Gemstone Replacement

A lost colored stone matched, sourced, and set — quoted before any work begins.

Decline, and there is nothing more to pay. If inspection turns up extra work, you get photos and an itemized quote first. Decline it and we send your piece back — your $30 round-trip shipping already covers the return. No diagnostics fee, no surprises.

From$23.00

$18 each

Filled in from your selections — edit or add detail (stones, engraving, brand…) if you like.

Up to 5 photos, 8MB each.

    Add-ons
    Your price — updates as you choose
    Total

    Same math as the bench — no surprises at checkout.

    Back in your hands by

    • Insured shipping available up to $10,000
    • 1-year workmanship guarantee
    • Clean, polish & inspection included
    • Photographed at intake and before it ships
    Need it sooner?

    Rush service moves your repair to the front of the bench queue so it ships 2–3 days sooner — the exact surcharge is shown on the option below.

    About this service

    A missing sapphire, a cracked opal, a birthstone that vanished down a sink — losing a colored stone feels worse than losing a diamond, because color is personal. Gemstone replacement is our matching and sourcing service: we find a stone that honors the original's color, cut, and character, you approve it, and only then do we set it.

    Colored stones are harder to match than diamonds — two sapphires of the same size can be entirely different blues — so we treat matching as its own step. The jeweler measures your empty setting and studies whatever reference exists (remaining stones, photos of the piece, your description), then sources candidate stones and sends you options with a written quote. Once you choose, the stone is set with technique adjusted to its hardness: heat kept away, tool pressure moderated for soft stones like opal and turquoise, and every prong or bezel edge finished smooth.

    What's included

    • Stone matching and sourcing, with options sent for your approval
    • A written quote before any stone is purchased or set
    • Professional clean and inspection, included
    • 1-year workmanship guarantee and prepaid shipping both ways ($30 round trip)

    The $23 price is the setting labor for one side stone in silver ($5 base + $18), with metal, setting style and any extra side stones priced live above. The stone itself is quoted separately, because gemstones range from a modest garnet to a fine Burmese ruby: we send options with the full price for your approval before anything is set, and if no option suits you, you owe nothing for stones. Already have the replacement stone? Our stone replacement cost guide explains how sourcing and setting are priced, and our Gemstone Replacement & Setting service covers the labor alone.

    How your repair works

    1. Order

      Configure your repair and check out — nothing ships until your label arrives.

    2. Send it in

      Your prepaid UPS label is ready in your account within minutes. Pack it up and drop it at any UPS location.

    3. We repair & photograph

      A named bench jeweler works your piece. It is photographed at intake and again before it ships.

    4. Guaranteed return

      UPS back to you with signature on delivery, backed by our 1-year workmanship guarantee.

    Common questions

    How is gemstone replacement priced?
    The $23 covers setting labor for one side stone in silver ($5 base + $18 per side stone); metal, setting style and extra side stones are priced live on this page. The stone is quoted separately: we source candidates and send options with the full price for your approval before anything is set. If no option suits you, you owe nothing for stones.
    Can you really match my missing stone's color?
    That's the heart of the service. We work from your remaining stones, photos of the piece when it was whole, and your description, then send you the closest candidates we find. You see the options before deciding — if nothing satisfies you, you owe nothing for stones.
    What if I already have a replacement stone?
    Then you only need setting labor — order our Gemstone Replacement & Setting service instead, where setting is priced in the configurator at a $5 base + $18 per side stone (from $23). Pack your stone securely with the jewelry and we'll handle the rest.
    Are soft stones like opal, pearl, or turquoise a problem?
    No, they just demand gentler handling — no heat near the stone, reduced tool pressure, and protective setting techniques. These stones cross our bench constantly; if a setting can't safely hold a fragile stone as designed, we'll flag it and propose a fix before setting.

    Not sure?

    Not certain this is the right repair?

    Answer a few quick questions and we'll match the right service, or text us a photo and we'll point you to the right repair.