Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Does gold vermeil or gold-plated sterling silver tarnish?

Vermeil can tarnish, but not because of the gold. It is sterling silver underneath, and the silver darkens wherever the gold layer wears thin or through, usually first at clasps, the backs of rings and the edges of earrings. JewelryRepair.com re-plates a sterling silver ring or pendant with gold from $60.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

2.5 micronsminimum gold thickness for vermeil (FTC)
$60flash gold plating, sterling ring or pendant
$3852–3 micron gold plating, sterling ring ($60 + $325)
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • Vermeil is sterling silver plated with gold of at least 10 karat and at least 2.5 microns thick, under the FTC's Jewelry Guides.
  • The gold resists tarnish; the silver doesn't. Exposed sterling reacts with sulfur in the air and darkens.
  • The color doesn't fade; the gold wears through, starting at rub points.
  • Thinner gold-plated sterling wears through sooner than true vermeil.
  • Wash it; don't polish it. Polishing cloths and pastes remove gold along with tarnish.
  • Re-plating is the only way to cover silver that shows through.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Gold Plating from $60Silver polished bright, cleaned ultrasonically and with steam, and activated so the gold bonds metal-to-metal, then plated in yellow, rose or white gold. Sterling ring or pendant: flash $60, 1–2 microns $310, 2–3 microns $385, 3–4 microns $460, 4+ microns $535.
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked under magnification and the metal tested and documented, to confirm whether a piece sold as vermeil is gold over sterling or gold-plated brass.
Mail-In Evaluation $19For vermeil with a broken clasp, a loose stone or other damage: an itemized quote with photos before any work. The $19 is credited in full.

Why vermeil tarnishes even though gold doesn't

Under the FTC's Jewelry Guides, a piece may be called vermeil only if it is sterling silver plated on all significant surfaces with gold of at least 10 karat, at least 2.5 microns thick, about 100 millionths of an inch. If a base metal such as nickel sits between the silver and the gold, that has to be disclosed. So every vermeil piece is two metals that age very differently.

The Canadian Conservation Institute explains that sterling, 92.5% silver and 7.5% copper, reacts with sulfur gases in the air: the silver forms silver sulfide, the copper forms copper sulfide, and the copper makes sterling tarnish faster than pure silver. The layer starts yellow, moves through red-brown and blue, and looks black once it passes about 100 nanometers, and it grows faster as humidity rises. While the gold covers the silver completely, the silver is shielded. Once the gold wears thin at an edge or a clasp, that spot behaves like bare sterling.

Where it shows first, and what the colors mean

  • Rings: the palm side and inside of the band.
  • Necklaces and bracelets: the clasp, jump rings and links that rub each other.
  • Earrings: edges, posts and the parts of hoops that touch the earlobe.
  • Pendants: the back and the bail.

A silvery patch is worn-through gold with clean silver showing. A gray, brown or black spot is that silver tarnishing. Green is the color of copper corrosion: sterling contains some copper, but a piece that goes green quickly, or shows pink or brassy metal where the gold has worn, is worth testing. Gold-plated brass is a common costume-jewelry metal, and it isn't vermeil at any thickness. Genuine vermeil is usually stamped 925, the sterling mark, because the base is sterling silver.

Rose gold vermeil, and sterling plated with rhodium or white gold, behave the same way: the silver under the plating is what tarnishes once the layer wears. None of them can rust, because neither silver nor gold contains iron.

Vermeil vs ordinary gold plating

The difference is thickness. Vermeil's 2.5-micron minimum is the same figure the FTC uses for heavy gold electroplate, and about 14 times the 0.175-micron minimum for ordinary gold electroplate (2.5 ÷ 0.175 = 14.3). A piece described only as gold-plated sterling may carry far less gold than vermeil and show silver much sooner.

There is no standard lifespan for either, because three things decide it: the thickness of the gold, the kind of piece (earrings and pendants rub less than rings and bracelets) and how often it meets chlorine, salt water and abrasion. More in how long gold plating lasts.

