Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Is it safe to clean jewelry with vinegar, baking soda, toothpaste or hydrogen peroxide?

Mostly no. Warm water with mild dish soap is the safe household cleaner. Vinegar is an acid that dissolves pearls and harms porous stones, baking soda paste and toothpaste are abrasives that scratch metal and strip plating, and hydrogen peroxide disinfects but doesn't remove tarnish. The foil-and-baking-soda bath suits plain sterling only. A bench clean starts at $44.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

4%minimum acetic acid in US vinegar; distilled white vinegar is about pH 2.6
8-20%share of a typical toothpaste that is abrasive
2.5Mohs hardness GIA gives pearls: very soft and easily scratched
$44Jewelry Spa: ultrasonic, steam and hand-polish clean with a written report

The short version

  • Dish soap and warm water: safe for almost everything, and it removes what actually dulls jewelry: skin oil and lotion.
  • Vinegar and lemon juice: no for pearls, opal, turquoise, coral and plated pieces; no better than soap on gold and diamonds.
  • Baking soda: no as a paste or scrub; the foil bath (steps below) is for plain sterling only.
  • Toothpaste: no. It removes tarnish by scratching off metal.
  • Hydrogen peroxide: unnecessary. It doesn't lift tarnish or grease, and it's a risk to pearls and treated stones.
  • Ammonia: a few drops in soapy water for diamonds in gold or platinum only. Window cleaner isn't a jewelry cleaner.
  • Chlorine bleach: never.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic bath, steam, hand polish and a written inspection report. Sterling ring, earrings or pendant $44; 14K yellow gold ring $59 ($44 + $10 + $5); a bracelet or necklace adds $12.
Jewelry Polishing from $30Removes the haze of fine scratches that toothpaste and baking soda leave: sterling ring or earrings $30, 14K yellow gold ring $55 ($30 + $17 + $8).
Rhodium Plating from $69For white gold or rhodium-plated silver that harsh cleaning has dulled or yellowed: sterling ring $69, 14K white gold ring $79 ($69 + $8 + $2).
Gold Plating from $60 over silver
from $173 over brass
For gold-plated pieces scrubbed through to the metal underneath: yellow gold flash plating for a ring or pendant is $60 over sterling, $173 over brass ($60 + $113) and $240 over copper ($60 + $180).

Why kitchen cleaners don't do what you hope

Most of what makes jewelry look dull isn't dirt in the kitchen sense. It's skin oil, lotion and soap residue, and on silver, tarnish. Diamonds attract oil, which is why one worn every day soon looks cloudy. Oil comes off with a detergent, which is exactly what dish soap is, and it's why GIA and Jewelers Mutual both point to mild dish soap in warm water as the safe default.

The kitchen favorites are built for other jobs: vinegar for mineral deposits, baking soda for scouring, peroxide for disinfecting. Tarnish on silver is silver sulfide, which comes off in one of three ways: rubbed off (a silver cloth or polish), dissolved (a silver dip) or turned back into silver (the foil method). Vinegar and peroxide do none of these well, and toothpaste and baking soda paste manage the first only by taking metal with the tarnish.

Ingredient by ingredient

Vinegar (and lemon juice). US vinegar must contain at least 4% acetic acid, and distilled white vinegar sits around pH 2.6. That matters for anything made of calcium carbonate. Pearls are, and they can be dissolved in vinegar; GIA says pearls are damaged by all acids, and mother-of-pearl is the same nacre. GIA also notes turquoise can be discolored by chemicals, and says porous gems such as coral should be kept away from any chemicals. On plated and costume jewelry, acid that reaches brass or copper where the plating is thin can discolor it. Gold itself resists most acids and diamonds resist virtually all of them, so a brief vinegar soak is unlikely to harm a plain karat-gold diamond ring, but it won't clean it better than soap either.

Baking soda. Dissolved in water it's fairly harmless; as a paste, it's a scouring powder, and GIA notes that sterling silver and high-karat gold are soft and prone to scratches. The UK's Sheffield Assay Office goes further for silver: it says foil, baking soda, toothpaste, detergents and vinegar may all cause long-term damage to silver and gemstones if used often, and prefers a specialist silver cloth, used sparingly.

