Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Can you be allergic to white gold or sterling silver?

Yes. Most reactions blamed on white gold are to nickel, which many white gold alloys contain under their rhodium plating, and sterling can carry traces of it. A ring or chain rash can also be soap trapped against skin; a patch test tells which. At JewelryRepair.com, Rhodium Plating by mail starts at $69 and restores the barrier.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

18%+of people in North America are allergic to nickel, the American Academy of Dermatology estimates
12 to 72 hoursafter contact, when a nickel rash usually appears (Cleveland Clinic)
$79Rhodium Plating for a 14K white gold ring ($69 + $8 + $2)
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers

The short version

  • "Allergic to white gold" usually means allergic to nickel. A 2003 metallurgy guide on Ganoksin called nickel white the predominant white gold alloy in the US, and DermNet notes that many people who believe they're allergic to gold or silver jewelry are reacting to nickel.
  • The rhodium plating hides it until it wears off. That's why a white gold ring worn for years without trouble can start to itch.
  • Sterling silver rarely causes it. It's 92.5% silver, usually alloyed with copper, though DermNet notes some sterling carries traces of nickel. Cheap silver-colored jewelry often has nickel in its base metal.
  • Gold itself is an uncommon culprit. GIA rates the allergy risk of 18K gold "unlikely" and 14K "possibly".
  • Only a patch test diagnoses it. A jeweler can test the metal, clean the piece and re-plate it, but can't tell you what your skin is reacting to.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Rhodium Plating from $69Polished, cleaned and plated with fresh rhodium, a barrier over the alloy: $69 for a sterling ring, $79 for 14K white gold, $109 for a sterling necklace ($69 + $40). It wears again with time.
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic, steam and hand-polish clean with a written inspection report, clearing soap and lotion packed inside the band and under stones.
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked and the metal and karat tested and documented, so you know whether it's solid white gold, sterling or plated base metal. Not a nickel-release test.
Mail-In Evaluation $19The whole piece examined under magnification, with an itemized quote and photos; credited in full toward approved work.

Allergy or irritation? How to tell them apart

  • Irritation. DermNet lists soap and water under a piece, and its non-metal parts, among the causes of skin reactions to jewelry. Soap, hand cream and moisture collect inside a band and under stones and sit against the skin all day. The usual clue is a rash right under the ring that flares after handwashing and settles when you keep the ring and your finger clean and dry.
  • Allergy. Nickel allergy is, in the Cleveland Clinic's words, the most common type of contact dermatitis related to metal. Symptoms usually appear 12 to 72 hours after contact, the rash may last two to four weeks, and the allergy can develop at any time, so a ring that never bothered you can start to. If earrings, earring backs or a watch also make you itch, nickel is the likely common thread: the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) names those among the biggest culprits.

The AAD advises seeing a board-certified dermatologist for a rash that blisters, becomes infected, or comes and goes. Diagnosis is a patch test: small amounts of suspected allergens, nickel among them, stay on patches on your back for 48 hours and are then checked for a reaction, as the Cleveland Clinic describes it.

Why white gold can start a reaction years later

White gold is gold alloyed with whitening metals. Stewart Grice's 2003 alloy guide on Ganoksin called nickel white the predominant type used in the US, and notes that nickel-free white golds were first developed in the 1920s with palladium as the main whitener. Most white gold jewelry is then plated with rhodium for its bright finish.

DermNet puts the consequence plainly: white gold is usually alloyed with nickel, and the initial plating protects you against it, but the plating wears off over months or years. Our rhodium plating cost guide puts its life at about 12 to 24 months on engagement rings and wedding bands worn every day. It goes first on the palm side of the band, which is exactly where the skin reacts. GIA's guide to ring metals sums up white gold's allergy risk as "unlikely, unless plating wears off", and points sensitive skin toward white gold alloyed with palladium, or yellow and rose gold that contain no nickel.

So the same ring can be fine for a year, start itching as the plating thins, and calm down again after it's re-plated. That pattern points to the alloy under the plating rather than the gold.

