Repair questions · Earrings & pendants
Can you replace a lost earring screw back, or does the post need changing?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- A screw back is a tiny nut, and it only works on a post with the same diameter and thread.
- If the post is straight and its threads are crisp, a matching back is all you need.
- If the post is bent, stripped or loose, or no back will catch, the post gets replaced with a new threaded one.
- Don't force a back that won't catch. Crossing the threads can ruin a good post.
- Earrings with push backs can be converted to screw backs.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Earring Post Repair (screwback posts) | from $45 a pair in sterling silver | Old post removed flush, the pad cleaned to bare metal, and a new threaded post soldered or laser-welded on square, in your earring's metal. One earring is $10 less. |
| Earring Back Conversion (to screwback) | from $70 in sterling silver | Replaces push-back or clip fittings with screwback posts and leaves the earring itself untouched. |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | Not sure if it's the back or the post: a magnified exam and an itemized quote with photos, credited in full. |
Why a spare screw back often won't fit
On a screw back earring, the post is cut with a fine thread and the back is a small nut threaded to match. A push or butterfly back grips a smooth post by spring tension alone. A screw back has to engage the thread, so the diameter and the thread both have to agree.
Diameter varies more than most people expect. One findings seller lists four common gauges for threaded posts: 21 gauge (0.71 mm), typical of baby and toddler earrings; 20 gauge (0.82 mm), common on less expensive pairs; 19 gauge (0.90 mm), which includes push-on, screw-off styles; and 18 gauge (1.0 mm), typical of finer pieces. Its rule is simple: the back's gauge has to match the post's. Stuller, a major supplier to bench jewelers, sells posts and backs as matched sets to take the guesswork out.
So a mixed pack of "universal" screw backs is a gamble. If a back goes on stiffly or only catches on the last turn, stop. Forcing it at an angle can cross and flatten the threads on the post, and then no back will hold.
Back or post? The quick check
Try the back from the matching earring on this post: if it threads on and tightens, the post is fine and you only need a back; if it spins or binds too, the post is the problem. Our screw back earrings glossary entry covers thread wear and cleaning in more detail.
Measure before you buy. If you're ordering a back, measure the widest part of the threaded section with a digital caliper and match it to the gauge. A back from another pair won't thread on unless both the gauge and the thread match, so a back sold to fit that brand or that post is the safer buy.
If only the back is missing
Get a back made for that post, in the same metal. For a branded pair, the maker or the store it came from is the first call, and if the earrings are still under the maker's warranty or service plan, check with them before anyone else works on them. Otherwise, a jeweler can try backs on the actual post, which beats ordering by guesswork. Match the metal as well as the thread: the American Academy of Dermatology names earring backs among the biggest culprits for nickel allergy, so a base-metal back on a gold post can still bother sensitive ears.
Until the right back arrives, keep the earring out of your ear rather than wearing it with a push back. A friction back is made to grip a smooth post, not a threaded one, so it's the easiest way to lose the earring itself.
There's no standalone listing for a loose back at JewelryRepair.com. If you'd like a jeweler's opinion on the pair first, ask for a free quote through the on-site chat or the contact page. You'll get an itemized reply within 1 business day, and nothing ships until you've seen the price. If it's hard to say whether the post is sound, the Mail-In Evaluation is $19, credited in full toward the repair.
If the post needs replacing: how a jeweler does it
A threaded post is a bench repair, never a glue job. In Earring Post Repair, the old post is removed flush at its pad, the pad is cleaned to bare metal, and a new screwback post in your earring's metal is soldered or laser-welded on, perpendicular and true. Laser welding is used when pearls, opals or other heat-sensitive material sit near the post, because it puts heat only at the joint. A post that has been bent is work-hardened and usually gets replaced rather than straightened.
If the pair has push backs and you're tired of losing them, Earring Back Conversion fits screwback posts instead and leaves the earring itself untouched. Screw backs take longer to put on, but they can't simply slide off; see the most secure earring backs.
What it costs at JewelryRepair.com
The configurator prices each job by metal and post style and shows the total before checkout. A new threaded post through Earring Post Repair adds $15 to the $30 base for the screwback style:
- Sterling silver: $30 + $15 = $45 for both earrings; one earring alone is $10 less, so $35.
- 14K gold: yellow is $30 + $6 metal + $4 karat + $15 = $55; white is $30 + $11 + $4 + $15 = $60. In 18K yellow it's $30 + $6 + $7 + $15 = $58.
- Platinum: $30 + $74 + $15 = $119.
Moving a pair from push backs to screw backs is Earring Back Conversion, with the screwback style at +$30 on a $40 base: $70 in sterling silver, $136 in 14K yellow gold ($40 + $55 + $11 + $30), $142 in 14K white ($40 + $61 + $11 + $30) and $238 in platinum ($40 + $168 + $30).
Send both earrings when you can, so posts and backs come back matched. A jeweler confirms everything on arrival, and if the job turns out different from what you booked, you approve the change before work begins.
Before you ship
Seal both earrings, and any back you still have, in a small bag padded inside a sturdy small box, and print the prepaid UPS label from your account. Shipping is $30 round trip per order with $100 of coverage each way; diamond studs can be covered for full value up to $10,000 at 2.5% of the value above $100, both directions, so a $2,500 pair costs $60 ($2,400 × 2.5%). The box is plain, and a signature is required both ways.
Sky Jewelry has been a family jeweler on Lenox Avenue since 1989, and threaded posts are routine bench work among its over 50,000 repairs. At the New York studio your earrings are photographed on arrival and again before they leave; a bench jeweler fits the post and a second jeweler checks the work. The repair carries a 1-year workmanship guarantee.
Questions
Are earring screw backs universal?
Why does my screw back spin without tightening?
Can I buy just a screw back for my earring?
How much does it cost to replace a screw back post?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list