Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Does real gold tarnish, including 10K, 14K and 18K gold?

Pure 24K gold doesn't tarnish: it doesn't react with oxygen at any temperature, or with sulfur directly. Karat gold can, because the copper and silver alloyed into it react with sulfur, sweat and cosmetics. Tarnish shows up mostly on low-karat gold such as 10K, occasionally on 14K and 18K, and gentle cleaning usually removes it.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

41.7%gold in 10K (14K is 58.3%, 18K is 75%, 24K is pure)
$55Jewelry Polishing for a 14K yellow gold ring ($30 + $17 + $8)
$15Metal Testing & Verification, per item
50,000+repairs since 1989, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue

The short version

  • 24K (pure) gold: doesn't tarnish. Gold is one of the least reactive elements.
  • 18K (75% gold) and 14K (58.3% gold): occasionally darken, usually in crevices and on the back of a ring. 18K has less alloy to react, so it resists better.
  • 10K (41.7% gold): the most likely to tarnish, because more than half of it is other metals.
  • What darkens is the alloy, mainly copper and silver, not the gold.
  • Solid gold doesn't fade, because its color runs all the way through. Plated gold wears through, and white gold's rhodium wears off; neither is tarnish.
  • Not sure what you have? Metal Testing & Verification settles it for $15.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Polishing from $30Tarnish and fine scratches removed through progressively finer compounds, details worked by hand. Yellow gold ring: $47 in 10K ($30 + $17), $55 in 14K, $63 in 18K. 14K yellow necklace $130 ($30 + $75 + $17 + $8).
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish with a written inspection report. 14K yellow gold ring $59 ($44 + $10 + $5); 14K yellow chain or bracelet $71 ($44 + $12 + $10 + $5).
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked under magnification, metal and karat tested and documented, for when you can't tell solid gold from filled or plated.
Gold Plating from $60For plated pieces worn through to the metal underneath. $60 for a silver ring or pendant, $110 for a silver necklace ($60 + $50); brass adds $113. Thicker layers are priced by micron.
Rhodium Plating from $69For white gold that has turned yellowish as its rhodium wears. A 14K white gold ring is $79 ($69 + $8 + $2).

Why karat decides how much gold can tarnish

Karat counts gold in 24ths. The World Gold Council's chart puts 24K at pure gold, 22K at 91.7%, 18K at 75%, 14K at 58.3%, 10K at 41.7% and 9K at 37.5%. The rest is alloy metal, often copper and silver, which hardens the gold and sets its color: copper gives rose gold its pink, and white gold uses whiter metals such as palladium or silver.

Gold itself barely reacts. It doesn't react with oxygen at any temperature and doesn't react with sulfur directly, which is why Jewelers Mutual says pure gold does not tarnish while noting that almost all gold jewelry is an alloy. The other metals do react. Writing on Ganoksin in association with the World Gold Council, Christopher Corti describes tarnish on karat gold as superficial corrosion that attacks the base metals, particularly copper, and the silver, leaving mainly copper oxides and silver sulfides. He notes it is generally seen in lower-karat golds of 8 to 10 karat and occasionally in 14 and 18 karat.

High karat isn't completely immune. Corti also reports blackened 21K and 22K jewelry from India and the Middle East; analysis of 22K pieces found a layer of silver and copper sulfide, and the pieces weren't under-karated. The cause wasn't confirmed. Karat sets the odds; sweat, cosmetics and storage decide what actually happens to a piece.

What 'tarnished' gold usually turns out to be

  • True tarnish: a dull brownish to dark tint, often in crevices, behind settings and inside a band. Rub a hidden spot with a soft white cloth; tarnish leaves a gray or dark smudge with bright metal underneath.
  • Black marks on your skin: Corti explains these come from a tarnish product rubbing off the jewelry during wear. They're harmless, though unsightly, and most common with low-karat gold, though they can appear with 18K too.
  • Everyday grime: lotion, soap and skin oil leave a greasy dullness that washes straight off.
  • Worn plating: gold electroplate can be as thin as 0.175 microns under the FTC's Jewelry Guides. When it wears through, the base metal shows as a dark or coppery patch that no amount of wiping changes. See does gold-plated jewelry tarnish?
  • Yellowing white gold: the bright white is rhodium plating, which wears off to show the warmer alloy, usually at the back of the band first. See does white gold tarnish?
  • A green finger: usually copper in a low-karat or plated piece reacting with skin. See why does my ring turn my finger green?

How to keep gold from darkening

  • Keep chlorine away from it. Jewelers Mutual warns that chlorine, especially at hot-tub temperatures, can permanently damage or discolor gold jewelry, and to take gold off when cleaning with bleach.
  • Put it on last. Corti lists perfume, hairspray and deodorant sprays among the causes of tarnish, along with sweat, which is rich in salt, and sulfur-rich or acidic foods such as onions and pickles.
  • Wipe it after wearing. A soft cloth removes sweat and early tarnish before either builds up.
  • Store it dry. Corti recommends a pouch or bag in a dry, unpolluted place, and says any box, pouch or plastic bag should be free of sulfur-containing compounds, which some storage boxes contain.

