Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing
Can my old gold jewelry be melted down and made into a new ring?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Solid karat gold can be remelted. Gold melts at about 1,064 °C (about 1,948 °F), and a jeweler can re-alloy it, cast it, or roll it into wire and sheet.
- Plated and gold-filled pieces can't become a gold ring. They are mostly other metal under a gold layer.
- Test first. Stamps can be worn, wrong or missing. Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item.
- Stones come out before any heat, and go into the new design or back to you.
- Mixed karats average out. Equal weights of 14K and 18K melted together make roughly 16K, an odd karat that has to be adjusted.
- Old gold isn't always better than new metal. Old solder and repeated melting can leave pits and porosity, which is why many jewelers use fresh metal and credit your gold instead.
- Here, Custom Work & Modifications starts with a $10 estimate, and existing stones or gold can be reused or credited.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Custom Work & Modifications | $10 | Send photos, sketches or references; nothing ships yet. A jeweler reviews the project and quotes it line by line before anything proceeds. Existing stones or gold can be reused or credited. |
| 3D Design & Rendering | $150 | A jewelry CAD model and photorealistic render with two rounds of revisions; the $150 is credited toward fabrication and the files are yours. Stone sourcing quoted separately. Rush +$50. |
| Metal Testing & Verification | $15 | Hallmarks and karat stamps examined under magnification, then the metal and karat tested directly, cross-checked when a first result is ambiguous, and documented, so you know what you're melting. |
What happens to your gold, step by step
This is the usual sequence at the bench; the quote for your project says which steps apply.
- Sort and test. Pieces are separated by color and karat, and the metal is tested rather than read off the stamp. One goldsmith on Ganoksin's Orchid forum points out that an acid test reads only the surface spot tested, so a plated piece can read as high karat, which is why a first result is cross-checked.
- Remove the stones. Writing in GIA's journal Gems & Gemology, Deborah Dupont Martin advises taking a stone out of its mounting whenever possible before a repair, because any stone carries some risk under heat. Before a melt, every stone comes out.
- Deal with the solder. Old jewelry is held together by solder, an alloy made to melt lower than the metal it joins. On Orchid, one goldsmith calls solder the biggest problem in remelting old gold, especially in chains, and another advises sawing out solder joints from 12K and 14K pieces before they go in the crucible.
- Melt and adjust. The gold is melted under flux, and fine gold or fresh alloy is added to bring it to the karat and color you want. Metal melted again and again picks up oxides and inclusions that show as pits, and the zinc in many alloys burns out, shifting the color.
- Form the ring. The metal is cast, often from a model designed in CAD, or rolled into stock and fabricated by hand.
- Finish. The ring is cleaned up, sized and polished, and any stones are set.
The arithmetic of mixing karats
Karat counts gold in parts of 24, so 14K is 14 parts gold to 10 parts other metal, as the FTC explains. 14K is 14/24, about 58.3%, and is normally alloyed to 58.5% and stamped 585; 18K is 75% (750) and 10K about 41.7%. Melt different karats together and you get the weighted average:
- 10 g of 14K plus 10 g of 18K: 5.85 g + 7.5 g = 13.35 g of gold in 20 g, which is 66.75%, or 16.02K (0.6675 × 24). That isn't a standard karat.
- Bringing it down to 14K means adding alloy: 13.35 g ÷ 0.585 = 22.82 g in total, so about 2.82 g of alloy.
- Bringing it up to 18K means adding pure gold: solving (13.35 + x) ÷ (20 + x) = 0.75 gives x = 6.6 g of fine gold.
- 10 g of 10K plus 10 g of 14K: 4.17 g + 5.85 g = 10.02 g in 20 g, or 50.1%, about 12K.
Karat marks are regulated, too. Under US law, gold tested without solder may fall no more than 3 parts per thousand below its mark, and anyone stamping a quality mark must add their registered trademark or name beside it. A melt whose content isn't known can't honestly be stamped 14K, which is why one goldsmith on Orchid declines to karat-mark pieces cast from customers' old gold.