Sterling, plated silver and other metals

  • Sterling silver. DermNet describes sterling as 92.5% pure silver alloyed with copper, adding that a small percentage of other metals is sometimes in the mix, so traces of nickel may be present. The AAD includes pure sterling silver among metals for nickel-sensitive people, while GIA rates sterling "possibly" and advises checking the alloy.
  • Silver-plated and fashion jewelry. DermNet notes that in less expensive jewelry, nickel is often used in the base metal, which is then plated with gold or silver. Once the plating wears through, the nickel is against your skin.
  • Platinum. GIA rates platinum's allergy risk "unlikely", at usually around 95% platinum, and the AAD and Cleveland Clinic both list it for sensitive skin. One caution: some platinum jewelry is Pt/Co 950, about 5% cobalt according to an alloy guide on Ganoksin, and DermNet groups cobalt with nickel as a jewelry allergen. If a platinum ring reacts, mention it at your patch test.
  • Yellow gold. The AAD lists 18-, 22- and 24-karat yellow gold for nickel-sensitive skin; the Cleveland Clinic includes 14K yellow gold as well.
  • Dark marks aren't a rash. Gray or black smudges are tarnish rubbing off, and green is usually copper; see why rings turn fingers green or black.

What a jeweler can and can't do

A jeweler can't cure an allergy or take the nickel out of an alloy. What the bench can do:

  • Clean out the residue. If irritation is the cause, a ring packed with soap and lotion keeps it going. Jewelry Spa is an ultrasonic, steam and hand-polish clean with a written inspection report: $44 for a sterling ring, $68 for 14K white gold ($44 + $19 + $5).
  • Restore the barrier. Rhodium Plating polishes the piece, cleans it and lays down fresh rhodium: $69 for a sterling ring, $79 for 14K white gold ($69 + $8 + $2). A chain or necklace that itches at the neck follows the same logic: a sterling silver necklace is $109 ($69 + $40). It wears again with time, so it's maintenance, not a cure.
  • Find out what the metal is. Metal Testing & Verification, $15 per item, checks the hallmarks and tests and documents the metal and karat, so you know whether a "white gold" ring is solid gold or plated base metal. It doesn't measure nickel release. A dimethylglyoxime (DMG) spot test screens for that, with limits covered below.
  • Remake it in another metal. If a dermatologist confirms nickel, Custom Work & Modifications can remake a design in platinum or a nickel-free gold, starting with a $10 estimate.
  • Not sure what's going on? The Mail-In Evaluation, $19 and credited in full, gets the whole piece examined under magnification, with an itemized quote and photos.

The work is done at Sky Jewelry's New York studio; the family, jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, has carried out over 50,000 repairs since 1989. Your piece is photographed when it arrives and before it ships back, a second jeweler checks the work, and plating that wears prematurely is covered by the 1-year workmanship guarantee. Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, with the prepaid label in your account and $100 of coverage each way.

Questions

Is sterling silver hypoallergenic?
Mostly, but it isn't guaranteed. Sterling is 92.5% silver, usually alloyed with copper, and the AAD lists pure sterling silver among metals for nickel-sensitive skin. DermNet notes that some sterling contains small amounts of other metals, including traces of nickel, and GIA rates its allergy risk "possibly". Silver-plated fashion jewelry is riskier, because its base metal often contains nickel.
Why is my ring suddenly giving me a rash?
Usually because something changed around the metal, not the metal itself. On white gold, the rhodium plating may have worn through on the palm side, exposing nickel in the alloy. Soap or lotion may have built up inside the band. Or the allergy is new: the Cleveland Clinic says nickel allergy can develop at any time. See a dermatologist if the rash persists or blisters.
Does rhodium plating stop a nickel allergy?
It helps for a while, but it isn't a cure. DermNet notes that the plating on white gold protects you from the nickel in the alloy until it wears off over months or years, and our rhodium guide puts that at about 12 to 24 months on a ring worn daily. Rhodium Plating is $79 for a 14K white gold ring and $69 for sterling silver.
Does 14K or rose gold have nickel?
Rose and yellow gold usually don't; 14K white gold often does. Rose gold gets its color from copper, 32.5% of 14K rose gold on the World Gold Council's chart, and the Cleveland Clinic lists 14K yellow gold for nickel-sensitive skin. White gold is the exception, because nickel has long been a common whitener. Metal Testing & Verification, $15, confirms what a piece is, but not its nickel release.
Can a jeweler test my jewelry for nickel?
Not as a listed service here. Metal Testing & Verification, $15 per item, identifies the metal and karat, telling you whether a piece is solid white gold, sterling or plated base metal, but doesn't measure nickel release. A dimethylglyoxime spot test screens for it, though in a 2010 study of earring parts it missed about 41% of items releasing nickel above the EU limit (59.3% sensitivity, 97.5% specificity).