Jewelry repair questions · Engraving & appraisals
How can I tell if my diamond is real?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Home tests can rule some fakes out, not prove a diamond in. Glass and cubic zirconia often fail them; moissanite passes most of the same tests a diamond does.
- "Real" hides two questions: is it diamond at all, and is it natural or lab-grown? A lab-grown diamond has the same crystal structure as a mined one, and GIA says the difference can potentially be indistinguishable by eye.
- Basic testers have limits. A thermal tester rejects most look-alikes, but older probes can be fooled by moissanite, and none tells natural from lab-grown.
- Paperwork is the best evidence: a grading report, and any laser inscription on the stone's edge that matches it.
- For an answer you can use, have it examined in hand. A written Jewelry Appraisal here starts at $105.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Jewelry Appraisal | from $105 | Examined in hand, never from photos: stones measured in their settings and weights calculated, color and clarity assessed under proper lighting, the metal tested and stamps verified, condition documented, and a written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs. Optional origin and treatment add-ons (+$20 each): what they can establish for your stone is confirmed before ordering, and they are not a lab test of natural versus lab-grown. Not a lab grading report. |
| Metal Testing & Verification | $15 | When the question is the metal, not the stone: hallmarks and karat stamps checked under magnification, the metal tested and the result documented. |
Why the popular home tests don't settle it
Every common test leans on one of diamond's properties. The FTC's jewelry guides define diamond as essentially pure carbon with a hardness of 10, a specific gravity of about 3.52 and a refractive index of 2.42. The best look-alikes share enough of those numbers to pass.
- The fog test. Breathe on the stone: diamond spreads heat so fast that the fog is meant to clear almost at once. Moissanite has a thermal conductivity similar to diamond's, so it clears too, while grease on a real diamond makes fog linger. Cubic zirconia and glass are thermal insulators, so the test can flag them, but it can't prove a diamond.
- The water test. A diamond sinks because its specific gravity is 3.52. So do cubic zirconia (5.6 to 6) and moissanite (about 3.2). Sinking proves nothing.
- The read-through test. Lay a loose stone face-down on print: a well-cut round diamond bends light so strongly that the letters shouldn't show through. Moissanite's refractive index, about 2.65, is higher than diamond's, so it can pass too. It also only works on a loose, round, well-proportioned stone.
- The scratch test. Scraping a stone across glass is, in Wikipedia's words, a potentially destructive test. Cubic zirconia (8 to 8.5), white sapphire (9) and moissanite all scratch glass, and GIA notes a hard blow can still cleave a real diamond. Don't do it.
- The sparkle test. Lots of rainbow flash can point to a simulant: moissanite's dispersion is 0.104 and cubic zirconia's 0.058 to 0.066, against diamond's 0.044, and GIA notes moissanite has more than twice the fire of diamond. Lighting and cut change what you see, so it's a hint, not a verdict.
Clues worth checking, and what they can't tell you
- Look for doubling with a 10x loupe. Moissanite is doubly refractive, and GIA's 1997 Gems & Gemology study describes the result as a doubling in the appearance of facet junctions. Look at an angle through the side or crown facets toward the pavilion facet junctions, not straight down through the table: moissanite is often cut so that little or no doubling shows face-up. Diamond doesn't show this doubling, but seeing none face-up doesn't rule out moissanite.
- Look for an inscription. GIA laser-inscribes the girdle, the thin outer edge, of each lab-grown diamond it grades with the report number, which you can match against the report.
- Too perfect? GIA notes most cubic zirconia is colorless with high clarity, often with few or no visible imperfections, and that it can yellow over time.
- Weigh a loose stone. A cubic zirconia weighs about 1.7 times as much as a diamond of the same size, so a stone far heavier than its stated carat weight isn't diamond.
- Read the paperwork. A grading report, an appraisal or a receipt naming the stone is better evidence than any home test.
- Stamps describe the metal. A 14K or 585 mark inside the band is a claim about the gold, not the stone, and stamps can be wrong too.