Why many jewelers credit your gold instead
Reusing a customer's gold is possible, but the trade is frank about the risks. On Orchid, jewelers describe warning customers about possible porosity or odd colors, one says old white gold alloys vary too much to reuse, and another reports failures fabricating with it. Others avoid the problem by casting the new piece in fresh metal, crediting the customer for the old gold and sending it to a refiner separately.
Neither route is wrong. If wearing the actual metal matters to you, because it was a parent's wedding band, say so in your request and the quote will reflect it. If the look and a known karat matter more, credit and fresh metal give the more predictable ring. At JewelryRepair.com the custom work quote says which applies to your project: existing stones or gold can be reused or credited.
What can't be melted into a gold ring
- Gold-plated and vermeil pieces carry only a thin gold layer over another metal. Even vermeil, gold over sterling silver, needs only a coating of at least 10K gold equivalent to 2.5 microns of fine gold, under FTC rules.
- Gold-filled pieces are a layer of at least 10K gold mechanically bonded to a base metal. Under FTC rules the term applies only when that layer is at least 1/20 of the metal's weight; thinner layers must be sold as rolled gold plate or gold overlay. At the 1/20 minimum, a 20 g gold-filled bracelet holds about 1 g of karat gold (20 ÷ 20).
- Tungsten carbide is carbide particles bonded with metal, with a melting point around 2,780 °C, and can't be recast into a ring. See whether a cracked tungsten ring can be repaired.
- Platinum melts at about 1,768 °C (about 3,215 °F), against gold's 1,064 °C, and must never go into a gold melt. Reworking it is a separate, specialist job; at JewelryRepair.com, send photos with the $10 Custom Work estimate and a jeweler will say whether and how it can be done.
- Sterling silver melts down into silver, not gold, so keep it out of the gold pile. A gold-colored piece stamped 925 is silver underneath; see what 585, 750 and 925 stamps mean.
Melting at home, and alternatives that keep more of the original
People do melt gold at home with a torch and a crucible, and gold's melting point is within reach of a jeweler's torch. But a lump of gold isn't a ring. Turning it into one takes casting, with a model, an investment mold and a burnout kiln, or fabrication, with a rolling mill, soldering and sizing skills. Melting also brings hazards you don't want in a kitchen: molten metal, hot flux and fumes from whatever solders and coatings the old pieces carry. Stones left in will be ruined, and the result can't honestly be stamped with a karat. For a ring that matters, have a jeweler do it.
- Redesign instead of melting. Ring-to-pendant conversions, combining pieces and resetting stones are all custom work here. See whether a jeweler can redesign your jewelry.
- Move the stone, not the metal. An heirloom diamond can go into a new setting; see what resetting a diamond costs.
- Join, don't melt. Two family bands can be joined with Solder Rings Together, from $62.
- Copy the design. If you love the ring but not its condition, see whether a jeweler can copy a ring.
- Repair it. A worn or broken gold ring is often worth fixing as it is; see whether broken gold jewelry is worth repairing.
What it costs at JewelryRepair.com
- Custom Work & Modifications: a $10 estimate. Send photos, sketches or references; nothing ships yet. A jeweler reviews them and quotes the project line by line before anything proceeds.
- 3D Design & Rendering: from $150 for a CAD model and photorealistic render with two revision rounds. The $150 is credited toward fabrication and the files are yours; rush adds $50, so $200 with rush.
- Metal Testing & Verification: $15 per item. Four inherited pieces are $60 (4 × $15), plus $30 round-trip shipping for the box.
- Making the ring is quoted per design, since the metal, width and stones set the price. Stone sourcing, if needed, is quoted separately.
Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, with the prepaid label in your account and $100 of coverage each way. Full value up to $10,000 costs 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions: $27.50 to cover gold worth $1,200 (2.5% of $1,100). JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. Pieces are photographed on arrival at the New York studio and before they ship back, a bench jeweler does the work and a second jeweler checks it, and repairs carry a 1-year workmanship guarantee.
Questions
How much gold do I need to make a ring?
Can you melt down a wedding ring to make a new one?
Can you mix 10K and 14K gold together?
Can a platinum ring be melted down?
Do diamonds survive being melted with the gold?
Can you melt a gold necklace or chain into a ring?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list