Re-plating vermeil at JewelryRepair.com

Once silver shows through, re-plating is the fix. Gold Plating starts by polishing the silver to a clean, bright surface, because plating copies whatever lies beneath it; the piece is then cleaned ultrasonically and with steam and run through an activation bath so the gold bonds metal-to-metal. You choose the thickness. On a sterling ring or pendant:

  • Flash plating: $60, the thinnest layer.
  • 1–2 microns: $310 ($60 + $250).
  • 2–3 microns: $385 ($60 + $325). The low end of this range is thinner than the 2.5-micron vermeil minimum, so choose 3–4 microns if thickness matters to you.
  • 3–4 microns: $460 ($60 + $400), thicker than the FTC's 2.5-micron vermeil minimum.
  • 4+ microns: $535 ($60 + $475).

These are thickness choices only. If you need the finished piece to meet the FTC vermeil definition, which also requires gold of 10 karat or better throughout, ask for a free quote on the contact page before ordering. Earrings add $25, a bracelet $35 and a necklace $50. A rose gold finish adds $52 ($112 for a flash-plated ring) and a white gold finish $65; for a white look on sterling, Rhodium Plating is $69 for a ring. Plated pieces that need solder work, such as a broken clasp, are quoted before any work begins.

JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, working from our New York studio. Our 1-year workmanship guarantee covers plating that wears prematurely; ordinary wear beyond that standard isn't covered. Shipping is $30 round trip by UPS with a prepaid label in your account and $100 of coverage each way.

Questions

Does gold vermeil turn green?
It can, but it's less common than with gold-plated brass. Green is copper corrosion, and sterling silver is mostly silver with a small share of copper, so worn vermeil more often darkens gray or black. A piece that turns green quickly, or shows pink or brassy metal where the gold wears, may be gold-plated brass rather than vermeil. Metal Testing at JewelryRepair.com confirms the base metal for $15.
Does gold vermeil fade?
Not in the sense of the color washing out. Gold keeps its color; what happens is that the layer wears thin at rub points, such as the back of a ring or the edge of a hoop, until the paler silver shows through and then tarnishes. That reads as fading. Re-plating restores it: Gold Plating on a sterling silver ring or pendant at JewelryRepair.com starts at $60 for flash plating.
Can you shower or swim with gold vermeil?
It's better not to. Jewelers Mutual warns that pool chlorine and ocean salt can rapidly tarnish metals. Soap and shampoo also cause buildup, Jewelers Mutual notes, which dulls the gold, and any spot where the gold has worn thin tarnishes faster when it stays wet. Take vermeil off for the shower, pool and beach, and dry it fully if it does get wet.
Is vermeil better than gold-plated jewelry?
Usually, yes. Under the FTC's guides, vermeil needs a sterling silver base and at least 2.5 microns of 10-karat-or-better gold, while ordinary gold electroplate can be far thinner and sit over any base metal. Gold-filled jewelry, which the same FTC guides define by the weight of karat gold rather than its thickness, is a different and generally heavier construction. Vermeil is still plating, though, and it wears. Solid karat gold is the only option with no layer to wear through.
Does 18K gold vermeil tarnish less than 14K?
Not in a way you'd notice. The karat describes the gold layer, and both 14K and 18K gold resist tarnish; what tarnishes is the sterling silver underneath once the gold wears through. Thickness matters more than karat for how long that takes, so when comparing pieces, ask for the plating thickness in microns, not just the karat.
Can a jeweler clean or restore tarnished vermeil?
Yes. If the gold is intact, a gentle wash restores the shine; if silver shows through, re-plating restores the color. Gold Plating on a sterling silver ring or pendant at JewelryRepair.com is $60 for flash plating or $385 for 2 to 3 microns. The Jewelry Spa ($44 for a sterling ring) ends with a hand polish, so for vermeil ask for a free quote first.