisal is $105 for any piece, or $145 with stone origin and treatment checks ($105 + $20 + $20), plus $30 round-trip UPS shipping. Send a copy of your GIA report with the piece so the appraisal can use its grades.
Is an appraisal what my jewelry would sell for?
No. An insurance appraisal estimates what it would cost to replace a piece at retail, and GIA's 4Cs blog notes that an appraisal doesn't guarantee a price that can be fetched on the market. What a buyer will pay is a different figure, set by that buyer. JewelryRepair.com appraises for insurance and doesn't buy jewelry or make offers on it.