Repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing
Why does my ring turn my finger green or black?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Green means copper. Copper in the metal reacts with salts and acids from sweat, soap and lotion, forming green or blue-green compounds that rub onto skin. Brass, bronze, copper, plated pieces worn through to a copper-alloy base, and 10K and 14K gold can all do it.
- Black or gray usually means tarnish. Silver and copper react with sulfur compounds, and the dark layer rubs off. Sterling silver and low-karat gold are the usual sources.
- Red, itchy or blistered skin is a reaction, not a stain. Nickel is one of the most common causes. Stop wearing the piece and see a dermatologist.
- A mark doesn't mean the ring is fake. Solid 10K and 14K gold and sterling silver normally contain copper.
- Fixes run from drying your hands to a plated barrier at the bench: Rhodium Plating from $69 or Gold Plating from $60.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Metal Testing & Verification | $15 | Hallmarks checked and the metal and karat tested and documented, so you know what's touching your skin. |
| Rhodium Plating | from $69 | A ring polished, cleaned and plated with fresh rhodium. The usual barrier for white gold and sterling; yellow gold comes out white. |
| Gold Plating | from $60 | A new gold layer over a silver base; brass, copper, steel and gold bases and thicker plating add to the price. |
| Jewelry Polishing | from $30 | Tarnish and fine scratches removed from a ring or earrings, inside and out. |
Read the mark: what each color tells you
The color on your skin and the metal of the ring together usually point to the cause.
- Green or blue-green. Copper. Science Notes explains that copper reacting with salts, acids and other chemicals forms green or blue-green compounds; pure copper does it fastest, and copper alloys such as brass, bronze and 10K or 14K gold can do it too. A plated ring made over brass or copper starts marking once the plating wears through on the inside of the band.
- Black or gray on sterling silver. Silver tarnish. Sterling is at least 92.5% silver under the FTC's Jewelry Guides, and the other 7.5% is usually copper, added for strength. Silver reacts with sulfur compounds and turns dark, and that tarnish transfers to skin. Science Notes says sterling can turn skin black or green: black is the silver tarnish, and green comes from the copper.
- Black on gold. Tarnish of the copper and silver in the alloy. Chris Corti, in an article published with the World Gold Council, says tarnish is mainly seen in 8 to 10 carat gold, occasionally in 14 and 18 carat, and that the black smudges it leaves on skin are harmless but unsightly.
- Green or dark from a tungsten ring. Tungsten carbide is held together by a metal binder, often cobalt, though nickel is also used, and Science Notes notes that lower-quality tungsten carbide can leave a green mark. More in whether tungsten and titanium rings tarnish.
- Red, itchy, scaly or blistered. Irritation from soap, lotion or sweat trapped under the band, or allergic contact dermatitis. The American Academy of Dermatology estimates that more than 18% of people in North America are allergic to nickel, which can be present in white gold alloys and many base-metal pieces.
Why some rings mark skin and others don't
Gold itself doesn't react with skin. What reacts is the other metal mixed into it, and karat tells you how much there is: 24K is pure gold, 18K is 75% gold, 14K is 58.3% and 10K is 41.7%, each the karat divided by 24. Copper is a common alloy metal in colored golds; Wikipedia's article on colored gold gives 18K rose gold as 75% gold and 22.25% copper, and notes that the more copper an alloy carries, the redder it looks. That's why rose gold and low-karat yellow gold are the gold rings most likely to leave a mark.
Gerald Wykoff of the International Gem Society observes that 14K smudges faster than 18K because it contains more copper, that it's believed people whose sweat is high in salt or chloride see it more, and that it's especially noticeable in seacoast and semitropical climates. Corti adds perfume, hair spray and deodorant sprays, and sulfur compounds in some storage boxes and pouches, to the triggers. Science Notes points to lotion, sunscreen and sweat trapped under a band. So two people can wear the same ring with different results, and a ring that never marked you can start to in a humid summer or after a change in hand cream.
