Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing
Does rhodium plating or clear nail polish help sensitive ears?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Rhodium plating helps, for a while. It covers the metal underneath with one that doesn't corrode, and Wikipedia's nickel allergy entry lists rhodium plating as a way to keep wearing favorite pieces. The layer is thin and wears, though.
- Clear nail polish is a stopgap. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) suggests it as a barrier on things like clothing fasteners but says it needs re-applying often; DermNet advises against it on earring studs because it soon chips off.
- Nickel is the usual culprit. The AAD says more than 18 percent of people in North America are allergic to it and names earrings and earring backs among the biggest culprits.
- Check the backs too. A gold stud on a base-metal back still puts that back against your skin; see the most secure earring backs and earring backs for sleeping.
- For tarnish, rhodium works well on sterling silver, because rhodium itself doesn't tarnish. Nail polish is patchy protection at best.
- A rash that won't settle, or a sore, weeping piercing, is a question for a doctor, not a jeweler.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Rhodium Plating | from $89 silver earrings | Polished to a flawless surface, cleaned ultrasonically and with steam, then plated with fresh rhodium, a barrier between skin and the metal underneath while it lasts. 14K white gold earrings $99 ($69 + $20 + $8 + $2); gold-plated or fashion earrings $94 ($69 + $20 + $5). |
| Gold Plating | from $85 silver earrings | A cosmetic re-plate in yellow gold; a rose finish adds $52 ($137) and white $65 ($150), and thicker layers last longer (1 to 2 microns +$250). The listing says base metals that resist plating get an underlayer first without naming the metal, so it isn't sold as a nickel-free skin barrier: if you react to nickel, start with the Mail-In Evaluation or a free quote before booking. |
| Earring Post Repair | from $30 | A broken, bent or worn post replaced in the earring's own metal, soldered or laser-welded, never glued. Silver pair $30, single $20; 14K yellow gold pair $40 ($30 + $6 + $4). Changing a post to a different metal isn't a listed service: ask through the Mail-In Evaluation. |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | For earrings whose metal you don't know, pieces with pearls or soft stones, or a post you'd like changed: examined under magnification and quoted item by item with photos. Credited in full. |
Why earrings set off sensitive ears
Most reactions to earrings are allergic contact dermatitis from nickel. Wikipedia's summary of the research puts nickel allergy at about 8 to 19 percent of adults, with women affected 4 to 10 times as often as men, possibly because of greater exposure through jewelry and ear piercings. A post sits inside the piercing for hours at a time, so whatever the metal releases stays in close contact with the skin.
Nickel turns up in more places than people expect:
- White gold. DermNet notes that white gold and nine-carat gold contain nickel, and the rhodium that gives white gold its bright color also covers the alloy until it wears, so a reaction can start years after purchase. More in can you be allergic to white gold or sterling silver?
- Plated and costume jewelry. Plated jewelry can have a nickel-bearing base metal or underlayer; nickel silver, a common base metal, is about 20 percent nickel. When the top layer wears, that's what touches your ear.
- Earring backs and hooks. The AAD names earring backs alongside earrings, and a replacement back isn't always the same metal as the stud.
Not every sore earlobe is an allergy. Heavy drops, tight backs and posts that are too thick or too long can make a piercing sore too; see earring posts that are too long, short or thick.
Rhodium plating: what it does and doesn't do
Rhodium is a platinum-family metal that is hard, highly reflective and, as Wikipedia puts it, inert against corrosion and most aggressive chemicals. Electroplated over sterling silver, white gold or a plated fashion piece, it covers the original surface with a metal that doesn't tarnish, and Wikipedia's nickel allergy entry names rhodium plating, along with enamel, as a way to keep wearing heirlooms and wedding rings.
What it doesn't do is last forever. The plating is thin, and Wikipedia's rhodium entry notes that it wears away with use. On earrings the wear is concentrated where it matters most for sensitive ears: the post or hook that slides through the piercing each time you put them in, and the spot where the back grips. Our rhodium plating cost guide puts rhodium at about 1 to 3 years on a ring and often 3+ years on earrings, which barely touch anything. The post is the exception: it slides through the piercing, so it wears first, and a reaction can return before the front looks worn.
- It covers only what's plated. A separate back from another pair, or a post replaced later, isn't protected.
- The surface underneath matters. Rhodium reproduces every scratch and trace of oil beneath it, so the piece is polished and cleaned before plating.
