Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Does white gold or platinum need more maintenance?

White gold needs more routine upkeep: its bright rhodium plating wears through, often within 12 to 24 months on a ring worn daily, and has to be re-plated. Platinum needs no plating and only dulls to a satin patina you can keep or polish away, but each platinum repair costs more. Re-plating a 14K white gold ring here is $79.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$79Rhodium Plating, 14K white gold ring ($69 + $8 + $2)
$125Jewelry Polishing, platinum ring ($30 + $95)
12–24 monthstypical rhodium life on a ring worn every day
50,000+repairs since 1989, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue

The short version

  • White gold: more frequent, cheaper upkeep. Most white gold is rhodium-plated, and the plating wears through where the ring rubs, so it needs re-plating, typically every 12 to 24 months on a ring worn daily. A 14K ring costs $79 to re-plate here.
  • Platinum: less frequent, costlier upkeep. It is white all the way through, so there is nothing to re-plate. It softens to a satin patina, which you can keep or have polished ($125 for a ring).
  • Wear: both scratch. Gold loses a little metal with each scratch; platinum mostly pushes the metal aside, so prongs and bands thin more slowly.
  • Bench work costs more in platinum: sizing a band down is $76 in 14K white gold versus $565 in platinum.
  • Sensitive skin: platinum is the safer bet; nickel white gold can cause trouble once its plating wears.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Rhodium Plating from $69The routine white gold job: polish, clean and a fresh layer of rhodium. A 14K white gold ring is $79 ($69 + $8 + $2), 18K is $83 ($69 + $8 + $6).
Jewelry Polishing from $30The routine platinum job, and optional: a platinum ring is $125 ($30 + $95). A 14K white gold ring polished without new plating is $60 ($30 + $22 + $8).
Prong Re-Tipping from $29New metal laser-welded onto worn prong tips, 1 to 4 prongs: 14K white gold $57 ($29 + $23 + $5), platinum $224 ($29 + $195).
Ring Resizing from $45Sizing a plain band down: 14K white gold $76 ($45 + $24 + $7), platinum $565 ($45 + $520).
The Anniversary Service $199Yearly engagement-ring care for either metal: deep clean, magnified inspection, loose stones tightened and condition photos, with re-rhodium included on white gold.

Why white gold needs re-plating and platinum doesn't

White gold is gold alloyed with at least one white metal, usually nickel, silver, platinum or palladium. None of those alloys is truly white. An alloy article on Ganoksin describes low-palladium 14K white golds as "straw white" or "cream white", and notes that most 10K nickel-free and 18K low-palladium alloys need rhodium plating to look properly white. That bright, cool white you see in a jeweler's case is usually a thin layer of rhodium, a platinum-family metal, over a warmer alloy.

Rhodium is hard but thin, and daily contact buffs it away from the underside of the band first. When the warmer alloy shows, nothing is wrong with the ring; it is time to re-plate, or to keep it warmer. A few white golds, the high-palladium 14K and 18K alloys, look white enough that they usually aren't plated at all, so it is worth asking what yours is.

Platinum is different. GIA notes that jewelry platinum is typically about 95% pure and does not need plating for its white finish. Platinum also doesn't corrode or tarnish. The one exception: GIA also notes that some makers rhodium-plate platinum for extra shine, and a plated platinum ring needs re-plating from time to time just like white gold.

How each metal wears over the years

No metal is immune to scratching. The difference is what happens to the metal in the scratch. According to a Ganoksin article on platinum durability, a scratch in platinum displaces the metal and leaves small ridges along its edges, while other precious metals lose metal when scratched. JCK puts it more plainly: white gold loses a bit of metal with every scratch. Over decades, that is why gold prongs wear flat and gold bands get thinner, and why the same article describes platinum as wearing at a much slower rate.

  • The look: white gold stays bright until the plating wears, then goes warm in patches. Platinum goes from mirror-bright to a soft gray satin, which GIA calls a patina and which many people keep on purpose.
  • Prongs: gold prong tips wear down faster and eventually need re-tipping. Platinum prongs wear more slowly, for the same reason: the metal moves rather than leaves.
  • Weight: platinum is dense. Pure platinum weighs 21.45 grams per cubic centimeter against 19.28 for pure gold, and karat gold alloys are lighter still, so a platinum ring feels noticeably heavier.
  • Heat: pure platinum melts at about 1,768 °C, roughly 700 °C hotter than pure gold at 1,064 °C. Sizing, re-tipping and soldering platinum takes more heat and more care, and Ganoksin notes that platinum needs its own polishing compounds, with "no shortcuts". GIA lists platinum resizing as expensive.

