Jewelry repair questions · Engraving & appraisals
Is vintage costume jewelry, like old screw-back earrings, worth appraising?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Most costume jewelry has little material value. It's made to look like fine jewelry with base metals, plating, glass and plastic. When it's worth something, the value usually comes from collectors, not from the materials.
- An insurance appraisal states replacement value, not resale value. The IRS notes that in most cases there's no relationship between replacement cost and fair market value.
- Test before you appraise. Metal Testing is $15 an item; an appraisal is $105 an item, plus $30 shipping per order either way.
- Screw-backs help date a pair, not price it. Screw fittings for unpierced ears caught on from about 1909, and clip-ons in the 1930s, but fittings were easy to change.
- We don't value collectible costume pieces for resale, and JewelryRepair.com doesn't buy jewelry.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Metal Testing & Verification | $15 | The cheap first step: hallmarks and karat stamps examined under magnification, then the metal tested directly and the result documented. Catches heavy plating over base metal, the most common surprise in inherited jewelry. |
| Jewelry Appraisal | from $105 | For pieces that test as precious metal or carry real stones: a written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, from an in-hand examination. Stone origin or treatment checks add $20 each. Not a resale valuation, and not an offer to buy. |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | For condition rather than value: a jeweler examines the piece under magnification and sends photos and an itemized repair quote. Credited in full toward approved work. |
| Earring Back Conversion | from $40 | To wear them instead of value them: clip-ons converted to pierced, or a new back style fitted. Plated pieces aren't a listed metal here, and the new post is soldered on, so ask for a free quote first. |
Costume or fine? What to check before you pay anyone
Wikipedia's entry on costume jewelry describes pieces that use simulated stones such as rhinestones or lucite, crystals and cubic zirconia, plastic, and gold plating over pewter, nickel or other metals. A few minutes with a loupe or a phone camera on zoom sorts most of a jewelry box:
- Precious metal stamps: 10K, 14K, 18K or 417, 585, 750 for gold; 925 or Sterling for silver; Pt or Plat, sometimes with a number such as 900Pt, for platinum. See what 585, 750 and 925 stamps mean.
- Gold-over-base-metal marks: GF or a fraction such as 1/20 means gold filled, where the FTC requires the gold layer to be at least 1/20 of the metal's weight. RGP is rolled gold plate, GP is gold plate, and HGE is heavy gold electroplate, at least 2.5 microns. These pieces have real gold on the surface, but far less of it than a solid piece.
- A maker's mark on the back. Wikipedia notes the main collecting market is for signed pieces, with the maker's mark usually stamped on the reverse, and that unsigned pieces with unusual designs also find buyers.
- The stones. Rhinestones are glass, today lead glass sold as crystal glass, and classic ones have a metal coating on the back.
- Worn edges. Pinkish, brassy or gray metal showing through at edges and clasps means plating over base metal.
- Remember that stamps can lie. Counterfeit stamps exist and unstamped metal tells you nothing, which is why testing beats guessing.
What vintage screw-back earrings tell you
Screw-backs for unpierced ears use a U-shaped frame with a small screw that tightens against the earlobe. Navette Jewellery's history of earring patents traces the design to an 1894 patent by George Tilford and Arthur Bennett, notes that it didn't gain much traction until about 1909 onward, and dates the spread of clip-ons to the 1930s. So a pair of screw-backs suggests early- to mid-20th-century style, and the same source calls findings an important aid to dating jewelry.
What they don't tell you is value. Screw fittings were used on fine and costume earrings alike, and the same history warns that findings are easy to change as fashions change, so a fitting can be newer than the earring. Look for a karat or sterling stamp on the earring itself as well as on the fitting; a stamp on a replacement screw says nothing about the front. A gold pair has metal value and may have real stones. A base-metal pair set with glass is worth what a collector will pay, which depends on the maker, the design and the condition.
If you'd rather wear them than sell them, a missing screw or a tired fitting is usually fixable; see replacing a lost screw-back and converting clip-on earrings to pierced.
What an appraisal does, and doesn't, tell you
A Jewelry Appraisal here is a written insurance-replacement-value document with photographs. The appraiser examines the piece in hand: the metal is tested and marks verified, stones are measured in their settings and assessed under proper lighting, construction and condition are documented, and the appraiser researches what it would cost to replace the piece at retail today. For a glass-set brooch in plated brass, that document will say so honestly, but you'll have paid $135 to learn it.
It also answers a different question from the one most people with vintage costume jewelry are asking, which is what it would sell for. The IRS defines fair market value as the price a willing buyer and a willing seller would agree on, both knowing the relevant facts, and says that in most cases there's no relationship between replacement cost and fair market value. It adds that sentimental value has no effect on fair market value. The resale value of collectible costume jewelry is set in the secondary market of dealers, auctions and collectors that Wikipedia describes. JewelryRepair.com doesn't value collectible costume pieces for resale, isn't a buying or pawn service, and won't make you an offer. For a resale or fair-market-value figure, look for an independent personal-property appraiser who states fair market value rather than replacement cost. For a donation, IRS Publication 561 explains what counts as a qualified appraisal and a qualified appraiser, so ask your tax adviser or the estate's attorney which kind they need before booking anything.
When an appraisal is worth it
- Testing turns up precious metal. A screw-back pair, a brooch or a bracelet that tests as 14K gold or platinum, especially with real stones, deserves a proper description and value.
- You want it insured. The Insurance Information Institute says a standard homeowners policy generally limits jewelry theft to about $1,500, and that items must be professionally appraised before you can list them on a floater. If what you inherited is worth more than that limit, an appraisal is how you schedule it.
- The piece can't be replaced and you want proof of it. A photographed, written description is useful if it's ever lost, even when the dollar figure is modest.
- It isn't worth it when a piece is plainly plated base metal and glass, when you only want to know if something is gold (that's a $15 test), or when you want a sale price.
What it costs at JewelryRepair.com
Prices from the live service pages, Nov 18, 2026. Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, however many pieces are in the box, with the prepaid label ready in your account and $100 of coverage included each way.
- Test a mixed box first: six pieces through Metal Testing & Verification is $90 (6 × $15), or $120 with shipping.
- Appraise one piece: $105 + $30 shipping = $135. Two pieces: $210 + $30 = $240.
- Full-value coverage for anything worth more than $100: 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions. A $2,000 gold bracelet adds $47.50 (2.5% of $1,900).
- Stone checks: $20 each to determine a stone's origin or whether it's been treated.
- Re-plating a piece you'll wear: Gold Plating brass earrings with a yellow gold flash coat is $198 ($60 + $25 + $113).
- Converting earrings: Earring Back Conversion turns clip-ons into pierced earrings or fits a new back style: from $40 in sterling silver with a stick post, or $106 in 14K yellow gold ($40 + $55 + $11). Plated pieces aren't a listed metal, so they're quoted first.
A mixed box of inherited pieces travels in a plain box with nothing outside naming what's in it, signed for both ways, and every item is photographed on arrival at our New York studio and again before it goes home, so you have a record of each one. JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, and it isn't affiliated with any jewelry maker or brand.
Questions
Are vintage screw-back earrings worth anything?
How much does it cost to appraise costume jewelry?
How can I tell if old jewelry is real gold or costume?
Will an appraisal tell me what my costume jewelry would sell for?
Is signed costume jewelry valuable?
Can old costume jewelry be repaired or re-plated?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list