Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing
How do you tarnish (oxidize) silver jewelry on purpose?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Oxidized silver is darkened with sulfur, not oxygen. The black is silver sulfide, the same compound as tarnish, made on purpose and under control.
- The standard method is liver of sulfur: a clean piece, a warm, weak solution, quick dips and rinses until it's gray or black, then the raised areas polished bright.
- It takes on sterling, fine silver and copper. Brass takes it poorly, gold alloys mostly don't react, and intact rhodium plating blocks it.
- Silver-plated and costume pieces are a gamble: the silver layer is thin, and lacquer or other plating can stop the reaction.
- Ventilate and keep acids away. The fumes are hazardous, and sulfides meeting acid give off toxic hydrogen sulfide gas.
- Dull isn't the same as dark. A matte or brushed look is a surface texture, not a chemical color.
- A worn finish can be redone, at home or at the bench.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Rhodium Plating | from $69 | Oxidation (+$28) is an option listed on the Rhodium Plating page and is billed on that repair's base, $69 for a silver ring or pendant. Black antiquing (+$24) and Black rhodium (+$24) are listed too. Ask for an oxidized finish in your order notes and say which areas should be dark and which bright; for a re-oxidize-only job, get a free quote through the on-site chat or contact page, or book the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, first. A jeweler confirms the plan on arrival, and any change in scope or price is yours to approve. |
| Jewelry Polishing | from $30 | For taking a patchy or half-worn oxidized piece back to bright, even metal: worked through progressively finer compounds, with details done by hand. A silver pendant is $60, a necklace $105. |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | For a piece with stones, plating or soldered repairs, or one whose original finish you aren't sure of: examined under magnification and quoted item by item with photos. Credited in full. |
What oxidizing actually does to silver
Silver tarnishes when sulfur gases in the air, mainly hydrogen sulfide, react with its surface. The Canadian Conservation Institute (CCI) explains that the layer passes from yellow through red-brown to blue as it grows from about 10 to 100 nanometers thick, and looks black beyond about 100 nanometers, the true color of silver sulfide. Oxidizing does the same thing in seconds instead of years by putting clean silver in a sulfur-rich solution.
Two things follow. The dark layer is extremely thin, about 0.0001 mm, so it wears off wherever the piece rubs and comes off completely in a silver dip. And the in-between colors are unstable: Charles Lewton-Brain's guide on Ganoksin notes that the yellows, reddish browns, purples and blues of a weak solution keep darkening over time unless sealed, while a full gray or black is stable. That's why most jewelers take the color all the way and then polish it back from the high points. More on the finish itself in our glossary entry on oxidized silver.
Which pieces will darken, and which won't
- Sterling and fine silver: darken well, to a blue-black or steel gray.
- Copper: darkens to a purplish black.
- Brass: takes it poorly. Wikipedia's liver of sulfur entry says brass doesn't react, and Lewton-Brain describes coating brass with copper first, which is a workshop job.
- Gold: Ganoksin's guide says gold alloys don't react to most sulfur solutions, so liver of sulfur is unreliable on gold. Lewton-Brain describes a workshop route of copper-plating gold in used pickle and darkening the copper; the dark option for gold listed at JewelryRepair.com is black rhodium plating.
- Rhodium-plated silver: rhodium is inert against corrosion, so where the plating is intact, sulfur can't reach the silver and the piece won't darken. If a listing says rhodium-plated, test a hidden spot first. It's also why an oxidized-finish order on our Rhodium Plating page is confirmed by a jeweler on arrival rather than assumed to include plating.
- Silver-plated pieces: only the thin silver layer darkens, and polishing the high points afterward can cut through it to the base metal. Work gently and stop early.
- "Fake silver" and costume pieces: results are unpredictable. Nickel silver contains no silver at all, many fashion pieces are plated or lacquered, and Wikipedia notes that even oil from bare hands can block the reaction. Test on the back, or expect patchy color.
- Pieces with stones: GIA warns that pearls can be damaged by many chemicals and that turquoise can be discolored by them, and opal can fracture with sudden temperature changes. Keep those out of a warm bath: paint the solution onto the metal only, or leave the piece to a jeweler.
Getting an even, lasting finish
- Patchy or streaky color: usually grease or uneven temperature. Take the color off (a silver dip or polish removes it from plain silver) and start again from a clean, warm piece.
- Flaking, or a sooty black that rubs off: the solution was too strong. Wikipedia notes that strong solutions oxidize too fast and the patina may flake, while dilute ones build a more secure layer. Dilute it and build the color slowly.
