Metals & plating

Tarnish

Hands polishing a ring against a spinning polishing wheel

Tarnish is a dark surface layer that forms on silver when it reacts with sulfur gases in the air, and on sterling the copper in the alloy makes it form faster. It starts as a faint yellow, deepens through red-brown and blue, and turns black as the layer thickens.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

What tarnish is

Tarnish is corrosion that stays on the surface. Silver reacts with sulfur gases in the air, mainly hydrogen sulfide, and forms silver sulfide. Sterling silver must be at least 925/1,000 silver under the FTC's Jewelry Guides, and the rest is usually copper, which is why sterling tarnishes faster than fine silver.

The color tells you how thick the layer is. The Canadian Conservation Institute explains that a very thin layer looks yellow, then red-brown, then blue as it grows, and that above roughly 100 nanometers it turns black. It adds a point most people don't expect: a layer of tarnish, unappealing as it looks, actually helps protect the silver against further tarnishing.

Gold behaves differently. GIA describes gold as resistant to tarnish and corrosion. Karat gold is mixed with other metals for hardness: the FTC explains that 14K is 14 parts gold and 10 parts another metal, about 58% gold, and 10K is 10 parts in 24, about 42%. When a gold piece looks dark or dull, check the look-alikes below before calling it tarnish.

What causes it, and how to slow it

Sulfur gases are everywhere in a home. The Canadian Conservation Institute lists rubber bands, wool and felt, eggs, and some paints among the sources, and notes that silver tarnishes faster as humidity climbs, so it recommends storing silver below 50% relative humidity. At home that means:

  • Store silver dry, in a closed box or anti-tarnish pouch, not loose on a dresser.
  • Keep it away from rubber bands and wool.
  • Don't wrap it in newspaper or seal it in bubble wrap; the Sheffield Assay Office warns that newspaper tarnishes silver quickly and plastic traps moisture.
  • Put jewelry on after lotion and perfume, and wipe it with a soft cloth before putting it away.
  • Don't over-polish. The CCI notes that freshly polished silver tarnishes faster than silver with a layer already on it, and that each cleaning takes a little silver with it.

More storage habits are in our answer on how to keep sterling silver from tarnishing.

How to tell it's tarnish

Rub a hidden spot with a soft white cloth. Tarnish leaves a gray or black smudge and shows bright metal underneath. If the cloth comes away clean and the color doesn't change, you're looking at worn plating, an intentional finish or the metal's own color. A yellow-to-brown tint on sterling is early tarnish and comes off easily. Black tarnish packed into crevices takes longer, and that's where a professional clean earns its keep, because hard scrubbing scratches the high points while missing the recesses. Home methods are covered in how to clean tarnished sterling silver.

Tarnish vs oxidized silver, and other look-alikes

  • Oxidized silver. Darkened on purpose, usually in the recesses, so a design stands out. A dip or a hard polish removes it, so tell the jeweler which dark areas are meant to stay. If the finish has already been lost, it can be put back as an add-on to Rhodium Plating: $97 for a silver ring with oxidation ($69 + $28) or $93 with black antiquing ($69 + $24).
  • Worn plating. On gold-plated or vermeil pieces, a dark or coppery patch is often the metal underneath showing through. Under the FTC Guides, vermeil is sterling silver plated with gold of at least 10 karat, in a layer equivalent to at least 2.5 microns of fine gold, so once that layer wears through, the silver beneath tarnishes. Polishing won't bring the gold back; re-plating will. Flash plating restores the color, but it is the thinnest option, below the 1 to 2 micron tier, so it won't restore vermeil thickness. Heavier layers run $460 for a silver ring at 3 to 4 microns ($60 + $400) or $535 at 4+ microns ($60 + $475); because the FTC counts the minimum in fine gold, ask through a free quote if the piece needs to meet the vermeil standard. More in does gold vermeil tarnish?
  • Yellowing white gold. Not tarnish either. It's the rhodium plating wearing off to show the warmer metal beneath; GIA notes a white gold ring can start to look warm in color as the rhodium wears away. See does white gold tarnish?
  • Dirt. A dull, greasy look on gold is usually lotion, soap and skin oil. It washes off, and the Jewelry Spa clears it from under stones.

