Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

What is the best way to store jewelry, and can gold and silver be stored together?

Store each piece separately in a closed, dry place: a lined box with compartments, soft pouches, or, for completely dry sterling, a sealed polyethylene bag. Gold and silver can share a box as long as they don't touch, because contact causes scratches, not tarnish. Keep pearls out of plastic and everything away from bathroom humidity.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

10 vs 2.5Mohs hardness of diamond against pure gold and silver: hard stones scratch soft metal
below 50%relative humidity for storing silver, per the Canadian Conservation Institute
$44Jewelry Spa clean and written inspection for a sterling ring, earrings or pendant
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • One piece, one place. Individual padded slots, a soft pouch or a small bag for each piece, so nothing rubs or tangles.
  • Gold and silver can share a box as long as they don't touch. Contact causes scratches, not tarnish.
  • Closed and dry beats open and handy. Keep jewelry out of the bathroom. Sterling goes in a sealed polyethylene bag only once it's completely dry, since plastic also traps moisture.
  • Pearls never go in plastic, and fade-prone gems such as amethyst and kunzite stay out of strong light.
  • Wipe before you store. Skin oil and lotion left on a piece keep working on it in the box.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish with a written inspection report, for pieces that have dulled or tarnished in storage. Sterling ring, earrings or pendant $44; bracelet or necklace $56 ($44 + $12); 14K yellow gold ring $59 ($44 + $10 + $5).
Jewelry Polishing from $30For the fine scratches pieces leave on each other: worked through progressively finer compounds to a mirror, satin or brushed finish, with details done by hand. Sterling ring or earrings $30; 14K yellow gold ring $55 ($30 + $17 + $8); sterling necklace $105 ($30 + $75).
Chain Untangling from $15Knots opened under magnification with no tension on the links, then an ultrasonic clean and inspection. Three chains knotted together: $45.

What actually damages jewelry in storage

  • Scratching. On the Mohs scale diamond is 10, sapphire 9, topaz 8 and quartz 7, while pure gold and silver sit at about 2.5. GIA notes that diamond can scratch any of the precious metals used for settings and that only a diamond can scratch a diamond, so two diamond rings loose in one tray can mark each other.
  • Tangling. Fine chains with open links thread through each other in a drawer or pouch, and a knot pulled tight is how links stretch and kink.
  • Air and moisture. Silver tarnishes when it reacts with sulfur gases in the air, and the Canadian Conservation Institute (CCI) explains that the copper in sterling is why it tarnishes faster than fine silver. CCI recommends storing silver below 50% relative humidity.
  • Light and heat. GIA warns that light and heat, over time and in excess, can fade or damage some gemstones, such as amethyst, kunzite, topaz and shell cameos, and that heat can dry out, crack and discolor pearls.

Can gold and silver be stored together?

Yes. Tarnish isn't contagious: it forms when silver, and the silver and copper in lower-karat gold, react with sulfur gases in the air, so a silver chain lying next to a gold one doesn't pass anything to it. What contact does cause is scratching and tangling, so give each piece its own slot or pouch even when they share a box.

  • Lower-karat gold can tarnish too. Ganoksin's article on gold tarnishing explains that the copper and silver in karat gold alloys are what react; tarnish is generally seen in 8 to 10 karat, occasionally in 14 and 18 karat, and never in pure gold. So closed, dry storage helps 10K and 14K pieces as well. More in does real gold tarnish?
  • Plated, vermeil and gold-filled pieces carry a layer of gold over another metal, and a harder piece rubbing against them wears through that layer. Keep them away from anything set with stones.

How to store each kind of piece

  • Diamond and hard-gem rings and earrings: individual padded slots or separate pouches, so stones never touch metal or each other. GIA points out that the box or pouch a piece came in is a perfectly good place to keep it.
  • Sterling silver: dry, sealed and separate; the bag, strip and humidity details are in how to keep sterling silver from tarnishing.
  • Plated, vermeil and costume pieces: on their own, never loose in a dish, and completely dry before they go away.
  • Pearls: GIA advises a soft cloth or breathable pouch, never a plastic bag, which gives off a chemical that can damage the pearl's surface. GIA also notes the silk on a strand can stretch over time; laying strands flat rather than hanging them avoids adding to that strain. See how to store pearls.
  • Opals: like pearls, they draw moisture from the air, GIA notes, so a very dry spot can do more harm than good.
  • Chains: Jewelers Mutual suggests a box with hooks, the original box whose slits hold the chain, or threading very fine chains through drinking straws laid flat about an inch apart. More in how to keep layered necklaces from tangling.

