Repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

How do you clean or restore tarnished jewelry safely?

The safe method depends on the metal, so identify it first. Wash most pieces in warm water with a little mild soap (wipe hollow, glued or pearl pieces rather than soaking them), then use a silver polishing cloth only on solid sterling. Never polish or dip plated or costume pieces. Professional cleaning at JewelryRepair.com starts at $44.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$44Jewelry Spa for a silver ring, earrings or pendant
$30Jewelry Polishing for a silver ring or earrings
$15Metal Testing & Verification, per item
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • Identify the metal first. Sterling silver, solid gold, plated and costume pieces each need a different approach.
  • Start gentle. Warm water, mild soap and a soft brush remove grime without removing metal.
  • Only solid metal gets polished. A silver cloth suits light tarnish on sterling, and every polish takes a little silver with it.
  • Plated and costume pieces: soap and water only. Polishes and dips cut through plating.
  • Stones change the rules. Pearls, opals, emeralds and other treated or organic gems stay out of ultrasonic cleaners.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish, plus a written inspection report on stones, prongs, clasps and wear. Pearls and opals skip the ultrasonic and are cleaned by hand.
Jewelry Polishing from $30Machine and hand polishing through finer and finer compounds, back to the original mirror, satin or brushed finish.
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks checked; metal and karat tested and documented, so you clean it the right way.
Mail-In Evaluation $19For pitted, crusted or unknown pieces: a magnified exam and an itemized quote with photos, credited in full.

Step one: work out what you're cleaning

Look for a stamp on the clasp, inside a ring band or on an earring post. 925 or STERLING means solid sterling silver. 10K, 14K and 18K, or 417, 585 and 750, mean solid gold (what the stamps mean). GP, HGE, GF or RGP point to gold plate, heavy gold electroplate, gold-filled or rolled gold plate. No stamp, or one you doubt? Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item; stamps can be missing or misleading, especially on older pieces.

Then use the method for that metal:

The safe order for removing tarnish

The Canadian Conservation Institute (CCI), which advises museums on caring for silver, favors the gentlest method that works and as little tarnish removal as possible. In practice that means working up this list and stopping once the piece looks right:

  • Wash. CCI washes silver in water with a mild detergent, rinses it and dries it with a soft cloth. Washing is safe for plated pieces too.
  • Silver polishing cloth. CCI calls these gentler than liquid, paste or foam polishes because they hold less abrasive, so they suit light tarnish. See how to use a silver polishing cloth.
  • A silver-specific polish, for heavier tarnish. CCI warns against multi-purpose metal polishes, which remove more silver, and against polishes with ammonia, which can dissolve the copper in sterling and leave a green residue.
  • Dips, sparingly. Dips dissolve tarnish fast, but CCI says silver should be exposed to them as little as possible to avoid pitting, applies them with a cotton swab rather than by soaking, and never uses them on pieces with sealed hollow parts. See is silver dip safe for jewelry.
  • The aluminum and washing-soda bath. Silver touching aluminum in a warm washing-soda solution has its tarnish turned back into silver. CCI notes it leaves a dull finish that needs a light polish, and that silver cleaned this way may tarnish again faster than polished silver.

The principle behind all of it: every polish or dip removes a little of the silver underneath (the aluminum bath is the exception, but it leaves a dull finish), so clean when the piece needs it, not on a schedule. For pantry methods, see vinegar, baking soda or peroxide.

What to keep away from tarnished jewelry

  • Polish and dips on plated or costume pieces. The gold or silver layer is microns thin, and abrasion or acid goes straight through it.
  • Dips on oxidized silver. Dark recesses on designer silver are often deliberate, and a dip strips them along with the tarnish.
  • Soaking hollow pieces. Hollow beads, lockets and hollow chains can trap liquid, and CCI keeps sealed hollow objects out of solutions entirely.
  • An ultrasonic cleaner, for the wrong stones. GIA lists pearls, coral, amber, shell and other organic gems; emerald, opal and other stones treated with oil, resin or wax; fracture-filled stones; and heat-sensitive gems such as tanzanite. GIA also warns the vibration can shake stones loose.
  • Hard scrubbing. Stiff brushes and household abrasives scratch the high points while missing the black in the recesses.