- Nothing happens: the solution may be spent. Fresh liver of sulfur is dark yellow, close to liver-colored, and fades to pale yellow and then white as it loses strength. Or the piece is plated, lacquered or not silver.
- Too dark all over: polish more off the high points; the color sits only on the surface.
- Dark only in the lettering or pattern: paint the solution onto those areas while gently warming the piece, as Lewton-Brain describes, rather than dipping it.
- A deeper black on sterling: Lewton-Brain gets an excellent black by sandblasting sterling just before dipping. The point is a fresh, grease-free surface.
Safety: what's in the jar
- Ventilation. Lewton-Brain warns the fumes are dangerous: work with good airflow and cover the container right after use.
- Never near acids. Sulfide solutions release hydrogen sulfide, a toxic gas, when they meet acid. That includes the pickle used after soldering, so rinse a soldered piece thoroughly before coloring it.
- Gloves protect your hands and keep skin oil off the metal.
- Storage. Ganoksin notes that light and air break liver of sulfur down, so keep it in a tightly sealed dark bottle; Lewton-Brain finds the lump form lasts longer than powder, and Wikipedia notes gels with stabilizers keep longer too. Wikipedia notes the sulfides themselves are toxic, so store it away from children and food.
- Not bleach. It's sometimes suggested as a shortcut, but Jewelers Mutual warns that strong chemicals like bleach can damage and discolor silver, and it doesn't give a controllable finish.
Shortcuts: eggs, clay and garden sprays
Without liver of sulfur there are slower ways to bring sulfur to silver. Lewton-Brain notes that egg yolks will work in a pinch, which is the idea behind the familiar trick of sealing silver in a container with a hard-boiled egg; it's slower and harder to control than a bath. Plasticine modeling clay left against silver for a long time can leave dark patterns, and ammonium sulfide, sold as a garden spray, is said to substitute for liver of sulfur. None gives more control than a weak, warm liver of sulfur bath, which is also the quickest way to tarnish silver on purpose.
If you want silver dull rather than dark, what you're after is a matte, satin or brushed texture, made mechanically with a fine abrasive pad or brush rather than with sulfur, and it changes how light scatters, not the color of the metal. To change the finish on a piece you care about, start with a free quote or the $19 Mail-In Evaluation; Jewelry Polishing takes a patchy piece back to bright, even metal.
Redoing a worn or stripped oxidized finish
Because the color is a surface reaction, a worn or stripped finish can be put back once the silver is clean. On plain silver without stones or plating, the home method above works. Bring it to a jeweler instead when the piece has pearls, turquoise, opal or other sensitive stones, rhodium or other plating, soldered repairs nearby, or a design where only certain areas should be dark.
- At JewelryRepair.com, Oxidation (+$28), Black antiquing (+$24) and Black rhodium (+$24) are options listed on the Rhodium Plating page, billed on its base. The listed totals in sterling are $97 for a ring or pendant with Oxidation ($69 + $28), $117 for earrings or a bracelet ($69 + $20 + $28) and $137 for a necklace ($69 + $40 + $28); Black antiquing on a silver ring is $93 ($69 + $24). If the piece only needs its dark finish back, get a free quote through the on-site chat or contact page before booking, so a jeweler can say what the job involves.
- Gold: black rhodium is the route, $101 on a 14K yellow gold ring ($69 + $6 + $2 + $24).
- Engraved lettering: Hand Engraving, by free quote from $250, lists black antiquing (+$50) to darken graver-cut lettering and ornament.
- Not sure what the piece is, or what it needs? The Mail-In Evaluation, $19 and credited in full, gets you an itemized quote with photos before anything is done.
Say in your order notes which areas should be dark and which bright; a jeweler confirms the plan when the piece arrives, and if the scope or price changes, you approve it first. Sending an oxidized piece for a different repair? Mention the finish, because every repair includes a clean and polish and soldering heats the metal near the joint. To keep a finish you like while cleaning, see how to clean oxidized silver jewelry.
Your piece is photographed when it arrives at our New York studio and again before it ships back, so you can compare the finish in your account. It travels by UPS for $30 round trip per order, with $100 of coverage each way. JewelryRepair.com is Sky Jewelry's mail-in service; the family has been jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, and a finish redone here carries the 1-year workmanship guarantee.
Questions
How do you make silver tarnish quickly?
Can you oxidize silver-plated jewelry?
Can gold be oxidized like silver?
Does an oxidized finish wear off?
Is liver of sulfur dangerous to use at home?
Will oxidizing damage the stones in my jewelry?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list