Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing
Do brass, copper and costume jewelry tarnish?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version, metal by metal
- Brass (copper plus zinc): tarnishes. It goes brown, then darker, and can grow a green-blue patina where moisture and acids sit.
- Copper: tarnishes and is the usual cause of green marks on skin.
- Bronze (copper plus tin): behaves like brass, darkening and sometimes going green.
- Nickel silver or German silver: no silver at all; copper, nickel and zinc, so it tarnishes like brass (see the FAQ below).
- Pewter: dulls slowly to gray. Lead-free modern pewter is mostly tin with a little antimony and copper; older pewter could be up to 40% lead, and higher-lead pewter tarnishes faster and darker.
- Aluminum: doesn't blacken or go green. A thin oxide layer forms on it and protects the metal underneath, which is exactly what iron rust fails to do.
- Zinc alloy: bare zinc dulls quickly in air, then that dull layer protects it. On a plated zinc-alloy piece, that dull gray shows wherever the plating wears.
- Iron and plain steel: rust orange-brown when they stay damp, and the flaky rust doesn't stop the corrosion underneath.
- "Fake" gold or silver (plated costume jewelry): looks like gold or silver until the plating wears, then shows the base metal and its tarnish.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Gold Plating | $173 brass ring or pendant, flash $240 copper ring or pendant, flash | Brass and copper are listed base metals. The jeweler polishes the surface, cleans it ultrasonically and with steam, activates it, gives copper an underlayer first, then plates yellow, rose or white gold. Brass earrings are $198 ($60 + $25 + $113), a brass necklace $223 ($60 + $50 + $113); thicker layers add $250 to $475. |
| Rhodium Plating | from $74 ring, gold-plated / fashion from $94 earrings from $114 necklace | For silver-tone fashion pieces whose bright finish has worn to yellow or brown: polished, cleaned and given a fresh rhodium layer, priced on the Gold-plated / fashion metal option. |
| Metal Testing & Verification | $15 | Find out whether a "silver" or "gold" piece is solid, plated or base metal before you spend money on it: stamps checked under magnification, metal tested and documented. |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | For a broken costume piece that doesn't fit a listed repair option: a jeweler examines it under magnification and sends an itemized quote with photos before any work. |
The details: why copper-based metals change color
Copper is the common thread: brass, bronze and nickel silver are all copper alloys. Damp air, salts, ammonia and acids all attack brass. Sulfur in the air turns its copper brown and then black, and where damp, slightly acidic conditions keep working on it, that dark layer can give way to a green-blue patina (Wikipedia, Brass). The Canadian Conservation Institute separates the two: on copper alloys, tarnish is black, while the more serious corrosion is green or blue-green, sometimes red underneath.
Jewelers Mutual says humid storage speeds brass tarnish, that scratches expose fresh metal and trap dirt and moisture, and that chlorine and other chemicals in water accelerate it, so brass should come off before the shower, the pool or the hot tub.
Costume jewelry adds a layer of complication. Most of it is brass under a thin coat of gold or silver, and cheaper pieces may plate pewter, nickel or other base metals instead (Wikipedia, Costume jewelry). Once the plating wears at edges and contact points, the copper alloy underneath starts tarnishing and marking skin. The FTC's guides allow electroplate sold as gold plated to be as thin as 0.175 microns of fine gold, so on a ring or bracelet that rubs all day, that can happen quickly.
Green skin, dark skin and allergies
A green ring around your finger is copper at work: Science Notes explains that copper reacting with salts, acids and other chemicals on skin forms green or blue-green compounds, typically harmless and washable, while a red, itchy rash means irritation or a metal allergy. The full explanation, including dark marks from silver, is in why does my ring turn my finger green?
An allergy is a separate issue, and nickel is the usual cause. The American Academy of Dermatology estimates that more than 18 percent of people in North America are allergic to nickel and names earrings, earring backs and watches among the biggest culprits. That's why "nickel-free" and "tarnish-free" aren't the same claim: nickel-free brass is still copper and zinc, and it still darkens.
How to tell what your piece is made of
- Look at the wear points. A different color at edges, clasp ends or the inside of a ring means plating over something else.
- Read the stamp. 925, Sterling, 14K or 585 suggest solid precious metal; no mark at all is common on brass and plated pieces. EPNS means silver plated onto nickel silver.
- Try a magnet. The Canadian Conservation Institute notes copper and brass aren't magnetic, but brass-plated iron is. A pull means iron or steel underneath.
- Watch the color it turns. Black or brown, with green in damp spots, points to copper alloy; orange-brown crust points to iron.
- Test it. Stamps can be wrong. Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item and documents what you have.
How to clean and protect it: solid versus plated
Solid brass, bronze or copper can take more than precious metal can. Jewelers Mutual's brass routine runs from warm water and mild dish soap for light dirt, to lemon juice and salt for moderate tarnish, to a paste of baking soda and vinegar for heavy tarnish, always tested on a hidden spot first, scrubbed gently and rinsed well; it notes vinegar left on too long dulls brass. A polish made for brass jewelry works too. Avoid automotive and stainless-steel polishes: the Canadian Conservation Institute says their hard particles scratch copper alloys, and ammonia in many metal polishes can dissolve copper.
Plated costume jewelry gets none of that: Jewelers Mutual lists baking soda, vinegar, hydrogen peroxide and hot water among home cleaners that can damage plating. Mild soap, warm water, a soft brush and a full dry are enough; see cleaning tarnished costume jewelry.
For either kind, take pieces off for showers, swimming and workouts, and store each in its own pouch somewhere drier than the bathroom; keeping costume jewelry from tarnishing covers the rest. A wax or lacquer coating slows tarnish on solid brass, though the institute notes lacquer always changes the look a little.
When a cloth won't fix it: what we can and can't do
When the plating has worn through or you want a different color, Gold Plating lists both brass and copper as base metals. With flash plating in yellow gold, a brass ring or pendant is $173 ($60 + $113) and a copper one $240 ($60 + $180). Copper gets an underlayer before the gold because it resists plating, and a 1–2 micron layer adds $250. For a silver-tone fashion piece gone yellow or brown, Rhodium Plating on the Gold-plated / fashion option is $74 for a ring ($69 + $5), $94 for earrings ($69 + $20 + $5) and $114 for a necklace ($69 + $40 + $5).
Re-plating often costs more than a costume piece did new, so it makes sense for vintage pieces, gifts and anything you can't replace. Broken costume jewelry is a different job. A few repair pages list a Gold-plated / fashion metal option, such as Chain Soldering, from $47 for one break ($30 + $17), and Earring Post Repair, from $46 a pair ($30 + $16). A plated piece that needs polishing is quoted first, because polishing cuts through plating, and whether a costume piece can take solder heat depends on how it was made. For anything without a listed option, ask for a free, itemized quote through the contact page (a jeweler replies within 1 business day) or book the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full toward the work you approve. More in can costume jewelry be repaired?
Several costume pieces can share one box and one $30 round-trip UPS label. JewelryRepair.com, the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, has done over 50,000 repairs since 1989.
Questions
Does brass jewelry turn your skin green?
Does nickel-free jewelry tarnish?
Does German silver tarnish?
Can tarnished brass jewelry be gold plated?
Does aluminum or zinc alloy jewelry tarnish?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list