Toothpaste. Abrasives such as silica and calcium carbonate make up 8% to 20% of a typical toothpaste. GIA warns that abrasives like those in toothpaste can erode metal and scratch some gems. Toothpaste does take tarnish off sterling, by sanding it away with a thin layer of silver, and it leaves a haze of fine scratches. On plated pieces it rubs through the plating.

Hydrogen peroxide. Household peroxide is a 3% to 6% solution. Silver and platinum catalyze its breakdown into water and oxygen, so the fizzing on a silver or platinum ring is the peroxide decomposing, not grime lifting. It doesn't remove tarnish or dissolve skin oil the way soap does. It is a bleach; GIA says pearls can be damaged by many chemicals and all acids, and notes that excessive bleaching during processing can make some pearls more fragile, so keep peroxide off pearls. Keep it off emeralds too: GIA cites estimates that 90% or more are fracture-filled with oils, resins or polymers, and says chemicals can alter those fillings.

Ammonia. GIA says most diamond jewelry can be cleaned with a mild ammonia solution, unless the diamond has been treated, for example with a coating, and Jewelers Mutual's home method for gold adds a few drops of ammonia to dish soap and warm water. GIA also warns that the harsh chemicals in ammonia-based cleaners are wrong for organic and porous gems such as pearls, coral and turquoise. CCI notes that ammonia dissolves copper and that residue left in crevices can turn green, a reason to keep it off sterling and brass.

Chlorine bleach. Never. GIA warns that chlorine and other bleaching agents can damage some gemstones and metal alloys, and Jewelers Mutual says chlorine, especially when hot, can permanently damage or discolor gold.

The foil-and-baking-soda method, step by step

Silver touching aluminum in a hot baking soda solution has its tarnish converted back to silver without removing any silver, as a UC Davis chemistry demonstration shows. Use it only for plain sterling with no stones, pearls, glue or hollow parts.

  • Line a heat-safe glass or ceramic bowl with aluminum foil.
  • Add baking soda and a pinch of salt, then pour in water just off the boil. The UC Davis demo uses about 15 grams of baking soda per 100 mL of water; it notes the reaction still works without baking soda, only more slowly.
  • Lay the silver on the foil so it touches the aluminum; without contact, nothing happens. Bubbles rise from the tarnished areas as the silver brightens.
  • Lift it out once the tarnish is gone, then rinse well with distilled water to remove the solution and dry it completely, crevices included.

The Canadian Conservation Institute (CCI), describing the same method with washing soda, adds caveats: rinse well with distilled water, keep sealed hollow parts out of any water bath, and expect the silver to tarnish more quickly than polished silver. Because a darkened (oxidized) finish is itself silver sulfide, the bath can lighten it too. More on its limits in how to clean tarnished sterling silver.

Which household cleaner, by material

  • Solid gold, platinum and diamonds: soap and water, with a few drops of ammonia if you like. Vinegar and peroxide add nothing.
  • Sterling silver: the foil bath for plain pieces; no toothpaste, baking soda paste or ammonia.
  • Plated, vermeil and costume: no vinegar, no abrasives; soap and water briefly, then dry at once.
  • Emeralds, opals, turquoise, pearls and coral: none of these agents. GIA calls warm soapy water the safest method for emerald and the only safe one for opal.

For a full home routine, see the safest way to clean jewelry at home.

