Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Which jewelry metals don't tarnish, and what does 'tarnish-free' really mean?

Platinum, tungsten carbide and higher-karat gold don't tarnish in normal wear, and titanium, palladium and stainless steel resist it. Sterling silver, copper and brass do tarnish. A 'tarnish-free' label usually means stainless steel or a plated or coated piece, which stays bright only until the coating wears through. Metal testing at JewelryRepair.com is $15.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

58.3%gold in 14K; 10K is 41.7%, so more than half of a 10K piece is other metals
10.5%minimum chromium that gives stainless steel its self-renewing oxide layer
0.175 micronsthe FTC guides' benchmark for electroplate sold as gold plated
$15Metal Testing & Verification by mail, per item

The short version

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked under magnification and the metal and karat tested and documented, per item. Tells you whether a piece is solid, filled or plated before you spend money on it.
Rhodium Plating from $69$69 for a sterling silver ring or pendant: a rhodium layer keeps tarnish off the silver until it wears. A 14K white gold ring is $79 ($69 + $8 + $2).
Gold Plating from $60For plated pieces worn through to the base metal. A ring or pendant with flash plating: $60 on a silver base, $173 on brass ($60 + $113), $211 on stainless steel ($60 + $151). A 1–2 micron layer on silver is $310 ($60 + $250).
Jewelry Polishing from $30Removes tarnish and fine scratches from solid metal: $30 for a silver ring or earrings, $50 bracelet, $60 pendant, $105 necklace.

Why some metals tarnish and others don't

Tarnish is a thin layer of corrosion that stays on the surface. On silver, sulfur gases in the air, mainly hydrogen sulfide, turn the surface into silver sulfide; the Canadian Conservation Institute explains that the layer looks yellow when it is very thin, then red-brown, then blue, and black once it passes roughly 100 nanometers. Jewelers Mutual notes that copper forms a reddish-brown layer that darkens toward a green or blue-green patina, and that brass tarnishes too.

For gold, karat is the key. Pure gold is 24 karat; 18K is 75% gold, 14K is 58.3% and 10K is 41.7%, so more than half of a 10K piece is silver, copper and other metals. Jewelers Mutual groups pure gold and gold above 14 karats with the metals that don't tarnish, and the International Gem Society notes that 18K smudges less quickly than 14K because it holds less copper. Rose gold takes its color from copper, the metal that darkens. White gold resists tarnish too, but its rhodium plating wears, and the warmer alloy underneath can look yellowish. That's wear, not tarnish.

Platinum, palladium and titanium are a different case. Platinum is white all the way through, so there's no plating to wear; GIA notes only that it develops a patina over time. Palladium doesn't react with oxygen at room temperature, though Wikipedia notes it can slowly develop a slight brownish tint over time, so call it highly tarnish-resistant rather than tarnish-proof. Titanium and tungsten carbide hold their color, though GIA warns that tungsten is brittle and can crack or shatter under a hard impact.

Stainless steel contains more than 10.5% chromium, which forms a thin, invisible chromium-rich oxide layer that regenerates when exposed to oxygen, according to the World Stainless Association. The same source notes that stainless steel is susceptible to pitting and crevice attack in chloride-bearing water, so rinse steel jewelry after the pool or the ocean.

What 'tarnish-free', 'non-tarnish' and 'anti-tarnish' labels mean

The FTC's Jewelry Guides set rules for words like sterling, gold plated, gold filled and vermeil, but they give no definition for "tarnish-free," "non-tarnish" or "anti-tarnish." The nearest rule is about corrosion: a piece may be called corrosion resistant only if all its parts resist material corrosion damage for most of its expected life, and the guides name gold alloys of at least 10 karat and austenitic stainless steels among the metals that may qualify. A tarnish-free claim tells you what the seller claims, not what the piece is made of. In practice it usually describes one of these:

  • Stainless steel, often in a gold color. The gold color is a coating over the steel: the steel won't tarnish, but the color wears first where it rubs.
  • Gold-plated brass or copper. The FTC guides treat electroplate of at least 10 karat and 0.175 microns of fine-gold equivalent (about 7 millionths of an inch) as enough to be called gold plated, provided it is reasonably durable. Once that wears through, Jewelers Mutual notes, the base metal underneath is exposed and tarnishes.
  • Vermeil: sterling silver plated with at least 2.5 microns of gold of 10 karat or better. It outlasts ordinary plate, but the silver beneath tarnishes where the gold wears thin; see does gold vermeil tarnish?
  • Gold filled: a karat-gold layer bonded on mechanically that makes up at least 1/20 of the metal's weight, a much heavier layer than electroplate; see does gold-filled jewelry tarnish?
  • Tarnish-resistant silver alloys such as Argentium, made with 93.5%, 94% or 96% silver and about 1% germanium in place of some of sterling's copper. They are highly tarnish-resistant, not tarnish-proof.
  • Rhodium-plated silver. The rhodium keeps sulfur off the silver until it wears; our rhodium plating guide puts that at about 1 to 3 years on a ring. More in does rhodium-plated jewelry tarnish?

