Repair questions · Earrings & pendants

What backs do vintage and antique earrings have, and can they be replaced?

Vintage earrings made for unpierced ears, mostly from the early 1900s to the 1950s, usually have a screw back, a U-shaped screw that tightens against the lobe, or a clip. Pierced pieces use hooks, wires or, later, posts with butterfly backs. Most can be restored or converted; at JewelryRepair.com, conversion to pierced posts starts at $40.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

1894patent for the U-shaped screw fitting for unpierced ears (Tilford and Bennett)
$40Earring Back Conversion in sterling silver, to stick posts
$19restoration evaluation for keeping original fittings, credited in full
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue

The short version

  • For unpierced ears: screw backs (ear screws) and clip-ons. Wikipedia notes that in the late 19th century and the first half of the 20th, piercing was out of fashion in the West and earrings were mostly clip-ons, until piercing came back in the late 1950s and early 1960s.
  • For pierced ears: hooks and wires on older pieces, then posts with butterfly backs, patented in the 1920s, and omega backs from the 1960s, according to a history of earring patents by Navette Jewellery.
  • Restore or convert: keep the original fitting working if the earrings are valuable as antiques; convert them if you want to wear them in pierced ears.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Earring Back Conversion from $40Clip-on to pierced, or a new back style: the old mechanism removed at its mount and a new fitting soldered on. Stick posts included; screwback or wire +$30, leverback +$40, omega +$60. Metal charges apply for gold, platinum and stainless steel.
Earring Post Repair from $30A bent, snapped or stripped post on a pierced earring replaced by soldering or laser welding, never glue. A single earring is $10 less.
Antique & Heirloom Restoration $19For keeping original screw or clip fittings working: a $19 evaluation, credited in full, then an itemized quote with photos at regular menu prices before any work.
Mail-In Evaluation $19Not sure what the fitting is or what it needs? An examination under magnification and an itemized quote with photos, credited in full.

How to identify the backs on vintage and antique earrings

  • Screw back for unpierced ears. A U-shaped frame behind the earring with a threaded screw ending in a small flat pad; you turn the screw until the pad presses the lobe. Navette Jewellery traces it to an 1894 patent by George Tilford and Arthur Bennett for a finding resembling the U-shaped screw that became popular in the 20th century, and notes screw fittings took off from about 1909. Wikipedia notes that ear screws can be adjusted for a more comfortable fit than clips.
  • Clip-on. A hinged lever that springs flat against the back of the lobe. Wikipedia describes the two pieces closing around the earlobe with mechanical pressure and says clip-ons have existed longer than any other non-pierced style; Navette cites an 1877 patent by Louis Weed for a finding that clipped onto the lobe, with a safety chain looped into the hair, and further clip and screw patents in the 1930s.
  • Hooks and wires for pierced ears. Navette shows an 1858 patent for an earring hooked inside the ear and an 1869 patent for a hook looping over the top and back of the ear. On a French hook, Wikipedia notes, the wire passes through the piercing without a closure.
  • Post with a butterfly back. A straight post with a friction back, which Wikipedia also calls a butterfly or scroll fitting. Navette dates the patents to the 1920s, so a post on an earring claimed to be much older may be a later replacement.
  • Omega back. A hinged loop that closes over the post for heavier pieces; Navette places it in the 1960s.
  • Threaded post with a screw back. Not the same as an ear screw: a pierced post cut with threads so a small nut can't slip off, which Wikipedia notes is used on some more expensive studs.

For dating a whole piece rather than its back, see how to tell if jewelry is antique or vintage.

Can the original backs be replaced or repaired?

  • A missing or stripped ear screw. A spare from another pair rarely fits (see the questions below), so the fitting is restored or replaced at the bench. At JewelryRepair.com that's Antique & Heirloom Restoration: the $19 evaluation, credited in full, then an itemized quote with photos before any work.
  • A clip that's weak, stiff or broken. Resist bending the lever by hand to tighten it. Wikipedia's article on work hardening notes that repeated flexing can lead to work hardening and stress cracking. A clip that won't hold, or has snapped, goes to the same restoration evaluation. More in fixing clip-on earrings that are too tight, loose or broken.
  • A bent, snapped or stripped post on a pierced pair. Earring Post Repair: the old post is removed flush at its pad, the surface is cleaned to bare metal, and a new post is soldered or laser-welded on, straight and true. Never glue.
  • A lost butterfly back. Usually just a new back in the same metal that fits the post; see replacing a lost earring back.

