Jewelry repair questions · Pearls

How can I tell if my pearls are real?

Rub two pearls gently together, or lightly along the edge of a front tooth: natural and cultured pearls feel slightly gritty because they are built from nacre platelets, while most imitations feel smooth. Then check the drill holes under magnification for chipped or peeling coating. Home checks aren't proof; at JewelryRepair.com an appraisal starts at $105.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

2.5–4.5Mohs hardness of pearl, so every test should be gentle
10xloupe magnification for checking the drill holes
$105Jewelry Appraisal for a strand
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • Gritty usually means real. Natural and cultured pearls are composed of nacre platelets and feel faintly sandy when rubbed together; most imitation pearls feel completely smooth.
  • The drill holes give a lot away. Under magnification, nacre on a real pearl usually looks continuous around the opening; on many imitations the coating chips or peels there.
  • Too perfect is suspicious. Real pearls are rarely flawless and vary subtly; a strand where every bead is identical deserves a closer look.
  • Weight and temperature are weak clues. Glass imitations can be heavy and feel cool too.
  • Skip the vinegar and flame tests. Pearls dissolve in vinegar, and heat can turn a pearl brown, burn it or split it.
  • Natural or cultured? That takes X-ray examination in a gem lab. Home checks only separate pearls from imitations.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Appraisal from $105A written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, from an examination in hand. It values the strand for insurance; natural-versus-cultured identification is a gem lab's job.
Pearl Restringing from $15 + $4/inchRestrung in the original order on silk or synthetic cord. Beads, including imitation pearls, carry no surcharge; genuine pearls +$20, hand-knotting +$25, new clasp +$25, rush +$50.
Mail-In Evaluation $19For a strand with a loose clasp, missing pearls or damage you can't name: examined under magnification, photographed and quoted, credited in full toward the work you approve.

Real pearls, cultured pearls and imitations

Real covers two kinds of pearl. Natural pearls form inside a mollusk without human help of any kind. Cultured pearls are real pearls too: in bead-cultured pearls, the mollusk's mantle tissue secretes nacre onto a bead placed inside it, so the surface you see and touch is the same material as a natural pearl's. Both are built from nacre, layer on layer of tiny platelets, which gives them their texture and the deep glow called luster.

Imitations are made to look like that surface without having it. Wikipedia's article on imitation pearls lists glass, plastic and shell bases dipped or sprayed with a pearlescent coating, which may contain essence d'orient, fish scales or oyster scales, as well as pearls made of crushed nacreous shell powder sintered into shape. So a shell pearl can contain mother-of-pearl and still not be a pearl. Imitations aren't fakes in a bad sense; many are well made and sold honestly as what they are. The point of testing is to know which you have before you pay for an appraisal, insure a strand, or choose how to restring it.

Five checks you can do at home

  • 1. The friction test. Rub two pearls from the strand lightly against each other, or run one gently along the biting edge of a clean front tooth. Natural and cultured pearls feel slightly gritty, like very fine sand; imitations feel glassy and smooth. Use almost no pressure, since pearl is only 2.5 to 4.5 on the Mohs hardness scale, and skip the tooth version on pearls you don't own, as Jewelers Mutual advises. The limit: the International Gem Society notes that some imitation coatings change the result, so treat it as a clue, not a verdict.
  • 2. The drill holes. With a 10x loupe and good light, look into the hole where the thread enters. On real pearls the nacre usually runs cleanly to the edge of the opening. On imitations the coating may be chipped, flaking or built up in a ridge, or a different material may show underneath. Old imitation strands often give themselves away here first, because the holes are where the coating wears.
  • 3. The surface under magnification. Real pearls rarely look perfect up close: Jewelers Mutual points to tiny bumps, welts or ridges as a good sign. GIA's laboratory has described imitations that showed, under magnification, numerous minute particles with a glittering effect and none of the overlapping nacre platelets found on nacreous pearls.
  • 4. Matching. GIA says the pearls on a strand should match in all the quality factors, so good matching is normal and expected. What's suspicious is identical: every bead the same size, shape and tone with no variation at all, which Jewelers Mutual describes as almost too perfect.
  • 5. Luster. In daylight, real pearls tend to show depth, a glow that seems to come from inside, while many imitations look shiny only on the surface, or flat. This takes practice, and it's easiest side by side with a strand you know is real.

Weight and temperature get mentioned often but prove little. Real pearls feel cool at first and then warm against the skin, and a strand that feels very light may be plastic, but Jewelers Mutual notes that glass imitations can have real weight and feel cold too.

