Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

How do you clean tarnished or rusty costume jewelry?

Start gently: wipe costume (fashion or "fake") jewelry with a soft cloth dampened in warm, soapy water, then dry it at once. Most is thin plating over brass, copper or another base metal, so acids, pastes and hard scrubbing strip the finish with the tarnish. Green or rusty spots mean the base metal is showing.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$19Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full toward the repair
$173flash gold plating on a brass ring ($60 + $113)
$15Metal Testing & Verification, per item (free within a repair)
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • To untarnish cheap or fake jewelry, start with soap and water on a soft cloth or cotton swab, not a long soak, and dry it immediately.
  • Save lemon, salt, vinegar and baking soda for solid, unplated brass and copper. On plated pieces they remove the plating.
  • Green is copper corrosion; red-brown flakes are rust on an iron or steel part. Both usually mean the plating has failed in that spot.
  • Cleaning can't put back worn plating. Only re-plating can.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Mail-In Evaluation $19A jeweler photographs the piece, examines it under magnification and sends an itemized quote; approve all, some or none. The $19 is credited in full toward approved work.
Gold Plating from $60Base polished, cleaned and activated, then plated in yellow, rose or white gold; copper and stainless steel get an underlayer first. Flash plating on a ring: $173 over brass, $240 over copper ($60 + $180), $211 over stainless steel ($60 + $151). Pieces with glued stones, pearls or enamel are quoted first.
Rhodium Plating from $69A bright white finish for silver-tone fashion pieces: $74 for a ring ($69 + $5 for gold-plated / fashion metal). Pieces with glued stones are quoted first.
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked and the metal tested and documented, before you clean or plate an inherited piece that might be sterling or gold. Free when you choose "Not sure" on a repair.

First, figure out what it's made of

Most costume jewelry is a base metal, such as brass, copper, pewter, zinc alloy or steel, with a thin coat of gold or silver color; a few better pieces are sterling silver or vermeil. The base under the color decides how you clean it. Clues:

  • A 925 or Sterling stamp: clean it as silver. See how to clean tarnished sterling silver.
  • Yellow or pinkish metal showing at the edges: a brass or copper base under worn plating.
  • Gray metal showing: pewter, nickel or steel. A magnet that sticks points to iron, steel or nickel, though some stainless steel isn't magnetic.
  • No stamp, and it matters to you: if you're ordering a repair or re-plating anyway, choose "Not sure" for the metal and it is tested at no charge. On its own, Metal Testing & Verification is $15 an item. Stamps can be wrong, and heavy plating over base metal is the most common surprise in inherited jewelry.

How to clean it, problem by problem

  • Dull grime (any piece): Jewelers Mutual calls soap and water the gentlest, safest way to clean any metal. For costume pieces, wipe rather than soak: a soft cloth or cotton swab dampened in warm water with a drop of mild dish soap, then a barely damp cloth, then dry at once.
  • Dark tarnish on solid, unplated brass or copper: Jewelers Mutual suggests a tablespoon each of salt and lemon juice in water, from a few minutes to an hour depending on the tarnish, with light scrubbing, or a paste of baking soda and vinegar left a few minutes. Vinegar left too long dulls brass, so dilute it, and test any method on a hidden spot first.
  • Dark tarnish on a plated piece: stop at soap, water and a soft, untreated cloth. The Canadian Conservation Institute warns that polishing can damage thin silver plating or remove it entirely; gold-tone plating on costume pieces is just as thin, and acids and pastes strip it too.
  • Green crust: copper corrosion, the green to blue-green copper salts that form on copper, brass and bronze. On solid brass or copper, the lemon-and-salt method lifts it. On a plated piece, loosen it with a dry soft brush or wooden toothpick, wipe with soapy water, dry, and wash your hands; the bare patch stays bare.
  • Rust: only iron and steel rust, so on costume jewelry it usually means a steel part, such as a pin stem, a spring or a plated steel base. Lift loose flakes with a dry brush and keep the piece dry, since rust needs water and oxygen. Rust replaces solid metal with brittle compounds, so a badly rusted pin or clasp part may need replacing. Sterling silver doesn't rust: red-brown or black on silver is tarnish. See can sterling silver get wet or rust?
  • Rhinestones and glued stones: rhinestones are usually glass or acrylic, often with a metallic coating on the back that water can cloud, and in costume pieces our bench often finds them glued in rather than set. Clean around them with a barely damp swab and never soak the piece.

