Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Does gold-filled jewelry tarnish or turn green?

Gold-filled jewelry can tarnish slightly, but far less than gold-plated or sterling pieces, because its surface is a thick layer of real karat gold making up at least 1/20 of the metal's weight. It usually turns green or dark only where that layer has worn through to the brass core, most often on clasps, ring backs and edges.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

1/20minimum share of the metal weight that is karat gold (5%)
10Kminimum karat of the gold layer under FTC rules
$19mail-in evaluation of a worn piece, credited in full toward the repair
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • Tarnish: slight at most. The outside of gold filled is karat gold, so it behaves like the karat it's made of; a light dullness is usually skin oil and lotion, not corrosion.
  • Green: a sign the gold has worn through somewhere. The core is usually brass, a copper alloy, and copper is what leaves green marks.
  • Fading: gold filled doesn't fade the way thin plating does; it wears, slowly, at rub points.
  • If it went green in weeks: it's probably plated, not gold filled. Check the stamp.
  • Once brass shows: cleaning can't put gold back. Re-plating usually restores the color; a jeweler confirms that on the piece.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Metal Testing & Verification $15Tells you whether a piece is gold filled, gold plated or solid karat gold before you decide how to clean or repair it: stamps examined under magnification, then the metal tested and documented.
Mail-In Evaluation $19For a worn or broken gold-filled piece when you're not sure which listed repair fits: a jeweler examines the whole piece under magnification and sends an itemized quote with photos.
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish to clear lotion and grime packed into links and clasps, plus a written inspection report from the bench. Gold filled is priced under Other / not sure, which adds nothing.
Gold Plating from $60New gold over a piece whose gold-filled layer has worn through, after polishing, ultrasonic and steam cleaning and an activation bath. Gold filled isn't a listed base metal, so the price depends on the base the jeweler confirms; on a brass base, flash plating is $173 for a ring or pendant ($60 + $113).

The details: why gold filled resists tarnish

Under the FTC's jewelry guides, a piece can be called gold filled only if a layer of gold alloy of at least 10 karat is bonded on by a mechanical process such as soldering, brazing or welding, and that layer makes up at least 1/20 of the weight of all the metal. A layer between 1/40 and 1/20 of the weight can be sold as rolled gold plate or gold overlay, but not as gold filled. Jewelry supplier Cookson Gold describes the core as usually brass, joined by heat and pressure, and puts gold-plated items at usually under 0.05% gold by weight against 5% for gold filled. Wikipedia's gold-filled article puts the layer at 5 to 10 times thicker than regular gold plating.

The most common marks are 1/20 12K GF and 1/20 14K GF. A 1/20 14K piece is 5% 14K alloy by weight, and 14K is 58.3% gold, so the whole piece is about 2.9% pure gold (0.05 × 0.583). That matters for tarnish in two ways. The surface you see and touch is real karat gold, which tarnishes very little. But karat gold isn't pure: 14K is 41.7% other metals, and GIA's Gems & Gemology journal notes that tarnish spots on gold jewelry have been a concern for centuries, particularly on lower-purity gold. In practice, a 12K or 14K gold-filled chain may pick up a faint darkening over years. It shouldn't go green or black while the layer is intact.

Where it tarnishes or turns green, and what that tells you

  • A dull, slightly darker look all over: lotion, soap and skin oil, or a faint tarnish on the karat alloy. A warm soapy wash fixes most of it.
  • A brassy or greenish patch in one spot: the gold has worn through. Gold filled wears from the points that rub: the palm side of a ring, clasp ends, the edges of a bangle, chain links at the back of the neck. Brass is copper plus zinc, and Science Notes explains that copper reacting with salts, acids and other chemicals on skin forms green compounds that also mark it.
  • A dark or green clasp on a bright chain: look at the small parts. The FTC guides leave joints, catches, screws and springs out of the assay of gold-filled products, so the spring in a gold-filled clasp can be plain base metal.
  • Discoloration at an old repair: any cut, file or polish at a solder joint can go through the gold layer and leave the core exposed at the joint.
  • Green or black all over within weeks: probably not gold filled. GEP means electroplate, and GP usually does; under FTC rules electroplate sold as gold plated can be as thin as 0.175 microns, while HGE (heavy gold electroplate) needs at least 2.5 microns. GF, G.F. or a fraction such as 1/20 14K GF means gold filled; RGP means the thinner rolled gold plate.

