Jewelry repair questions · Stones & settings

Can a jeweler remove the diamonds or gemstones from old jewelry, and should I try it myself?

Yes. A jeweler frees stones by lifting prongs, opening a bezel or, when the mounting won't be reused, cutting the metal away, keeping the force on the metal rather than the stone. Doing it yourself risks chipping the stone's edge or losing small stones. At JewelryRepair.com unsetting is quoted through a $10 Custom Work estimate.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$10Custom Work estimate: unsetting is quoted line by line before anything proceeds
$19Mail-In Evaluation of the whole piece, credited in full
$15Metal Testing & Verification per item, to know what the gold is before you sell it
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • Yes, a jeweler can unset stones. GIA even advises taking stones out of their mountings before many repairs, so it's familiar bench work.
  • The method follows the setting, and the force goes on the metal, never levered against the stone's edge.
  • Some stones need extra care: emeralds, opals and anything already chipped or fractured. Bench jewelers avoid heat when freeing a stone you're keeping.
  • Doing it yourself risks chipping the girdle, losing small stones and cutting your hand.
  • At JewelryRepair.com unsetting is quoted through a $10 Custom Work estimate. There's no flat menu price.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Custom Work & Modifications $10Unsetting stones to keep loose or reuse: add photos and say what you want, and a jeweler quotes the work line by line before anything proceeds; if a request falls outside Custom Work, the estimate says so. Existing stones or gold can be reused or credited toward a new design.
Mail-In Evaluation $19The whole piece examined under magnification, including any stones that look chipped, fractured or loose, with photos and an itemized quote. Credited in full toward approved work.
Antique & Heirloom Restoration $19For antique pieces, including old European, old mine and rose cut stones, that may be worth restoring rather than breaking up: the $19 evaluation, credited in full, then each step quoted item by item with photos.
Jewelry Appraisal from $105A written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, unmounted stones included, useful before a piece is broken up or once loose stones need insuring. Not a lab grading report.
Metal Testing & Verification $15A documented answer on what the metal is, per item, before you sell the gold separately from the stones.

How a jeweler takes stones out, setting by setting

GIA's 1987 gem durability study advises removing a stone from its mounting whenever possible before repair work, because any stone can suffer thermal shock under a torch. Ganoksin's article on colored gemstone repair notes that removal itself carries some chance of breaking a stone. How it's done depends on what holds the stone:

  • Prongs. Each prong tip is eased back off the stone with a prong lifter or thin blade working against the metal. When the mounting is being retired, bench jewelers on Ganoksin's Orchid forum describe sawing just behind each prong, stopping short of the stone, and folding the weakened prong away.
  • Bezels. The metal wall is eased up gradually around the rim, lifting it away from the stone rather than wedging against it, or its joint is cut open. Jewelers in an Orchid discussion of bezels stress working slowly with almost no force, and warn that a sharp point pressed against the stone can chip it.
  • Channel, pavé and bead settings. The small beads or channel walls holding each stone are cut back with a graver, and the stone lifts out or is gently pressed free.
  • Tennis bracelets and clusters. Each stone has its own setting, so the stones are freed one by one and counted.
  • When the metal won't be reused, it can be filed, ground or cut away from the stones, often the gentlest route for the stones.

Which stones are at risk

  • Diamonds are hard, not unbreakable. GIA explains that hardness is resistance to scratching while toughness is resistance to breaking, and that even after cutting, a hard blow can still cleave a diamond. A blade levered against a diamond's thin outer edge, the girdle, is that kind of blow.
  • Fractures and inclusions near the girdle make any stone more fragile, GIA's durability study notes, and stones in old jewelry often carry decades of chips.
  • Emeralds have fair to good toughness, per GIA, which notes that heat can extend existing fractures and that some estimates put 90 percent or more of emeralds as fracture-filled.
  • Opals sit at 5.5 to 6 on the Mohs scale, softer than quartz at 7.

That's why bench jewelers avoid heat when freeing a stone to keep: GIA's durability study warns that any stone can suffer thermal shock if heated too quickly, and GIA notes filled and treated stones can change in appearance with heat or chemicals.

Should you try removing stones yourself?

