Repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Is it safe to wear tarnished jewelry?

Usually, yes. Tarnish is a thin surface layer, mostly silver sulfide on silver, and the gray or black smudge it leaves on skin isn't considered toxic. The real risks sit underneath: plating worn through to nickel or copper, and grimy earring posts in a piercing. A red, itchy rash means stop wearing it. Professional cleaning starts at $44.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$44Jewelry Spa for a silver ring, earrings or pendant: ultrasonic, steam, hand polish and a written inspection report
$89Rhodium Plating for a pair of sterling silver earrings ($69 + $20), a barrier between the silver and your skin
18%+of people in North America are allergic to nickel, the American Academy of Dermatology estimates
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers on Lenox Avenue

The short version

  • Tarnish itself is harmless. It's a thin surface layer, and the dark smudge it leaves on skin washes off.
  • Look at what's under it. Dark or coppery patches on a plated piece usually mean the plating has worn through to the base metal.
  • A rash is a different problem. Redness, itching, scaling or blisters point to an allergy or irritation, not tarnish. Take the piece off, and see a dermatologist if it persists.
  • Earrings need the most care. In a healed piercing, the risks are nickel in the post and dirty posts and backs. A fresh piercing should have only implant-grade metals.
  • Tarnish doesn't hurt the silver. Removing it is for looks, and every polish takes a little metal with it.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish, with a written inspection report from the bench. A bracelet or necklace adds $12; gold adds a metal charge.
Jewelry Polishing from $30Tarnish and fine scratches taken off solid metal on the wheel and by hand, from a silver ring or earrings; a silver necklace is $105 ($30 + $75).
Rhodium Plating from $69Polish, clean and a fresh rhodium layer: the usual barrier on sterling and white gold. Earrings add $20.
Gold Plating from $60A new gold layer where plating has worn through. Base metals other than silver, and earrings or larger items, add to the price.
Mail-In Evaluation $19For green crust, pitting or damage you can't identify: examined under magnification, with photos and an itemized quote. Credited in full.

Why tarnish on its own isn't a health risk

Tarnish is metal reacting with sulfur in the air. On silver the product is silver sulfide, which Wikipedia's entry describes as insoluble in most solvents; its listed solubility in water is about six quadrillionths of a gram per liter, so it doesn't dissolve into sweat in any meaningful way.

When tarnish rubs onto skin, you see a gray or black mark. Science Notes, a science-education site, explains that mark as tarnish transferring from the metal and says the marks jewelry leaves on skin are generally harmless; green marks come from copper, which sterling silver and many gold alloys contain. Gold can tarnish too. Chris Corti, writing on Ganoksin, says it shows up mostly in 8 to 10 karat gold and occasionally in 14 and 18 karat, describes the resulting smudge as ugly rather than dangerous, and points to sweat, perfume, hair and deodorant sprays, and sulfur compounds in storage boxes as triggers. More in why rings turn fingers green or black.

Tarnish doesn't damage the silver either. The Canadian Conservation Institute (CCI) notes that a layer of tarnish helps protect silver against further tarnishing, and that each tarnish-and-clean cycle loses some silver.

When tarnish is a warning sign

The discoloration matters less than what it can reveal:

  • A plated piece with dark, coppery or gray patches. That's usually the base metal showing through worn plating. DermNet notes that in less expensive jewelry, nickel is often used in the base metal, which is then plated, so once the plating is gone that metal is against your skin. See does gold-plated jewelry tarnish?
  • Itching, redness, scaling or blisters under the piece. That's a skin reaction. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) estimates that more than 18 percent of people in North America are allergic to nickel, and counts earrings, their backs and watches among the most common sources. DermNet adds that irritation can also come from dirt on the metal and soap trapped under it. A dermatologist's patch test tells allergy from irritation; more in can you be allergic to white gold or sterling silver?
  • A white gold ring turning yellow. Not tarnish: the rhodium plating has worn and the warmer alloy shows. DermNet notes that the plating on white gold protects you from nickel in the alloy but eventually wears off over months or years, so this is also when a sensitive finger can start to itch.
  • Green crust or pitting on brass, copper or costume pieces. That's corrosion of the base metal, not a thin surface layer. Keep corroded posts out of a piercing and have the piece looked at.