Converting vintage earrings to pierced: what changes

Earring Back Conversion is the job most vintage pairs come in for: clip-ons from a mother or grandmother, unworn because nobody in the family wears clips. The clip mechanism is removed cleanly at its mounting point, the surface is dressed back to bare, smooth metal, and the new fitting goes on: a soldered post for pierced ears, or a more secure system such as screwbacks, a leverback or an omega back. The earring itself is left untouched.

  • Ear screws: converted the same way in principle, but older screw fittings vary, so send photos for a free quote first through the on-site chat or the contact page.
  • Stones, paste and enamel near the fitting: laser welding keeps heat at a pinpoint. In a Ganoksin trade article, a jeweler describes welding findings onto pendants and brooches without affecting the finish, with the stones left in place.
  • Heavy pieces: large vintage earrings tend to tip forward on a plain post. An omega back or a leverback holds them steadier; see omega back earrings, the most secure earring backs and backs for heavy earrings.
  • Plated costume earrings: plated pieces that need solder work are quoted rather than booked at a set price, so send photos first.
  • What you give up: the original fitting. For a signed or valuable antique, that can matter to a collector, so decide before you ship, and say in your order notes if you want the original look kept as far as possible.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

Conversion is priced by metal and back style. Each service includes a clean and polish and the 1-year workmanship guarantee.

  • Earring Back Conversion in sterling silver: $40 with stick posts, $70 with screwbacks ($40 + $30), $80 with leverbacks ($40 + $40), $100 with omega backs ($40 + $60).
  • In 14K yellow gold: $106 with stick posts ($40 + $55 + $11), or $166 with omega backs ($40 + $55 + $11 + $60). 14K white or rose gold with stick posts is $112 ($40 + $61 + $11).
  • Earring Post Repair: $30 a pair in sterling silver, $20 for one earring; $40 a pair in 14K yellow gold ($30 + $6 + $4); $45 a pair with threaded screwback posts in silver ($30 + $15).
  • Keeping the original fittings: Antique & Heirloom Restoration, from the $19 evaluation, credited in full; each step is quoted at regular menu prices with photos.
  • Not sure of the metal? Choose "Not sure" and it's tested at no charge.

Send the pair together, both earrings in one box, so the new posts and backs match; shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, however many pairs are inside. Each earring is photographed on arrival and before it ships back, and a second jeweler checks the work at the New York studio of Sky Jewelry, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

Questions

How can I tell if vintage earrings are for pierced ears?
Look at what sits behind the lobe. A U-shaped frame with a screw and a small flat pad, or a hinged clip that springs flat against the lobe, means the earrings were made for unpierced ears. A hook, wire or straight post that passes through the lobe means pierced. A threaded post with a small nut is a pierced screw back, not an ear screw.
Can you replace the screw on a vintage screw-back earring?
Sometimes, but a spare screw from another pair rarely fits, because the screw and its threaded barrel were made together and threads aren't universal. If the screw is missing or stripped, the reliable fix is restoring or replacing the fitting at the bench. At JewelryRepair.com that starts with the $19 restoration evaluation, credited in full, and an itemized quote with photos.
Does converting antique clip-on earrings lower their value?
It can, for collectible pieces. The original fitting is part of how an antique earring is dated and described, and conversion removes it at its mounting point. For heirlooms you simply want to wear, conversion is often worth it. For a signed or valuable antique, consider restoring the clips instead: the $19 restoration evaluation, credited in full, comes with an itemized quote and photos before any work.
What backs should converted vintage earrings get?
Match the back to the weight. Light button earrings sit well on stick posts with friction backs, included in the $40 conversion price in silver. Heavier pieces, which tend to tip forward on a post, are steadier with an omega back (+$60) or a leverback (+$40), and screwbacks (+$30) suit studs you can't afford to lose. Gold adds a metal charge.
Are vintage costume earrings worth fixing?
Often, when you love them, but plated base metal needs a quote first. Costume earrings are often plated, and at JewelryRepair.com plated pieces that need solder work are quoted rather than booked at a set price. Send photos through the on-site chat or the contact page; a jeweler replies with an itemized quote within 1 business day, and nothing ships until you've seen the price.