If the damage is already done

  • Hazy, scratched metal from toothpaste or baking soda: polishing removes the scratched surface. Jewelry Polishing is $30 for a sterling ring and $55 for a 14K yellow gold ring ($30 + $17 + $8).
  • Plating scrubbed through to a coppery or gray metal underneath: only new plating restores the color. Gold Plating for a ring or pendant is $60 over sterling, $173 over brass ($60 + $113) and $240 over copper ($60 + $180); Rhodium Plating on plated or fashion jewelry is $74 ($69 + $5). Plated pieces that need polishing are priced by free quote.
  • White gold turning yellowish: that's the rhodium plating wearing through, and abrasive cleaning speeds it up. Re-plating a 14K white gold ring is $79 ($69 + $8 + $2).
  • Pearls that look chalky, pitted or dull after vinegar or peroxide: lost nacre can't be polished back. A jeweler can examine the strand with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full; if the cord is the only problem, Pearl Restringing for genuine pearls is $35 plus $4 per inch ($15 + $20 pearls option), so an 18-inch strand is $107 ($35 + 18 × $4), or $132 hand-knotted (+$25).
  • A stone that now moves after scrubbing: Stone Tightening, from $50. A cloudy emerald or opal starts with the evaluation.

What a bench clean does that a kitchen soak can't

A kitchen soak can't flush out residue packed behind stones or show you a prong that's wearing thin. The Jewelry Spa at JewelryRepair.com, the mail-in repair service of Sky Jewelry in New York: an ultrasonic bath, a steam jet, a hand polish and a written inspection report. It's $44 for a sterling ring, earrings or pendant and $59 for a 14K yellow gold ring ($44 + $10 + $5). Every repair already includes a clean and polish.

The Spa's ultrasonic and steam steps aren't suitable for pearls, opal, emerald, turquoise or coral; GIA advises against them for these. For a piece with any of those, ask for a free quote through the on-site chat or contact form, or start with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full. Each piece is photographed on arrival and before it ships back. JewelryRepair.com is run by Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue who have completed over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

Questions

Can you clean sterling silver with baking soda and aluminum foil?
Yes, if it's plain sterling with no stones, pearls, glue or hollow parts. In a hot baking soda solution, silver touching aluminum has its tarnish converted back to silver without losing any metal. Rinse well afterward to remove the solution; the Canadian Conservation Institute notes silver cleaned this way may tarnish more quickly than polished silver. Keep oxidized pieces out, because the bath can lighten their dark finish, and never scrub silver with baking soda paste.
Can you clean gold with vinegar or baking soda?
You can, but neither helps much, and baking soda paste can harm it. Gold itself resists most acids, so a brief vinegar soak is unlikely to hurt plain karat gold, but vinegar doesn't cut skin oil the way dish soap does and can damage pearls, turquoise and the brass under gold plating. Baking soda paste is abrasive, and GIA notes higher-karat gold is the softest and most prone to scratches. Use warm water with mild dish soap.
Can you clean a diamond ring with hydrogen peroxide?
You can, but it won't do much. Peroxide is a disinfectant and bleach; it doesn't break down the oil and lotion that make a diamond look cloudy, and diamonds attract oil. A few drops of mild dish soap in warm water, a soft brush and a rinse work better. Keep peroxide away from any pearls, emeralds or other treated stones in the same piece.
Does toothpaste remove tarnish from sterling silver?
Yes, but by scratching it off. A typical toothpaste is 8% to 20% abrasive, so it sands the tarnish away together with a thin layer of silver and leaves fine scratches that dull the surface. GIA advises against abrasives like those in toothpaste. A silver polishing cloth removes light tarnish with far less abrasion, and Jewelry Polishing at JewelryRepair.com takes out existing scratches from $30.
Can you clean jewelry with Windex?
It isn't recommended; use a mild ammonia solution instead, and only on diamonds in gold or platinum. GIA says most diamond jewelry can take a mild ammonia solution unless the diamond has been treated, for example with a coating, and warns that ammonia-based cleaners are too harsh for pearls, coral and turquoise. Ammonia also dissolves copper, so keep it off sterling silver and brass. Mix a few drops into warm soapy water and rinse thoroughly.
Can you clean sterling silver with vinegar?
Not well, and it isn't worth the risk. Vinegar doesn't dissolve silver sulfide tarnish the way a silver dip does, and the Sheffield Assay Office lists vinegar among home remedies that may cause long-term damage to silver and gemstones if used often. For grime, use warm soapy water; for tarnish on plain sterling, a silver polishing cloth or the foil-and-baking-soda bath above; for heavy tarnish or scratches, Jewelry Polishing at JewelryRepair.com starts at $30.