Why jewelry tarnishes in a jewelry box

Tarnish inside a jewelry box usually comes from the box or the room rather than the jewelry. CCI's list of indoor sulfur sources includes wool and wool felt, vulcanized rubber such as rubber bands, protein-based glues, certain paints and poor-quality drywall. The Sheffield Assay Office adds that wooden drawers and cabinets can accelerate tarnish and that newspaper tarnishes silver rapidly. A felt-lined box kept in a steamy bathroom is about the worst home silver can have.

Pieces that aren't worn don't get wiped or rubbed in daily use, so a stored piece's surface is left to whatever is in its box and its room, and those decide how fast it tarnishes. CCI also notes that the salts and oils on skin mark silver and leave fingerprints, so wipe each piece with a soft cotton cloth before it goes away.

One bag for everything is the other common mistake: a shared zip bag or pouch lets stones scratch metal and chains knot together, however clean and dry it is.

When storage has already taken its toll

Sky Jewelry has been doing this bench work on Lenox Avenue since 1989, over 50,000 repairs since 1989, and JewelryRepair.com is its mail-in service. Each price includes the 1-year workmanship guarantee:

  • Jewelry Spa: ultrasonic bath, steam, hand polish and a written inspection report, so you learn whether prongs or clasps need attention before a piece goes back in the box. $44 for a sterling ring, earrings or pendant; $56 for a bracelet or necklace ($44 + $12); $59 for a 14K yellow gold ring ($44 + $10 + $5). Not for pearls: GIA says they should never go in an ultrasonic or steam cleaner.
  • Jewelry Polishing: removes the fine scratches pieces leave on each other. $30 for a sterling ring or earrings; $55 for a 14K yellow gold ring ($30 + $17 + $8); $105 for a sterling necklace ($30 + $75).
  • Chain Untangling: $15 for the first chain and $15 for each additional one, so three knotted chains are $45.

Send the pieces the way this page says to store them, each in its own small bag, so nothing scratches in transit. UPS shipping is $30 round trip per order however many pieces are in the box; coverage terms are in how jewelry shipping insurance works.

Questions

Can you store silver and gold jewelry together?
Yes, as long as they don't touch. Tarnish forms when silver reacts with sulfur gases in the air, so it doesn't spread from a silver piece to a gold one; contact causes scratches and tangles instead. Give each piece its own slot or pouch, keep sterling dry and sealed, and keep low-karat gold dry too, since its copper and silver can tarnish.
Can I store all my jewelry in one zip bag?
No, give each piece its own bag. In a shared bag, diamonds and other hard stones scratch softer gold and silver, and chains thread through each other and knot. Small individual bags, pouches or compartments fix both problems. If pieces have already scratched or knotted, Jewelry Polishing at JewelryRepair.com starts at $30 for a sterling ring, and Chain Untangling is $15 for the first chain.
Why does my jewelry tarnish in my jewelry box?
Usually because of the box or the room. Wool felt linings, rubber bands and protein-based glues can give off the sulfur gases that tarnish silver, wooden drawers can speed tarnish, and a box kept in a humid bathroom makes it worse. Give silver its own dry, sealed bag inside the box, wipe pieces before storing them, and keep the box in a dry room.
Why does jewelry tarnish when not worn?
Because nothing wipes it, so the air in its box and room does the work. Silver and low-karat gold tarnish by reacting with sulfur gases, faster in humid air and near sources like wool felt or rubber. Worn pieces get rubbed clean in daily use; stored ones don't. A dulled piece can be brought back with a Jewelry Spa clean at JewelryRepair.com, $44 for a sterling ring.
Is it bad to leave jewelry out?
It's the riskiest way to store it, though not a disaster for a piece you wear daily. Left out, jewelry collects dust, gets knocked together and sits in light that can fade some gems and humidity that speeds tarnish. GIA advises against leaving jewelry loose in a drawer or on a dresser. A closed box with compartments is just as easy to reach, and a ring you take off nightly can have a lined dish to itself, away from the sink.