Before you buy, ask two questions: what is the base metal, and how thick is the gold or coating? "18K gold plated" describes the karat of the layer, not of the piece.

Choosing for earrings, rings and chains

  • Earrings. Platinum and higher-karat gold won't tarnish in normal wear, and titanium resists it. Plated earrings wear first on the post and the edges of a hoop, where they rub. If your skin reacts to some metals, see why a ring turns a finger green and rhodium plating for sensitive ears.
  • Rings. A ring takes more contact than anything else you wear, so plating on the palm side of the band goes first. Solid metal is the only finish that can't wear through to a different color.
  • Chains and necklaces. For a gold necklace that won't tarnish, choose solid gold: the higher the karat, the less there is in it to darken. Plated chains wear at the clasp end and wherever links rub each other, and a "gold" chain of unknown make is worth testing ($15) before you pay to replate it. Gold plating a necklace is $110 on a silver base ($60 + $50) or $223 on brass ($60 + $50 + $113), with flash plating.

When a piece has already tarnished or worn through

  • Not sure what it is? Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item: hallmarks checked under magnification for signs of counterfeit stamps, and the metal and karat tested and documented. It tells you whether a "gold" chain is solid, filled or plated before you spend anything on it.
  • Tarnished silver or dull gold: Jewelry Polishing from $30 for a silver ring or earrings, or the Jewelry Spa clean and written inspection from $44.
  • Silver you'd like to stop tarnishing: Rhodium Plating, $69 for a sterling silver ring or pendant.
  • Plating worn through: Gold Plating for a ring or pendant with flash plating is $60 on a silver base, $173 on brass ($60 + $113) and $211 on stainless steel ($60 + $151); a 1–2 micron layer on silver is $310 ($60 + $250) for jewelry worn hard.

Plated pieces that need polishing are priced by free quote, because polishing can cut through a thin layer. Every repair here includes a clean and polish and a 1-year workmanship guarantee. Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, with the prepaid label in your account and $100 of coverage each way. Your piece is photographed when it arrives in New York and before it ships back, and a second jeweler checks the work. Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue, runs JewelryRepair.com and has handled over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

Questions

Is there silver that doesn't tarnish?
No silver is completely tarnish-proof. Sterling and fine silver both tarnish when sulfur in the air reaches the surface. Alloys such as Argentium, with about 1% germanium, are highly tarnish-resistant, and rhodium-plated silver stays bright until the plating wears. At JewelryRepair.com, Rhodium Plating is $69 for a sterling silver ring or pendant, and Jewelry Polishing removes tarnish from a silver ring from $30.
What does non-tarnish or anti-tarnish jewelry mean?
It's a marketing claim, not a defined standard: the FTC's Jewelry Guides don't define tarnish-free, non-tarnish or anti-tarnish. In practice the label usually means stainless steel, often with a gold-colored coating, or a plated piece that stays bright until the layer wears. Ask what the base metal is and how thick the gold is. Metal Testing & Verification tells you what you actually have for $15.
Is 18K gold plated jewelry non-tarnish?
Not permanently. "18K gold plated" describes the karat of a thin gold layer, not the piece, and once that layer wears through, the brass or copper underneath tarnishes. It lasts longer when you keep it away from water, lotion and friction. When it has worn through, re-plating a brass ring at JewelryRepair.com is $173 ($60 + $113) with flash plating, or $60 on a silver base.
What cheap metal doesn't tarnish?
Stainless steel and titanium are the tarnish-resistant choices that don't depend on precious metal. Stainless steel's chromium forms a self-renewing oxide layer, and GIA calls titanium resistant to corrosion and tarnish. Brass, copper and silver plate are the inexpensive metals that do tarnish. A gold-colored steel piece keeps its steel but can lose its color where the coating rubs off.
What earrings won't tarnish?
Earrings in platinum or higher-karat gold won't tarnish in normal wear, and titanium and stainless steel resist it. Plated earrings tarnish once the layer wears, usually first on the post and the edges of a hoop. If a favorite pair has worn through, Gold Plating for earrings is $85 on a silver base ($60 + $25), and Earring Post Repair replaces a failed post from $30 a pair.
What jewelry doesn't tarnish in water?
Platinum and tungsten carbide, which GIA describes as not tarnishing, and gold, which it calls tarnish-resistant, are the safest choices, with titanium close behind. Even so, Jewelers Mutual warns that "water, chlorine from pools, and ocean salt can rapidly tarnish metals" and advises taking jewelry off before showering, bathing or swimming. GIA adds that chlorine bleach can pit or damage gold alloys.