What not to do

  • No toothpaste or baking-soda scrubs on plated pieces. Jewelers Mutual warns these abrasives scratch softer metals; on plating they wear straight through.
  • No commercial silver cleaners on pieces with stones, which Jewelers Mutual warns may damage gemstones.
  • No long soaks, bleach or chlorine. Water creeps behind glued stones and feeds rust, and Jewelers Mutual says chlorine in pool, tub and shower water speeds up tarnish on brass.
  • No rotary tools or wire brushes, which take plating off with the dirt.

When cleaning isn't enough

If the gold or silver color is gone and brass, copper or gray metal shows through, no cleaner will bring it back; the piece needs a new layer. With Gold Plating at JewelryRepair.com, flash plating is $173 for a brass ring ($60 + $113), $198 for brass earrings ($60 + $25 + $113) and $223 for a brass necklace ($60 + $50 + $113); thicker layers add $250 to $475. For silver-tone pieces, Rhodium Plating is $74 for a ring. If you choose "Not sure" for the base metal, it is tested at no charge and the exact price is set once it's confirmed.

Not every costume piece can go straight into the baths. Gold Plating runs the piece through ultrasonic and steam cleaning and an activation bath, so pieces with glued rhinestones, pearls or enamel can't go through as they are, and pewter and zinc aren't listed base metals. Plated pieces that need polishing or soldering, such as a broken clasp, are quoted before any work, and pewter is delicate at the bench: it melts at around 170 to 230 °C. Send those for the Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full) before booking plating. See also can costume jewelry be repaired?

Re-plating costs more than many new fashion pieces, so it makes sense for vintage, signed or sentimental jewelry. JewelryRepair.com is run by Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, from our New York studio. Shipping is $30 round trip by UPS, the same however many pieces are in the box.

Keeping it from tarnishing again

  • Store pieces dry and apart in a closed box or pouch with an anti-tarnish strip or silica gel packet, as Jewelers Mutual suggests; scratches from other jewelry expose fresh metal that tarnishes faster.
  • Put jewelry on after perfume, hairspray, lotion and sunscreen, and take it off for the shower, pool and dishes.

More in how to keep plated and costume jewelry from tarnishing.

Questions

Can tarnished costume jewelry be restored?
Often, yes. Tarnish and grime on intact plating usually wipe off with mild soapy water and a soft cloth. If the plating has worn through to brass, copper or gray metal, cleaning won't bring the color back, but re-plating can on pieces without glued stones, pearls or enamel. A $19 Mail-In Evaluation at JewelryRepair.com, credited toward the work, tells you what's realistic before you commit.
How do you make fake silver jewelry shiny again?
Wash it, don't polish it. A soft cloth dampened with warm, soapy water, a clean damp wipe and a thorough dry bring back the shine on intact silver-tone plating; silver polish and dips take the thin color layer off. Where the silver tone has worn to yellow or copper-colored metal, it needs re-plating: Rhodium Plating on a fashion-metal ring is $74 at JewelryRepair.com, with glued-stone pieces quoted first.
Why does costume jewelry turn green?
Because there's copper in it. Brass and many plated pieces have copper in the base metal, and once the plating wears, the copper reacts with moisture, sweat and air to form green copper salts. The same reaction can leave a green mark on skin. Green spots on a piece usually mean the plating has failed there and needs re-plating, not just cleaning.
Can you fix rusted jewelry?
Sometimes. Light surface rust on a steel part can be brushed off dry, but rust replaces solid metal with brittle compounds, so a badly rusted pin, spring or clasp is weaker than it looks and may need replacing. At JewelryRepair.com, steel and plated pieces that need soldering are quoted before any work; a $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited toward the repair, is the easy way to find out.
Can I clean costume jewelry with vinegar?
Only solid, unplated brass or copper, and only briefly. Jewelers Mutual's vinegar and baking soda paste is meant for brass and sits just a few minutes; left too long, vinegar dulls brass, so dilute it. On gold- or silver-plated costume jewelry, acids can take the plating off with the tarnish. Start with mild soapy water and test anything stronger on a hidden spot.
Is it worth re-plating costume jewelry?
For a vintage, signed or sentimental piece, often yes; for one you could replace for less, usually not. Sending several pieces in one box helps, because shipping is charged once per order: three brass rings flash-plated together cost $549 ($173 × 3 + $30 shipping), or $183 each, against $203 for one ring sent alone ($173 + $30).