If the stones matter, no. Searches for doing it "without tools" have no good answer: fingernails, butter knives and scissors can't lift a prong or a bezel without levering against the stone. With tools, the common mistakes are:

  • wedging a blade between metal and stone, which puts the force on the girdle, the stone's thinnest edge;
  • a slipping blade, which chips the stone or cuts a hand;
  • a small stone springing free into a carpet or a drain;
  • heating the piece to soften metal or glue, which can crack, cloud or discolor stones.

For fine jewelry, GIA's 1987 durability study puts it plainly: if you can't afford to break a stone, or it can't be replaced, don't attempt anything that could damage it.

Before you take a piece apart

  • Decide what the stones are for. Keeping them loose, reusing them in a new piece, or freeing them so the metal can be sold separately each calls for a different plan, and a reset may not need the old mounting destroyed at all.
  • Find out what you have. Old pieces can hold glass, which GIA notes has imitated gems for centuries, as well as synthetics, doublets and treated stones. A Jewelry Appraisal, from $105, documents the stones and metal with photographs; it's an insurance-replacement-value document, not a lab grading report and not an offer to buy. To know what the gold is before you sell it, Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item.
  • Ask whether it's worth more whole. An antique with old mine or rose cut stones may be better restored; Antique & Heirloom Restoration starts with a $19 evaluation, credited in full.
  • Keep a record. At JewelryRepair.com each piece is photographed on arrival and again before it ships, so you can compare the stones going in and coming out. More in will a jeweler swap my diamond?
  • Once they're loose, keep each stone in its own labeled bag or stone paper, diamonds apart from each other (GIA notes only a diamond can scratch a diamond), and check whether your insurance still covers them unmounted.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

There's no menu price for unsetting at JewelryRepair.com, the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry (over 50,000 repairs since 1989), because the work depends on how many stones there are, how they're set, how fragile they are and whether the mounting has to survive. So it starts with a quote:

  • Custom Work & Modifications: a $10 estimate. Add photos and say what you want: stones kept loose, reused in a new piece, or freed from metal you're retiring. A jeweler quotes the work line by line before anything proceeds, and if the request falls outside Custom Work, the estimate says so. A new mounting for the stones is quoted the same way, with setting labor on top; see what resetting a diamond costs.
  • Mail-In Evaluation: $19, credited in full, if you'd like a jeweler to examine the whole piece first, with photos and an itemized quote.

Send the piece with its stones still set; if one has already fallen out, seal it in a small bag inside the package, with a copy of any grading report. UPS shipping is $30 round trip per order. Full-value coverage is 2.5% of the value above $100, so a $4,000 ring costs $97.50 to cover ($3,900 × 2.5%); details in how jewelry shipping insurance works. Work carries the 1-year workmanship guarantee.

Questions

How much does it cost to remove a diamond from a ring?
It depends on the setting and the number of stones, so at JewelryRepair.com there's no flat price: unsetting is quoted through a $10 Custom Work estimate, with the work priced line by line before anything proceeds. If you'd rather have a jeweler look at the whole piece first, the $19 Mail-In Evaluation is credited in full toward the work you approve.
Can you remove diamonds from a ring without tools?
Not safely. Prongs and bezels are metal pressed tight over the stone, and nothing at hand, fingernails, a butter knife or scissors, can lift them without levering against the diamond's thin edge, where a hard knock can chip or cleave it. Small stones also tend to spring loose and vanish. Send the piece with the stones still set and have a jeweler unset them under magnification.
Will removing stones from a setting damage them?
Usually not, in a jeweler's hands, but it isn't risk-free. GIA notes that even after cutting, a hard blow can still cleave a diamond, and stones with fractures near the edge, emeralds and opals need extra care. A jeweler examines each stone under magnification first, works against the metal rather than the stone, and avoids heat when freeing a stone you're keeping.
Can I sell the gold and keep the stones?
Yes. Have the stones unset first, then sell the metal on its own; a gold buyer pays for the metal, not the stones or the workmanship. Know what you're selling first: Metal Testing & Verification at JewelryRepair.com is $15 per item. If you'd rather keep the value, Custom Work can reuse or credit your gold and stones toward a new piece instead.
Can the diamonds from a tennis bracelet be removed and reused?
Yes. Each diamond sits in its own setting, so they're freed one at a time and counted, then can be kept loose or reused. At JewelryRepair.com the unsetting is quoted through the $10 Custom Work estimate. A new piece for them, such as a band, earrings or a pendant, is quoted through Custom Work as well, with the setting labor on top.