What to do about it at home
- Keep it dry. Take rings off for hand washing, dishes, swimming and lotion, and dry your finger and the inside of the band before putting them back on. Science Notes recommends removing rings before bathing, swimming or applying lotion, and rinsing after salt water.
- Clean the ring. Residue of soap, lotion and tarnish inside the band keeps the reaction going. A gentle clean helps; see the safest way to clean jewelry at home.
- Add a temporary barrier. Clear nail polish or a jeweler's coating painted inside the band slows it down, but both wear off and need redoing. Wykoff found petroleum jelly on the skin also slowed the smudge, while the special salves he tested didn't work.
- Store it dry and separate. Corti advises a pouch or bag in a dry, unpolluted place, free of sulfur compounds.
- Wash the mark off. The green or gray comes off skin with soap and water. If the skin underneath is red, itchy or blistered, stop wearing the piece; the AAD advises seeing a dermatologist for a rash that blisters, becomes infected or keeps coming back.
Longer-lasting fixes at the bench
If you love the ring and want it to stop marking, a plated barrier between the metal and your skin is the usual fix. Plating doesn't change what the ring is made of, and it wears with time.
- White gold and sterling silver: Rhodium Plating. The ring is polished, cleaned and plated with rhodium, a platinum-family metal; Science Notes notes that rhodium coatings don't discolor skin. A sterling ring is $69, a 14K white gold ring $79 ($69 + $8 + $2). The rhodium plating cost guide puts its life at about 12 to 24 months on a ring worn daily. Rhodium is white, so on yellow gold it changes the color; it's not the fix if you want to keep a yellow ring yellow.
- Plated jewelry worn through: Gold Plating. A new layer of gold over a properly prepared surface, from $60 for a ring with a silver base. Other bases cost more: brass is $173 for a ring with a yellow flash ($60 + $113), and copper and stainless steel, which get an underlayer first, are $240 ($60 + $180) and $211 ($60 + $151). Thicker plating takes longer to wear through and adds from $250 for 1 to 2 microns. See how long gold plating lasts.
- Low-karat yellow gold that blackens. Corti lists gold electroplating as one remedy, while noting it wears off over time. Here that's Gold Plating on a yellow gold base: $172 for a ring ($60 + $112).
- Not sure what the ring is? Metal Testing & Verification, $15 per item, checks the hallmarks and tests the metal and karat, so you know what's against your skin before you spend on plating. See what 585, 750 and 925 stamps mean.
Plating and testing are done at Sky Jewelry's New York studio. Your ring is photographed on arrival and before it ships back, a second jeweler checks the plated finish before it leaves, and plating that wears prematurely is covered by the 1-year workmanship guarantee.
When a different ring is the better answer
Plating buys time; it doesn't change the metal underneath. On an inexpensive fashion ring, replating can cost more than the ring did, and if a ring gives you a rash rather than a stain, a barrier that wears off isn't a cure. Whether you're replacing a ring or buying jewelry that won't mark your skin, the two problems point to slightly different lists.
- To avoid stains: the metals Science Notes names as least likely to mark skin are stainless steel, platinum and white gold, and it notes rhodium coatings don't discolor skin. In gold, less copper means less marking, and karat tells you how much other metal there is: 18K is 75% gold, against 58.3% in 14K and 41.7% in 10K.
- To avoid a rash: the AAD's list for nickel-sensitive skin is surgical-grade stainless steel, 18K to 24K yellow gold, pure sterling silver and platinum. White gold isn't on it, because white gold alloys can contain nickel, so if you react to nickel, choose from the AAD's list.
- Brass, bronze and copper are copper or copper alloys, which Science Notes lists among the metals that turn skin green. A lacquer or plated finish only delays it.
- Plated jewelry is only as good as its plating: once it wears through on the inside of a band or the back of an earring, the base metal is against your skin again.
See which jewelry metals don't tarnish and rhodium plating for sensitive ears.
Questions
Does sterling silver turn your finger green?
Can real gold turn your finger green?
Is it bad if my ring turns my finger green?
Does clear nail polish stop a ring from turning your finger green?
Why does my gold ring leave a black mark?
What jewelry won't turn your finger green?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list