Tests that damage pearls

  • Vinegar or lemon juice. Pearls are made mainly of calcium carbonate and can be dissolved in vinegar, and GIA's gemstone durability study lists pearls as attacked by all acids. A pearl that fizzes is a pearl being damaged.
  • A lighter or a match. The same study warns that heat can cause a pearl to turn brown, burn or split.
  • Scratching with a knife or pin. It marks a real pearl's nacre for good and tells you less than a loupe does.
  • An ultrasonic cleaner before testing. GIA's study notes that ultrasonic vibration can enlarge cracks beneath the nacre or bring them to the surface. Wipe pearls with a soft cloth instead.

Natural or cultured: when you need a lab

No home test, and no loupe, separates natural pearls from cultured ones, because both have the same nacre surface. Cultured pearls are distinguished from natural pearls by X-ray examination, which shows the internal structure without harming the pearl: natural pearls usually show concentric growth, while bead-cultured pearls often show a distinct central nucleus. The International Gem Society calls X-ray analysis the most reliable verification for valuable, antique or natural-represented pearls.

That matters most for an old family strand, or one sold to you as natural. For those, get a gem lab's identification first, then an appraisal. For a cultured strand you simply want insured, the appraisal is the document you need; how to get pearls appraised walks through it.

What the answer changes at JewelryRepair.com

  • Restringing: Pearl Restringing is $15 plus $4 per inch for beads, including imitation pearls, and real pearls rather than beads add $20, so this is the one choice on the order that your test answers. Worked prices by length are in whether a pearl necklace can be shortened or lengthened and the pearl restringing cost guide.
  • Not sure which to choose? Pick your best guess. A jeweler confirms everything when the strand arrives, and if the scope changes, you approve it before any work begins.
  • Appraisal: a Jewelry Appraisal for a strand is $105, a written replacement value for insurance with photographs. It isn't a lab report; natural-versus-cultured identification stays with a gem lab.
  • Something wrong with the strand? For a loose clasp, missing pearls or damage you can't name, start with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full toward the work you approve. A pearl that has come off a ring or earring setting goes to a free photo quote through the contact page.

Before you ship pearls

  • Skip any cleaning before you pack: a soft cloth at most, no dips, no cleaners.
  • Write down what you already know in the order notes: a lab report, an earlier appraisal, where the strand came from, and whether you think it is pearls or beads.
  • Note the pearl count and the end-to-end length with the clasp, and take a photo, then put the strand in a soft pouch, padded so it can't shift, in any sturdy small box with nothing outside naming the contents. Drop it at any UPS location with the prepaid label from your account.
  • The $30 round-trip UPS shipping per order carries $100 of coverage in each direction. To cover a $3,000 strand in full, the fee is $72.50, which is 2.5% of the $2,900 above the first $100, paid once for both legs; full value is insurable up to $10,000. Someone signs for the box at each end.

Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, runs JewelryRepair.com and has completed over 50,000 repairs since 1989. At the New York studio a strand is photographed when it comes in and again before it goes back; a bench jeweler does any work, a second jeweler checks it, and repairs carry a 1-year workmanship guarantee.

Questions

Do real pearls feel gritty?
Yes, usually. Natural and cultured pearls are made of nacre platelets, so rubbing two together, or one gently along a tooth's edge, feels faintly sandy, while most imitations are completely smooth. It's a strong clue but not proof, because some imitation coatings change the feel. Check the drill holes with a 10x loupe as well before you decide.
Can you tell if pearls are real by their weight?
Not reliably. Real pearls have a solid heft, and a strand that feels feather-light may well be plastic, but glass imitations can have real weight and feel just as cool against the skin. Use weight only alongside the friction test and a close look at the drill holes, and leave natural-versus-cultured questions to a gem lab.
How can I tell if an old pearl necklace is real?
Use the same checks, starting with the drill holes. On older imitation strands the coating often wears or chips around the holes first, showing glass or plastic underneath, while real pearls show nacre right to the edge. If the strand passes and might be natural, only a lab's X-ray examination can say. A JewelryRepair.com appraisal, $105 for a strand, documents it for insurance once a lab has identified it.
Does the vinegar test for pearls work?
It works only by damaging the pearl, so don't use it. Pearls are made mainly of calcium carbonate, which dissolves in vinegar, and GIA lists pearls as attacked by all acids. Any bubbling you see is the surface being eaten away. Rubbing two pearls together and looking at the drill holes under magnification tell you more, without harm.
Are freshwater pearls real pearls?
Yes. Freshwater cultured pearls are real pearls grown in freshwater mollusks, with the same nacre surface as saltwater pearls, so they pass the same friction and drill-hole checks. They aren't imitations, and they restring at the pearl price: at JewelryRepair.com an 18-inch strand is $107 unknotted or $132 with a knot between each pearl.
Can a jeweler tell if pearls are natural or cultured?
Not by looking. A jeweler can usually separate pearls from imitations with a loupe, but natural and cultured pearls share the same nacre surface, and cultured pearls are told from natural ones by X-ray examination in a gem lab. A JewelryRepair.com appraisal, $105 for a strand, values it for insurance but isn't a lab identification report.