What a handheld diamond tester can and can't do
The common pen testers measure how fast a stone conducts heat. Most simulants are thermal insulators, so the tester rejects cubic zirconia and glass. The exception is moissanite, which conducts heat much like diamond: GIA's 1997 study of synthetic moissanite found that the thermal probes then on the market reacted to it as if it were diamond. Wikipedia's article on diamond simulants notes that newer testers that also measure electrical conductivity can usually tell the two apart, though they are not infallible.
No handheld tester answers the origin question. A lab-grown diamond is diamond, so it tests as diamond. GIA says separating natural from lab-grown relies on specially developed screening equipment and advanced testing at gem labs. A pen tester's beep is not proof that a stone is natural. More in can a jeweler tell if a diamond is lab-grown?
Natural, lab-grown or simulant: what the words mean
- Natural diamond: mined, formed in the earth.
- Lab-grown diamond: real diamond with the same crystal structure as a mined one, grown in a lab. Under the FTC's guides it must be sold with a clear qualifier such as laboratory-grown, laboratory-created or [manufacturer name]-created. See lab-grown diamond.
- Simulant: a different material made to look like diamond. GIA says simulants such as glass, moissanite and cubic zirconia are completely unrelated to diamond at the atomic level. See moissanite and cubic zirconia.
- Treated diamond: a diamond whose color or clarity has been altered. GIA examines every diamond it reports on to determine whether it is natural, treated or laboratory-grown.
Each is a legitimate stone when it's sold for what it is. What matters is that you, and your insurer, know which one you own.
Getting a real answer at JewelryRepair.com
A Jewelry Appraisal is done in hand at our New York studio, never from photos: stones are measured in their settings and their weights calculated, color and clarity are assessed under proper lighting, the metal is tested and its stamps verified, and construction and condition are documented with photographs. The result is a written insurance-replacement-value appraisal describing what you own.
- Appraisal: $105, the same for a ring, pendant, necklace, bracelet or unmounted stone.
- Add-ons: the appraisal page lists optional origin and treatment add-ons; ask through the contact page what they can establish for your stone before ordering. Rush adds $50.
- The metal only: Metal Testing & Verification, $15 per item.
An appraisal is not a lab grading report or a GIA certificate; if you need to prove natural versus lab-grown, a gem lab report is the document built for that. See is an appraisal the same as a GIA report? JewelryRepair.com doesn't buy jewelry or make offers, and isn't affiliated with GIA or any gem lab.
If it isn't what you thought:
- Keep it and insure it for what it is. An appraisal that names the stone correctly is what an insurer replaces.
- Upgrade the stone. Diamond Setting sets a diamond in place of a look-alike: $65 for one center diamond in silver ($5 + $60) or $102 in 14K white gold ($5 + $60 + $33 + $4). Larger center diamonds are photo-quoted for your approval before sourcing, or you supply your own.
- Worried a stone was switched during an earlier repair? Will a jeweler swap my diamond? explains how to document a diamond. Here, every piece is photographed on arrival and before it ships back, so you can compare the stone in both sets of photos in your account.
Before you ship
- Enclose copies of any grading report, appraisal or receipt, and keep the originals at home. If the stone has an inscription number, write it on the order so it can be checked against the report.
- Insure it for what you believe it's worth, not what you fear it is. $100 of UPS coverage is included each way; full value up to $10,000 is 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions: $122.50 for a ring you'd value at $5,000 ($4,900 × 2.5%).
- Pad the piece in any sturdy small box with nothing on the outside naming the contents, and drop it at any UPS location with the prepaid label from your account. Shipping is $30 round trip per order, with a signature both ways, US addresses only.
Behind JewelryRepair.com is Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.
Questions
Does a diamond tester tell if a diamond is real?
Is a lab-grown diamond a real diamond?
Do real diamonds fog up?
How can you tell moissanite from a diamond?
Does a real diamond scratch glass?
Will a jeweler check if my diamond is real?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list