Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Does white gold tarnish?

Rarely, and not the way silver does. Well-made 14K and 18K white gold rarely tarnishes; what people call tarnish is usually worn rhodium plating letting the alloy's warmer color show, or a coating of lotion and soap. Some 10K white golds rich in silver can turn brown once the plating wears. JewelryRepair.com re-plates a 14K white gold ring for $79.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$79Rhodium Plating, 14K white gold ring
$68Jewelry Spa, 14K white gold ring
58.3%gold in 14K white gold (14 of 24 parts)
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • Gold doesn't tarnish, and well-made 14K and 18K white gold rarely does.
  • A yellow or straw tint isn't tarnish. It's the rhodium plating wearing off and the alloy's natural color showing.
  • A dull gray haze is usually lotion, soap and skin oil, and it washes off.
  • Real brown or black tarnish usually points to a silver-rich 10K alloy whose plating has worn, or to a piece that isn't white gold at all, such as plated silver.
  • Chlorine, not tarnish, is the bigger risk to white gold settings.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Rhodium Plating from $69Polished to a flawless surface, cleaned ultrasonically and with steam, then re-plated bright white. White gold ring: $77 in 10K, $79 in 14K, $83 in 18K. Earrings or a bracelet add $20, a necklace $40.
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish, with a written inspection report. White gold ring or earrings: $63 in 10K, $68 in 14K, $75 in 18K.
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked under magnification and the metal tested and documented, for a piece sold as white gold that tarnishes like silver.

What white gold is made of

White gold is karat gold alloyed with metals that bleach its color: 10K is 41.7% gold, 14K is 58.3% and 18K is 75%. Stewart Grice, an alloy designer writing on Ganoksin, describes nickel white as the predominant white gold in the US (the article dates from 2003, updated 2016), so nickel has long been the most common whitener. Most nickel-free 14K and 18K alloys use palladium instead, while most nickel-free 10K gets its color from high levels of silver and zinc. Designers can't make gold whiter, Grice explains, only "less yellow." That is why white gold is so often plated with rhodium, and why the FTC's Jewelry Guides require a rhodium surface layer to be disclosed on products sold as precious metal.

The whitener decides how the metal ages. Palladium stands up well to both corrosion and tarnish. Nickel white golds can discolor or tarnish if the alloy separates into two phases after casting, annealing or soldering. Silver reacts readily with sulfur in the air, so the silver-rich nickel-free 10K alloys tarnish most easily of all. Nickel is also a common skin allergen; see whether you can be allergic to white gold.

Does 10K, 14K or 18K white gold tarnish?

  • 10K white gold is the most likely to. Grice notes that rhodium shields silver-rich nickel-free 10K from tarnish only for a while: once the plating wears off, brown tarnish soon follows.
  • 14K white gold seldom tarnishes in normal wear; the change you'll see is color. Low-palladium 14K alloys are a cream or straw white, so they show clearly when the rhodium wears, while high-palladium alloys are whiter and wear is less noticeable.
  • 18K white gold is three-quarters gold, so there is the least of anything else to react. Most nickel-free 18K is whitened with palladium, which resists tarnish, but Grice notes that the low-palladium 18K alloys have a poor natural color and need rhodium plating. So 18K ages the way 14K does: a warmer tint on the high points as the plating wears, not a brown tarnish.

How to tell what you're looking at

  • Yellowish on the palm side and high points: worn rhodium. Our rhodium plating cost guide puts plating life at about 1 to 3 years on a ring and 12 to 24 months on engagement rings and wedding bands worn daily. Fix: Rhodium Plating.
  • Gray and cloudy all over: buildup. Jewelers Mutual notes that lotions and sprays leave jewelry dull and dingy. Fix: a wash in warm, soapy water with a soft brush; see the safest way to clean jewelry at home. If it's bright again, it was grime; if it's still yellowish on the back, it's the plating.
  • Brown or black: likely true tarnish, a sulfide layer, usually from silver in the alloy or under a plating, though some nickel white golds can also discolor. A dark smudge when you rub a hidden spot with a white cloth is only a rough home check, not a diagnosis. Fix: polish and re-plate; if the piece was sold as white gold and tarnishes like sterling, have the metal tested.
  • Dark pits, fine lines or a crack near the prongs or at the base of the shank: corrosion or stress cracking, not tarnish. Stop wearing it and book a Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited).

Chlorine and cracking: the real threat to white gold

Pools, hot tubs and bleach do more harm to white gold than tarnish ever will. Jewelers Mutual warns that chlorine can discolor metals like gold and platinum and can even corrode prongs until they break off. Separately, Grice reports that stress corrosion cracking frequently shows up in 14K nickel white settings, while none of the 14K palladium white alloys appeared susceptible. You can't tell which alloy you have by looking, so take white gold off for the pool, the hot tub and cleaning with bleach, and have the prongs checked if a ring has been exposed often.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in repair service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. Re-plating is done at the bench in our New York studio:

  • Rhodium Plating: $79 for a 14K white gold ring ($69 + $8 for white gold + $2 for 14K) and $83 in 18K. A pair of 14K white gold earrings is $99 ($69 + $20 + $8 + $2).
  • Jewelry Spa: $68 for a 14K white gold ring ($44 + $19 + $5), when the problem is grime rather than color.
  • Metal Testing & Verification: $15 per item, for a piece that tarnishes like silver. If you're booking a repair anyway, choose "Not sure" for the metal and it is tested at no charge.

If white gold comes in for a resize or other solder work, rhodium re-plating of the repaired area is included, so a ring sized down doesn't come home with a yellow seam. Shipping is $30 round trip by UPS with a prepaid label in your account and $100 of coverage each way.

Questions

Will white gold turn black?
Not on its own. Gold doesn't tarnish, and well-made 14K and 18K white gold rarely does. Black usually means silver is involved: a silver-rich 10K alloy whose rhodium has worn, or a piece that is actually plated silver. A cloth rub on a hidden spot is only a rough home check. Metal Testing & Verification at JewelryRepair.com confirms what the piece is made of for $15.
Can white gold rust?
No. Rust is iron oxide, and white gold is gold alloyed with metals such as nickel, palladium, silver, copper and zinc, not iron. What can happen is a different kind of damage: pitting, or fine cracks near the prongs or at the base of the band, which in some nickel white golds comes from stress corrosion. If you see either, have it checked; the Mail-In Evaluation at JewelryRepair.com is $19, credited toward the repair.
Does white gold tarnish in water?
Plain tap water won't tarnish it. Pool, hot-tub and sea water are different, because chlorine and salt attack the metal and the prongs rather than tarnishing it. The everyday problem is soap: hand soap and shower gel drying inside the band leave the gray residue people mistake for tarnish. Take white gold off to swim, and rinse and dry it after washing your hands.
Does white gold over silver tarnish?
Yes, once the plating wears. A piece sold as white gold over silver is sterling silver under a thin white plating, not solid white gold, and the silver tarnishes gray, brown or black wherever that layer rubs through, starting on the palm side of a ring. Re-plating restores it: Rhodium Plating on a sterling silver ring is $69 at JewelryRepair.com, and Metal Testing & Verification ($15) confirms the base metal.
Is platinum better than white gold if I don't want discoloration?
For color, yes. Platinum is naturally white all the way through, so it never shows the yellow tint of worn rhodium; with wear it takes on a soft satin finish instead. White gold needs re-plating from time to time to stay bright white, $79 for a 14K ring at JewelryRepair.com. A platinum ring needs no plating, just an occasional polish, which is $125 for a ring.