- Check the listing. The FTC's jewelry guides include a section on disclosing a surface layer of rhodium, so a seller's description or tag is the first place to look for whether earrings were plated.
- It isn't a medical treatment. If you react even to freshly plated earrings, a dermatologist can patch test to find out what you're reacting to.
Clear nail polish: does it work?
Painting clear polish on posts and hooks is the classic home fix, and the dermatology sources are lukewarm. The AAD suggests coating items such as clothing fasteners with clear nail polish, with the warning that it will need to be re-applied often. DermNet, the New Zealand dermatology reference, goes further for earrings: it says coating the stud with nail varnish is not recommended, because the varnish soon chips off.
A post is the hardest place for any coating to survive, since it slides through the piercing every time you wear it. As a tarnish barrier on silver, polish has the same weakness: the Canadian Conservation Institute doesn't recommend lacquering or waxing silver because an even coating is hard to get, and nail polish is a lacquer brushed on by hand. If you try it anyway:
- Coat a clean, dry post or hook and let it cure fully before wearing.
- Keep it, and the remover, off pearls and treated stones. GIA warns that pearls can be damaged by many chemicals and that solvents can damage treated turquoise, and nail polish remover is a solvent.
- Check it often for chips and expect to redo it, as the AAD says.
- Stop if the reaction continues; the coating isn't doing its job.
Earring metals least likely to irritate
The AAD's advice is to wear jewelry that is nickel-free or hypoallergenic, or made of surgical-grade stainless steel, 18-, 22- or 24-karat yellow gold, pure sterling silver or platinum. DermNet lists hypoallergenic stainless steel, solid gold of 12 carat or more and silver as generally safe, notes that stainless steel doesn't usually cause dermatitis unless it is nickel-plated, and mentions plastic covers for earring studs.
"Hypoallergenic" on a label doesn't name the metal, so look for the metal itself on the listing or stamp; with yellow gold, a higher karat means less alloy. Not sure what your earrings are? Metal Testing & Verification, $15 per item, checks the hallmarks and tests and documents the metal and karat. It tells you what the metal is, not how much nickel it releases; for that, DermNet describes a spot test with dimethylglyoxime that turns a cotton bud pink when free nickel is present.
When plating isn't the answer, and the alternatives
- The post itself is the problem. If a stud's post is base metal, plating only buys time. Swapping a post to a different metal isn't a listed service at JewelryRepair.com, so start with the Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full); a jeweler examines the earrings and quotes what's possible before anything is done.
- A broken or bent post on gold, silver or platinum earrings is a standard repair: Earring Post Repair replaces it in the earring's own metal, soldered or laser-welded, never glued, from $30 a pair.
- Gold plating changes the color, but we can't promise it as a skin barrier: the Gold Plating listing says base metals that resist plating get an underlayer first without naming the metal. Wikipedia's gold plating entry defines a gold flash as under 0.5 micron and heavy plate as 2.5 microns or more. On silver earrings it's $85 as a yellow flash coat ($60 + $25) or $335 at 1 to 2 microns ($60 + $25 + $250); rose adds $52 and white $65. If you react to nickel, ask first through the Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited) or a free quote.
- Matching backs. Backs in the same metal as the earring remove one more source of contact; see replacing a lost earring back.
What it costs at JewelryRepair.com
Rhodium Plating for earrings is $89 in sterling silver ($69 + $20), $94 for gold-plated or fashion earrings ($69 + $20 + $5), $97 in 14K yellow gold ($69 + $20 + $6 + $2) and $99 in 14K white gold ($69 + $20 + $8 + $2). The jeweler polishes the earrings to a flawless surface, cleans them ultrasonically and with steam, then plates them. Earrings with pearls, opal or turquoise should start with the Mail-In Evaluation, since GIA warns against ultrasonic and steam cleaning for those stones.
The 1-year workmanship guarantee runs from the day the earrings are delivered back and covers plating that wears prematurely; ordinary plating wear beyond that standard isn't covered. Send both earrings, and their backs, so they match: shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, label ready in your account, $100 of coverage each way. Each earring is photographed when it reaches our New York studio and again before it goes back. JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in side of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989 with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.
Questions
Does rhodium plating make earrings hypoallergenic?
Does clear nail polish on earrings stop irritation or tarnish?
Can white gold earrings irritate sensitive ears?
Is rhodium-plated sterling silver good for sensitive ears?
How long does rhodium plating last on earrings?
Are gold-plated earrings OK for sensitive ears?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list