What it costs here

  • Jewelry Polishing: $30 for a sterling silver ring or earrings, $50 for a bracelet, $60 for a pendant and $105 for a necklace.
  • Jewelry Spa: $44 for a silver ring, earrings or pendant, $56 for a bracelet or necklace, with a written inspection report.
  • Rhodium Plating: from $69 for a silver ring. Sterling silver is rhodium plated to resist tarnish, and rhodium itself is highly resistant to corrosion, but the plating wears away with use, so it buys time rather than ending tarnish for good.
  • Gold Plating: from $60 on a silver base, which covers vermeil. Other base metals add a charge: re-plating a gold-plated brass ring starts at $173 ($60 + $113) and a copper one at $240 ($60 + $180). Thicker layers are priced by micron.

Plated pieces that need polishing are priced by free quote, since too much polishing can cut through plating, and every repair already includes a clean and polish. Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS with $100 of coverage each way, and the prepaid label is waiting in your account. Pieces are photographed when they reach the New York studio and again before they ship back, so the before and after of a heavily tarnished piece is on record. A second jeweler checks the bench jeweler's work, which carries a 1-year guarantee. Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, runs JewelryRepair.com; the family has completed over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

Prices at a glance

Service Price What's included
Jewelry Polishing from $30 Worked through progressively finer compounds to a mirror, satin or brushed finish, with details and milgrain done by hand. Ring or earrings $30 in silver; bracelet $50, pendant $60, necklace $105.
Jewelry Spa from $44 Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish, plus a written inspection report. A bracelet or necklace adds $12.
Rhodium Plating from $69 Polished, cleaned and plated with fresh rhodium; $69 for a silver ring. For pieces meant to be dark, oxidation or black antiquing is booked as an add-on: $97 for a silver ring with oxidation ($69 + $28) or $93 with black antiquing ($69 + $24).
Gold Plating from $60 For vermeil and plated pieces worn through to the metal underneath. $60 for a ring on a silver base at flash thickness; a brass base adds $113 and copper $180. Thicker layers are priced by micron, such as +$400 for 3 to 4 microns.

Prices come from the live repair pages. Shipping is $30 round trip per order.

Questions

Does sterling silver tarnish?
Yes. Sterling is at least 92.5% silver, and the rest is usually copper, which is why sterling tarnishes faster than fine silver. Dry storage in a closed pouch slows it, and light tarnish wipes off with a silver cloth. For heavier tarnish, Jewelry Polishing at JewelryRepair.com is $30 for a sterling ring or earrings, plus $30 round-trip UPS shipping.
Does gold tarnish?
Gold itself resists it: GIA describes gold as resistant to tarnish and corrosion. Karat gold is part other metals, with 14K being 14 parts gold and 10 parts alloy, so when gold looks dark, first rule out lotion, soap and skin oil, or worn plating on a gold-plated piece. A Jewelry Spa clean is $59 for a 14K yellow gold ring at JewelryRepair.com ($44 + $10 + $5).
How do you remove tarnish from silver jewelry?
Light, yellowish tarnish comes off with a soft silver polishing cloth. Darker tarnish needs more, but keep harsh dips away from pearls, porous stones and pieces darkened on purpose, because dips strip intentional oxidation. A professional polish works through finer compounds and does details by hand; at JewelryRepair.com it's $30 for a silver ring and $105 for a necklace, plus $30 round-trip shipping.
Is tarnish the same as rust?
No. Rust keeps eating into iron and steel, while tarnish is a surface layer that limits itself: once it forms, it slows further reaction. The Canadian Conservation Institute notes that a tarnish layer on silver actually helps protect it from more tarnishing. Tarnish does come off, though each cleaning takes a little silver with it, so a $30 professional polish for a silver ring is better done occasionally than often.
Why does silver tarnish faster after polishing?
Because a freshly polished surface is bare silver with no tarnish layer slowing the reaction. The Canadian Conservation Institute notes that tarnish grows faster on freshly polished silver than on silver that has already tarnished, and that each cleaning removes some silver. So polish lightly and store dry rather than polishing often. When a piece does need it, Jewelry Polishing at JewelryRepair.com is $30 for a sterling ring.

All glossary terms · Repair questions · How online jewelry repair works

Sources