When cleaning isn't enough: can tarnished jewelry be restored?

Usually, yes, but the fix depends on what the dark color really is.

  • Black packed into detailed work: the Jewelry Spa reaches what a cloth can't, with an ultrasonic bath, steam and a hand polish, then a jeweler writes up the piece's condition.
  • Dull, scratched silver or gold: Jewelry Polishing removes the scratched surface layer and restores the original finish.
  • Color that won't wipe off a plated piece: that's worn plating, and Gold Plating lays down a new layer; see does gold-plated jewelry tarnish.
  • Yellowing white gold: the rhodium has worn, and Rhodium Plating (from $69) restores the white.
  • Dark accents polished away: re-darkening is listed only as an add-on to Rhodium Plating, so the piece is rhodium-plated as part of the job: $93 for a silver ring with Black antiquing ($69 + $24) or $97 with Oxidation ($69 + $28). If you just want plain oxidized sterling darkened again, ask for a free quote or start with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation.
  • Pitting, green crust or unknown damage: start with the Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full) for photos and an itemized quote.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

  • Jewelry Spa: $44 for a silver ring, earrings or pendant; $56 for a bracelet or necklace ($44 + $12); $59 for a 14K yellow gold ring ($44 + $10 + $5).
  • Jewelry Polishing: $30 for a silver ring or earrings, $50 for a bracelet ($30 + $20), $60 for a pendant ($30 + $30) and $105 for a necklace ($30 + $75); a 14K yellow gold ring is $55 ($30 + $17 + $8).
  • Gold Plating from $60 and Rhodium Plating from $69 for a ring.

Plated pieces that need polishing are priced by free quote, since polishing can cut through plating. And if a piece is coming in for a repair anyway, skip the separate clean: every repair already includes a clean and polish.

Shipping is $30 round trip per order however many pieces share the box, with $100 of coverage each way and a signature at both ends. Pieces are photographed on arrival at our New York studio and again before they ship back; a bench jeweler does the work, a second jeweler checks it, and it carries a 1-year workmanship guarantee. Sky Jewelry, the family jeweler behind JewelryRepair.com, has worked on Lenox Avenue since 1989, and cleaning and refinishing run through most of its over 50,000 repairs, since every repair ends with a clean and polish.

Questions

Does an ultrasonic cleaner remove tarnish?
Not on its own. GIA describes ultrasonic cleaners as using high-frequency sound waves to dislodge dirt and debris, while tarnish on silver is a chemical layer, mainly silver sulfide, that has to be polished off, dissolved or chemically reduced. An ultrasonic bath can make a piece look brighter by clearing grime, which is why professional cleaning follows it with steam and a hand polish.
What's the best jewelry tarnish remover?
The best tarnish remover depends on the metal. For solid sterling silver, use a silver polishing cloth, or a silver-specific polish for heavier tarnish; for gold-plated, silver-plated and costume pieces, use only warm soapy water and a soft cloth. The Canadian Conservation Institute warns against multi-purpose metal polishes, which remove more silver, and ammonia-based polishes, which can leave a green residue on sterling. Use silver dips sparingly, never on plated or oxidized pieces.
Can tarnished jewelry be fixed or restored?
Yes, in most cases. Tarnish on solid silver can be polished off, and Jewelry Polishing at JewelryRepair.com starts at $30 for a silver ring. If the dark color is base metal showing through worn plating, cleaning can't bring the color back, but Gold Plating lays down a new layer from $60, and Rhodium Plating restores yellowing white gold from $69. Pitted or crusted pieces start with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full.
Why does my jewelry tarnish again so fast after cleaning?
Usually because of storage, or because of how it was cleaned. Silver tarnishes when it meets sulfur gases, and CCI notes that silver cleaned in an aluminum-and-soda bath may tarnish faster than polished silver. Store pieces dry in a closed box or anti-tarnish pouch, away from rubber bands and wool. On plated pieces, dark spots that return quickly usually mean base metal is exposed.