Solid, filled or plated? How to tell

Tarnish on its own doesn't mean gold is fake, since solid 10K can tarnish. The stamp tells you more:

  • Solid gold: 10K or 417, 14K or 583 or 585, 18K or 750, 24K or 999, usually inside a band or near a clasp.
  • Gold filled: marked GF, often with a fraction such as 1/20 14K GF. A bonded layer of karat gold making up at least 1/20 of the metal's weight. See does gold-filled jewelry tarnish?
  • Plated: GP or RGP marks a mechanically bonded gold layer (at least 1/40 of the metal weight), and GEP marks gold electroplate (at least 0.175 microns). Either way, it is a gold layer over another metal. Heavy gold electroplate must be at least 2.5 microns.
  • Vermeil: sterling silver plated with gold of at least 10K, at least 2.5 microns thick.

Stamps can be faint, missing or counterfeit. Metal Testing & Verification ($15 per item) checks the hallmarks under magnification, then tests the metal and karat directly and documents the result. If you're booking a repair anyway, choose "Not sure" for the metal and testing is included at no charge.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in repair service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. For tarnished or dull solid gold:

  • Jewelry Polishing: a yellow gold ring is $47 in 10K ($30 + $17), $55 in 14K ($30 + $17 + $8) and $63 in 18K ($30 + $17 + $16). A 14K yellow gold necklace is $130 ($30 + $75 + $17 + $8).
  • Jewelry Spa: $59 for a 14K yellow gold ring ($44 + $10 + $5), $71 for a 14K yellow gold chain or bracelet ($44 + $12 + $10 + $5), with a written inspection report.
  • Rhodium Plating for white gold gone yellowish: $79 for a 14K white gold ring ($69 + $8 + $2). Rhodium plating cost covers how long it lasts: about 1 to 3 years on a ring.
  • Gold Plating for plated pieces worn through: from $60 for a silver ring or pendant, $110 for a silver necklace with flash plating ($60 + $50), $223 for a brass-based necklace ($60 + $50 + $113); thicker layers start at +$250 (1 to 2 microns).

Every repair price already includes a clean and polish, and plated pieces that need polishing are priced by free quote, because polishing can cut through plating. A darkened piece is photographed on arrival and again before it ships back, so the photos show exactly what the clean or polish removed, and the work carries a 1-year workmanship guarantee.

Questions

Does 14K gold tarnish?
Occasionally, and usually only lightly. 14K is 58.3% gold, so the rest is alloy metal, mostly copper and silver, which can darken with sweat, perfume, chlorine and sulfur in the air. Christopher Corti's review, published in association with the World Gold Council, notes tarnish occasionally in 14K and more often in 8 to 10K. Warm water, mild dish soap and a soft brush usually remove it; polishing a 14K yellow gold ring by mail is $55.
Does 10K gold tarnish or turn black?
It can, more readily than higher karats. 10K is 41.7% gold, so more than half of it is alloy metal, and tarnish on gold is generally seen in 8 to 10 karat pieces. It may darken in crevices or leave black marks on skin, which Corti describes as harmless. Clean it with soap and water and a soft brush; polishing a 10K yellow gold ring at JewelryRepair.com is $47.
Does 18K gold tarnish?
Only occasionally. 18K is 75% gold, so there's much less copper and silver to react, although Corti notes tarnish can still appear at 18K now and then. What 18K shows more is wear: higher-karat gold has less hardening alloy, so 18K tends to show scratches sooner than 14K. Polishing removes those fine scratches; at JewelryRepair.com, an 18K yellow gold ring is $63 ($30 + $17 + $16).
Does 14K gold or a gold chain fade over time?
Solid 14K gold doesn't fade, because the color runs all the way through the alloy. It can dull from fine scratches and grime, and low-karat chains can tarnish in the links. A gold-plated chain is different: the thin gold layer wears through and the metal underneath shows. Re-plating with Gold Plating at JewelryRepair.com is $110 for a silver-based necklace ($60 + $50) and $223 for a brass-based one ($60 + $50 + $113).
Does real gold rust?
No. Rust is a corrosion product of iron, and gold doesn't react with oxygen at any temperature. What looks like rust on gold jewelry is usually tarnish on the copper in a low-karat alloy, the base metal showing through worn plating, or plain dirt. A green mark on the skin usually points to copper; a test with Metal Testing & Verification ($15) tells you what the piece really is.
If my gold tarnishes, does that mean it's fake?
Not necessarily. Solid karat gold can tarnish, especially 10K, because of the copper and silver in the alloy. Check the stamp: 10K, 14K, 585 or 750 alone suggests solid gold, while GF, GP or GEP means a gold layer over another metal. Stamps can be wrong, so Metal Testing & Verification at JewelryRepair.com tests the metal and karat and documents it for $15.