Tarnished earrings and piercings

  • Healed piercings. Seattle Children's lists not cleaning earrings and posts daily, and not taking earrings out at night, among the causes of infection in healed ears, and advises cleaning earrings, posts, backs and earlobes with rubbing alcohol. The concern is dirt, not color.
  • Nickel in the post. Seattle Children's also notes that posts containing nickel can cause an itchy allergic reaction. A plated earring whose post has turned dark may have worn down to its base metal.
  • New piercings. The Association of Professional Piercers (APP) says jewelry for fresh piercings should be inert and body-compatible, and that gold-plated, gold-filled and vermeil jewelry isn't acceptable for them. Its suitable materials include implant-grade steel and titanium, niobium, nickel- and cadmium-free gold of 14K or higher, and platinum; sterling silver isn't on the list.
  • When to call a doctor. Seattle Children's advises calling for an infected-looking ear with a fever, a red and swollen upper-ear piercing, redness spreading beyond the earring site, or an earring back stuck in the lobe.
  • A blue-gray spot at the hole. DermNet lists silver earring sites among the places localized argyria can appear: silver particles deposited in the skin, not tarnish on the earring, and DermNet says the pigmentation is permanent. That's one for a dermatologist, not a jeweler.

What to do with a tarnished piece

  • Sterling silver and solid gold: wear it as it is if you like the look, or clean it. Light tarnish comes off with a silver polishing cloth; how to clean tarnished jewelry covers each metal.
  • Plated and costume pieces: wipe them, don't polish them; CCI notes that polishing can wear through plating. Dark spots that won't wipe off are worn plating, and only re-plating brings the color back.
  • To slow it down: CCI says silver tarnishes faster as humidity climbs and is best stored below 50% relative humidity, so a closed box or pouch between wears helps; more in how to keep sterling silver from tarnishing.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

  • Jewelry Spa: $44 for a silver ring, earrings or pendant; $56 for a silver bracelet or necklace ($44 + $12); $59 for a 14K yellow gold ring ($44 + $10 + $5).
  • Jewelry Polishing: $30 for a silver ring or earrings, $60 for a pendant ($30 + $30), $105 for a necklace ($30 + $75).
  • Rhodium Plating: $69 for a silver ring, $89 for silver earrings ($69 + $20), $99 for 14K white gold earrings ($69 + $20 + $8 + $2). The rhodium plating cost guide puts its life at about 1 to 3 years on a ring, and 12 to 24 months on engagement rings and wedding bands worn every day. See also rhodium plating for sensitive ears.
  • Gold Plating: from $60 for a ring on a silver base. A pair of gold-plated brass earrings is $198 ($60 + $25 + $113), which can be more than a fashion pair cost new.
  • Mail-In Evaluation: $19, credited in full, for green crust, pitting or anything you can't identify.

Shipping is $30 round trip per order. At the New York studio of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, a bench jeweler does the work, a second jeweler checks it, and plating that wears prematurely is covered by the 1-year workmanship guarantee.

Questions

Can tarnished jewelry make you sick?
No, wearing tarnish isn't considered harmful. On silver it's silver sulfide, which barely dissolves in water, so it doesn't soak into skin. What makes skin react is usually the metal itself, most often nickel in a base metal or a white gold alloy, or soap and dirt trapped under the piece. A red, itchy rash that keeps returning is one for a dermatologist, not a jeweler.
Can tarnished earrings cause an infection?
Tarnish itself isn't what causes ear infections; dirty jewelry and broken skin are. Clean posts, backs and lobes with rubbing alcohol and take earrings out at night, as Seattle Children's advises for healed ears. A post containing nickel can cause an itchy allergic reaction instead, and a fresh piercing should get only implant-grade metals, never plated jewelry.
Is it bad if tarnish rubs off on my skin?
No. A gray or black smudge is tarnish transferring from the metal, and it washes off with soap and water. It's a sign the piece needs cleaning, not a health problem. Keep the piece away from perfume and sprays while you wear it, and store it closed and dry between wears. A Jewelry Spa clean at JewelryRepair.com starts at $44.
Is it safe to wear gold-plated jewelry that has tarnished?
Usually, as long as your skin doesn't react. Dark patches on gold-plated pieces are normally base metal showing through worn plating, and that base metal can contain nickel, so nickel-sensitive skin may start to itch. Re-plating restores the barrier: Gold Plating at JewelryRepair.com starts at $60 on a silver base, and brass, copper and steel bases cost more.
Should I stop wearing jewelry that tarnishes quickly?
Not because of the tarnish. Fast tarnishing usually comes from the conditions around the piece, such as humidity, sweat, perfume and sprays, rather than from anything wrong with the metal. Stop wearing a piece only if your skin reacts. To slow the darkening on sterling, Rhodium Plating at JewelryRepair.com is $69 for a ring, and it wears off over time.