Jewelry repair questions · Pearls
How do I get pearls appraised, and what can a pearl appraisal tell me?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- For insurance, you want a written appraisal stating replacement value, from someone who has had the pearls in hand. The Insurance Information Institute says a standard homeowners policy generally limits jewelry theft to about $1,500, and that items must be professionally appraised before you buy a floater that covers them individually.
- Here, it's $105 for a strand. A Jewelry Appraisal is the same price for a necklace, bracelet or pendant, plus $30 round-trip UPS shipping per order. Rush adds $50 if your insurer is waiting.
- An appraisal isn't a lab report. Whether pearls are natural or cultured, and whether their color has been treated, are questions for a gemological laboratory. GIA, for its part, does not appraise anything submitted to it.
- It isn't an offer, either. JewelryRepair.com doesn't buy jewelry and isn't a pawn service, so it has no stake in the number.
- "Near me" can be your mailbox. The strand travels by UPS from any US address with a signature at both ends, or you can walk into the New York studio during studio hours.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Jewelry Appraisal | from $105 | Written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, from an in-hand examination. Necklace, bracelet, pendant and other item types are all $105. Rush +$50. |
| Pearl Restringing | from $15 + $4/inch | If the cord is stretched or broken, restring in the same box: pearls laid out in their original order, $132 for an 18-inch pearl strand knotted between each pearl. |
| Metal Testing & Verification | $15 | When you only want to know what the clasp is made of: hallmarks checked and the metal and karat tested and documented, with no valuation. |
What a pearl's value depends on
GIA's framework for what a pearl is worth has seven value factors:
- Size. When everything else is equal, larger pearls are rarer and more valuable than smaller ones of the same type.
- Shape. Round is the hardest shape to culture and the rarest, though well-formed pear, oval and baroque pearls are prized too.
- Color. Which colors command more changes with supply and demand.
- Luster. GIA calls it possibly the most important factor: within a type, higher luster means a more valuable pearl.
- Surface. A few minor blemishes matter little; numerous or severe ones can affect durability.
- Nacre. A visible bead nucleus or a dull, chalky look suggests thin nacre, which weakens both luster and durability.
- Matching. On a strand or a pair of earrings, the pearls should match across all of the factors above.
The strand itself matters as well: its length, whether it's uniform or graduated, how it's strung, and what the clasp is made of. A replacement-value appraisal arrives at one figure: what it would cost to replace the piece at retail today. That is a different number from what a buyer would pay you, as is an appraisal what jewelry would sell for? explains.
What it can't tell you, and when you need a lab
Some questions about pearls can only be answered with laboratory equipment. Cultured pearls are distinguished from natural ones by X-ray examination, and GIA's Pearl Identification Report states a pearl's identity (natural or cultured), the mollusk it came from when that can be determined, and any detectable treatments, along with quantity, weight, shape and color. Treatments are common: GIA says all types of pearls are routinely bleached with hydrogen peroxide, and notes that one-step bleaching of gems is generally very hard to detect. It adds that dye often improves the look of lower-quality pearls, and that some pearls are irradiated to dark gray colors. GIA also states that it does not certify or appraise any material submitted to it, so a lab report and an appraisal are two different documents that work together.
- A cultured strand you want insured, such as akoya, freshwater, South Sea or Tahitian: the appraisal is the document you need.
- A strand that might be natural, or an unusual pearl such as an abalone pearl: get the lab identification first, then send a copy with the piece for the appraisal.
- Black pearls: GIA notes that Tahitian cultured pearls are sometimes called black pearls and come in a wide color range. Separately, the great majority of inexpensive colored pearls have been dyed. Whether a dark color is natural changes the value, and it's a lab question.
- Possibly imitation: see how to tell if pearls are real before you pay for an appraisal; most costume strands don't justify one (is costume jewelry worth appraising?).
More on the difference between the two documents: is an appraisal the same as a GIA report?
How a pearl appraisal works at JewelryRepair.com
- Book it. On the Jewelry Appraisal page, choose Necklace, Bracelet or anklet, Pendant or charm, or Other; each is $105. The page's two optional checks, stone origin and treatment (+$20 each), are written for gemstones, so if you want either question answered for pearls, ask for a free quote through the on-site chat or the contact page before you book. A jeweler replies within 1 business day.
- Ship it. The prepaid UPS label is ready in your account within minutes of checkout. Include copies of any lab report, earlier appraisal or receipt.
- Intake. The strand is photographed the day it arrives at the New York studio, before anything else, and the photos appear in your account.
- The appraisal. A qualified appraiser examines the piece in hand, never from photos: the metal is tested and stamped marks verified, construction and condition are documented, and the appraiser researches what it would cost to replace the piece at retail today. You receive a written, photographed insurance-replacement-value appraisal, the written appraisal insurers ask for to schedule a piece. If you want to know how the write-up will describe your pearls, ask in the free quote before you book.
- Home again. The strand is photographed before it ships back by UPS, with a signature required at your door.
Getting several pieces appraised? The process is the same for rings and watches, covered in how to get jewelry appraised by mail.
What it costs, worked out
Prices from the live service pages, Nov 18, 2026. Shipping is $30 per order however many pieces share the box, with $100 of coverage each way; full value up to $10,000 costs 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions.
- An 18-inch cultured strand you'd value at $3,000: $105 appraisal + $30 shipping + $72.50 to cover its full value (2.5% of $2,900) = $207.50.
- The same strand, appraised and restrung with knots in one box: $105 + $132 Pearl Restringing ($15 + 18 × $4 + $20 for pearls + $25 for knots) + $30 + $72.50 = $339.50.
- A pearl necklace and a pearl bracelet worth $4,000 together, booked as two appraisals: $210 + $30 + $97.50 coverage (2.5% of $3,900) = $337.50.
- Rush: +$50 on each appraisal, shipping it back 2 to 3 days sooner.
For a strand worth more than $10,000, contact the studio before shipping. Re-appraising every so often keeps coverage in step with replacement cost; see how often jewelry should be reappraised.
Before you ship your pearls
- Pack them on their own: a soft pouch, padded so it can't shift in a sturdy box, never loose with other jewelry. Skip any deep clean before shipping; care is covered in how to clean real pearls.
- Keep the box plain. Nothing on the outside or the label should name the contents, and the issued label goes on the box you seal.
- Insure the full value by choosing "Insure the full value" before checkout. Coverage runs from the first UPS scan until the package is signed for, and a claim is paid up to that shipment's coverage.
- Photograph the strand before sealing and keep the UPS drop-off receipt until arrival is confirmed.
- In New York? Bring it in instead: 354 Lenox Avenue (Malcolm X Blvd), New York, NY 10027, Sunday to Thursday 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM, with an early close on Friday. Questions first: (212) 597-2899.
JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, the New York family jewelers behind over 50,000 repairs since 1989. It is independent and not affiliated with any pearl or jewelry brand, or with GIA, and its appraisals are not lab reports or GIA certificates.
Questions
How much does it cost to get pearls appraised?
Can pearls be appraised from photos?
Can an appraiser tell if my pearls are natural or cultured?
How are black pearls appraised?
Will a pearl appraisal tell me what I could sell my pearls for?
Should I restring my pearls before getting them appraised?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list