Jewelry repair questions · Earrings & pendants
Earring post too long, short or thick? How a jeweler fixes the fit
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Too long (it pokes your neck or behind your ear): try a snug new back first. If it still pokes, the post can be shortened and re-notched, or replaced.
- Too short (the back won't reach the notch): a longer post is the fix. Forcing a back past the notch only makes the earring easier to lose.
- Too thick (it won't go in, or it hurts): don't force it and don't file it. A thinner post is the fix.
- Too thin (it wobbles, droops or bends): a slightly heavier post, within what your piercing takes comfortably.
- At JewelryRepair.com: Earring Post Repair is $30 a pair in sterling silver and $40 in 14K yellow gold. If you need a particular length or thickness, ask for a free quote first, or start with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Earring Post Repair | from $30 pair, sterling silver, stick posts $40 pair, 14K yellow gold, stick posts | A new post in your earring's metal, soldered or laser-welded on in place of the old one, never glued. For a particular length or thickness, ask for a free quote first. One earring is $10 less; a 14K yellow gold pair is $40; screw posts add $15. |
| Earring Back Conversion | from $40 | A different back system fitted when the back, not the post, is the real problem: screw backs are $70 a pair in sterling silver ($40 + $30). |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | For posts beside pearls, opals or enamel, or earrings you're unsure about: examined under magnification, with an itemized quote and photos before any work. |
What decides the fit: thickness, length and the notch
Many jewelers make posts from 20 gauge wire, about 0.8mm, according to a 2012 Ganoksin thread on post sizes; the standard specs are in the glossary entry on the earring post. Fit comes down to two things: the post's thickness against your piercing, and where the notch sits. A friction back, the familiar butterfly kind, grips a notch or groove near the post's end, so the back has to reach that notch through your lobe and still sit comfortably behind it. To find the length that suits you, put on a stud that fits well, fasten the back where it's comfortable, and measure from the back of the lobe to the tip of the post. That number is what to put in a quote request.
Too long: why it pokes, and what to do
A post pokes when more of it sits behind your lobe than your ear needs, often on a thin lobe, or when the earring tilts and angles the tip toward your neck. Try these in order:
- Check the back. A worn back, or one pushed on past the notch, lets the earring tilt. A new back that clicks into the notch may be all it needs; see how to replace an earring back.
- Shorten it. A jeweler trims the post, rounds and smooths the tip so it passes through a piercing cleanly, and presses or cuts a new notch where the back should stop. On a plated earring, the cut end exposes the metal underneath.
- Replace it. If trimming would take off too much, or the post is worn, bent or straightened before, a new post at the right length is the cleaner fix.
Shortening an existing post, or fitting a new one at a particular length, isn't a separate listed option at JewelryRepair.com, so ask for a free quote through the contact page or the on-site chat; a jeweler replies within 1 business day with an itemized price, and nothing ships until you've seen it.
Too short: thick lobes and backs that won't catch
If the back only grips the very tip of the post, or won't click into the notch at all, the post is too short for your lobe, and the earring is held by friction alone. The fixes:
- A longer replacement post, soldered or laser-welded where the old one was. Send your measurement, or a stud that fits well as a reference, with a free quote request first, or start with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation.
- A different back, if the post reaches but the back works loose. Screw backs thread onto the post instead of relying on one notch. Converting a pair to screw backs is $70 in sterling silver on Earring Back Conversion ($40 + $30); see the most secure earring backs.
- Flat-back posts are another route; see whether earrings can be converted to flat backs.
Too thick or too thin
Too thick. A post that won't go in, or hurts going in, is thicker than your piercing. Filing it down takes metal from the part that carries the earring, can leave it uneven, and cuts through any plating; a new, thinner post is the fix. If a post that used to go in easily has stopped fitting, ask a piercer or a doctor before you change the earring.
Too thin. A thin post can bend or let a heavy earring tip forward. A slightly heavier post helps, up to what your piercing takes comfortably. For drops that sag, see earring backs for heavy, drooping earrings. If your ears react to some metals, pick the new post's metal with care; the American Academy of Dermatology suggests options such as sterling silver, platinum and 18K or higher yellow gold.
How a jeweler works out the fit
Fit work starts with measuring, not solder. The jeweler checks the post's thickness and length against what you've asked for and against the other earring, so the pair still matches, and for a shorter post moves the notch to where the back should stop. The replacement itself follows the same steps as any post repair, explained in whether a broken earring post can be fixed. At JewelryRepair.com the earrings are photographed on arrival at the New York studio and again before they ship back, and a second jeweler checks the work. Send both earrings, even if only one bothers you, with the backs you wear.
Can I fix it myself?
On an inexpensive pair, you can trim a too-long post with cutters, but the cut end must be filed round and smooth before it goes near a piercing, and if the notch sat near the end, the back will have nothing to catch on. Filing a post thinner weakens it and roughens the surface that sits in your ear. Glue isn't an option for changing a post; Earring Post Repair at JewelryRepair.com never uses it.
What it costs at JewelryRepair.com
Prices from the live repair pages, Nov 18, 2026. Each repair includes a clean and polish and the 1-year workmanship guarantee.
- Stick posts, per pair: sterling silver $30; 14K yellow gold $40 ($30 + $6 + $4); 14K white or rose gold $45 ($30 + $11 + $4). One earring is $10 less.
- Screw posts: +$15, so a 14K yellow gold pair is $55 ($40 + $15).
- A particular length or thickness, or shortening an existing post: by free quote.
- Plated and fashion earrings: the page books gold-plated / fashion pairs at $46 ($30 + $16); because heat and finishing can cut through plating, a jeweler may recommend a free quote first.
Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, however many pairs share the box. $100 of coverage is included each way; covering a $1,000 pair in full costs $22.50 (2.5% of the $900 above $100). JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in repair service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.
Questions
Can earring posts be shortened?
Why does my earring post poke my neck?
What can I do if my earring post is too short for my earlobe?
Can a thick earring post be made thinner?
Is it worth fixing the fit, or should I just buy new earrings?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list