What maintenance costs at JewelryRepair.com

JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in bench of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, and both metals go through the same New York studio. Every price includes a clean and polish and the 1-year workmanship guarantee.

  • Routine, white gold: Rhodium Plating for a ring is $79 in 14K ($69 + $8 + $2) and $83 in 18K ($69 + $8 + $6). If you re-plate every two years, that is five visits in ten years: 5 × $79 = $395.
  • Routine, platinum: Jewelry Polishing is $125 for a ring ($30 + $95). Polish twice in ten years and it is 2 × $125 = $250; keep the patina and it is $0.
  • Structural, per job: Prong Re-Tipping for 1 to 4 prongs is $57 in 14K white gold ($29 + $23 + $5) and $224 in platinum ($29 + $195). Ring Resizing down is $76 in 14K white gold ($45 + $24 + $7) and $565 in platinum ($45 + $520). Stone Tightening starts at $60 in white gold and $85 in platinum.
  • For an engagement ring, once a year: The Anniversary Service ($199) covers a deep clean, magnified inspection, loose-stone tightening and condition photos, and includes re-rhodium on white gold.

So the honest comparison is this: white gold costs more to keep looking the same, and platinum costs more each time it needs bench work, though its prongs and band wear more slowly, so those visits tend to come less often. Your exact timeline depends on how hard you are on your hands.

Signs your ring needs attention

  • White gold turning faintly yellow, usually at the back of the band or under the setting: the rhodium has worn through. Re-plating fixes it; our guide to rhodium plating cost covers how long it lasts on each kind of piece.
  • An itchy rash under a white gold band: some white golds contain nickel, and the American Academy of Dermatology estimates more than 18 percent of people in North America are allergic to it. Fresh plating puts a barrier back; see a dermatologist for the skin.
  • Platinum looking gray or matte: that is patina, not damage. Polish it only if you prefer it bright.
  • Prongs catching on sweaters in either metal: worn or lifted tips. Re-tip them before a stone goes missing.
  • A stone that rattles when you tap the ring next to your ear: have it tightened now.

Can I do the maintenance myself?

Partly. Gentle cleaning at home is fine for both metals (see the safest ways to clean jewelry at home), and you can make plating last longer by taking a white gold ring off for workouts, chlorinated pools and hand lotion, and by skipping abrasive cleaners, which wear plating away. What you can't do well at home is the plating itself: home kits can't do the polishing and deep cleaning the plating needs underneath, and rhodium reproduces every scratch and trace of oil below it. Platinum polishing is also bench work, done through progressively finer platinum compounds. If you just want to know what you have, Metal Testing & Verification ($15) confirms the metal and karat.

Before you ship

The prepaid UPS label is ready in your account within minutes of booking; shipping is $30 round trip per order, however many rings are in the box. Pack the ring in any small sturdy box with nothing on the outside naming the contents and drop it at any UPS location. $100 of coverage is included each way; full value up to $10,000 costs 2.5% of the value above $100, once for both directions, so a $3,000 ring is $72.50 (($3,000 − $100) × 2.5%). The ring is photographed on arrival, a bench jeweler does the work, a second jeweler checks it, and it is photographed again before it comes back with a signature on delivery. If the ring is under a store warranty or care plan, check with the store first, since outside work can void it.

Questions

How often does white gold need to be re-plated?
Usually every 12 to 24 months for an engagement ring or wedding band worn every day, according to our rhodium plating cost guide, and less often for pieces that see less contact. The plating wears first on the underside of a ring. At JewelryRepair.com, Rhodium Plating for a 14K white gold ring is $79, including the polish and clean that come before the plating.
Does platinum need to be rhodium plated?
No. Platinum is white all the way through and doesn't need plating for its color, according to GIA. Some makers plate platinum anyway for extra shine, and a plated platinum ring will need re-plating from time to time, like white gold. Unplated platinum just softens to a satin patina, which you can keep or have polished back to bright for $125 here.
Is platinum more durable than white gold?
For long-term wear, yes. Both metals scratch, but a scratch in platinum mostly displaces metal rather than removing it, so prongs and bands thin more slowly than in gold. Platinum's surface still shows scratches and turns satin with wear. White gold's plating gives a harder, brighter surface at first, but it wears away and has to be renewed.
Is white gold or platinum better for sensitive skin?
Platinum. The American Academy of Dermatology lists platinum among the metals to choose if you're allergic to nickel, and some white golds contain nickel that can reach your skin once the plating wears. Palladium white golds are nickel-free. If your white gold ring itches, fresh rhodium plating restores the barrier; a 14K ring costs $79 to re-plate.