How to keep gold filled from tarnishing

The care is the same as for gold plating, because the risk is the same one at a slower pace: wearing through. Wash it in warm, soapy water, skip abrasives, bleach and chlorine, and store each piece in its own pouch; the full routine, including what Jewelers Mutual says not to use, is in our guide to cleaning gold-plated, vermeil and gold-filled jewelry.

When the brass shows: what can and can't be done

A cleaning can't put gold back, and neither can polishing. Bench polishing works by removing a fine surface layer, so on gold filled it takes gold with it; if you're unsure whether a polish or a solder repair will expose the core, have a jeweler look first. Re-plating is usually the fix once the core shows: Gold Plating polishes the surface, cleans it ultrasonically and with steam, activates it so the new gold bonds metal to metal, and plates it. Gold filled isn't a listed base metal, so the jeweler confirms the base at intake; if it is brass, flash plating in yellow gold is $173 for a ring or pendant ($60 + $113), $198 for earrings ($60 + $25 + $113) and $223 for a necklace ($60 + $50 + $113).

Be honest about the math. Re-plating restores the color, not the original gold-filled layer, and a necklace that cost less than $223 new may not be worth it unless it matters to you. The safest first step for a worn or broken piece is the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full toward the work you approve, or a free, itemized quote through the contact page (a jeweler replies within 1 business day). For a piece that's simply dull, the Jewelry Spa cleans and inspects it from $44. Not sure it's gold filled at all? Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item.

Before you ship

Note the stamp in your order, for example 1/20 14K GF, and send the matching pieces of a set together if the color needs to match. JewelryRepair.com, the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry in New York, has done over 50,000 repairs since 1989, and our 1-year workmanship guarantee covers plating that wears prematurely.

Questions

Will 14K gold-filled jewelry turn my skin green?
Usually not while the gold layer is intact, because your skin touches 14K gold rather than the core. It can once that layer wears through at a rub point, since the core is usually brass and copper reacts with salts and acids on skin to form green compounds. A green mark from one spot on a gold-filled ring usually means the back of the band has worn.
Does gold-filled jewelry fade?
Not the way thin plating does. The surface is a karat-gold layer at least 1/20 of the metal's weight, so its color doesn't fade; it wears, slowly, at rub points such as ring backs, clasp ends and bangle edges. When it wears through, a brassy patch appears there while the rest stays gold. A $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full, tells you whether re-plating makes sense.
How long does gold-filled jewelry last?
Much longer than gold plating, but not forever. The gold layer is at least 1/20 of the metal's weight, while Cookson Gold puts plated items at usually under 0.05% gold by weight, so it takes far more wear to go through. How long depends on how it's worn: rings, bracelets and clasps rub the most and wear first, and that's where the brass core shows.
Does gold-filled jewelry tarnish faster than solid gold?
Not at the surface: a 1/20 14K gold-filled chain is 14K gold on the outside, so it tarnishes about as little as solid 14K. The difference shows with wear. Solid 14K is the same metal all the way through, so polishing or rubbing never reveals a different color, while gold filled eventually exposes its brass core at rub points, and that is where green and dark spots appear.
Can gold-filled jewelry rust?
The gold layer and the usual brass core can't rust, because rust is corrosion of iron and steel; worn-through brass turns dark or green instead. The exception is small parts: the FTC guides leave springs, catches and joints out of a gold-filled product's assay, so a clasp spring may be steel and can rust if it stays damp. Metal Testing is $15 per item if you're unsure what a piece is.