Repair questions · Stones & settings

Can antique or vintage jewelry be restored, and what does it cost?

Usually, yes. Most antique and vintage jewelry can be restored: worn prongs, thin or cracked shanks, loose old-cut stones, tired hinges and faded engraving are bench work. There's no flat price; at JewelryRepair.com, restoration starts with a $19 evaluation, credited in full, then an itemized quote with photos at regular menu prices.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$19evaluation to start, credited in full toward the work you approve
$53re-tip 1 to 4 prongs in 14K yellow gold ($29 + $19 + $5)
from $250Hand Engraving to re-cut worn antique engraving, by free quote
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers

The short version

  • Most antique and vintage jewelry can be restored. Worn prongs, thin or cracked bands, loose or missing stones, failing hinges and clasps, chipped enamel and faded engraving are all bench work.
  • Good restoration keeps what makes a piece old: its original stones and cuts, its marks and its patina, unless you ask otherwise.
  • There's no typical total. The work is quoted step by step after a jeweler has examined the piece in hand.
  • At JewelryRepair.com it starts with a $19 evaluation, credited in full, and each step is priced at the same menu prices as any repair.
  • Some repairs aren't worth the risk. If a step looks unsafe for an antique, worn or previously repaired piece, you're told before any work.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Antique & Heirloom Restoration $19The $19 evaluation, credited in full. Every step is then quoted item by item at regular menu prices, with photos, before any work.
Prong Re-Tipping from $29New metal laser-welded onto 1 to 4 worn prong tips in silver; gold and platinum add a metal charge.
Prong Rebuild from $29A snapped or missing prong raised again from its base, same option charges as re-tipping.
Reset Loose Stone $89One shifted, sunken, tilted or fallen-out stone; the seat is re-cut and the stone set level.
Shank Repair from $45A cracked or cut band closed; a band worn thin can be re-shanked with new metal, half or all the way round.
Hand Engraving from $250Graver-cut re-cutting of worn antique engraving, by free quote.
Enamel Repair from $54Chips filled with color-matched enamel and polished flush; $54 covers one color and one location on silver ($34 + $10 + $10), each extra color or location +$10.

What "restored" should mean for an old piece

Repair makes a piece wearable again. Restoration does that while keeping its age intact, and much of the difference lies in what the jeweler leaves alone.

  • Original stones and cuts. Wikipedia's history of diamond cuts notes that many antique stones have been recut into modern brilliants to make them easier to sell, which erases the period look for good, so restoration resets the stone you have rather than recutting or swapping it. To date a piece by its old-cut stones and marks, see how to tell antique from vintage.
  • Patina. The soft darkening in recesses and the gently worn edges are part of an antique's character. Wikipedia's article on patina records that removing or reducing it may dramatically reduce an antique's value, though views on this differ. In antique restoration here, patina is preserved unless you ask for a full polish.
  • Marks. Hallmarks and maker's marks help date and identify a piece. If yours has them, mention it when you book so sizing seams or new metal can be planned around them where the construction allows.
  • Period technique. Worn hand engraving is re-cut by hand along the original lines, not replaced with machine lettering.

What can usually be restored, and which repair it is

  • Worn or broken prongs. Prong Re-Tipping laser-welds new metal onto worn tips, and Prong Rebuild raises a new prong where one has snapped off. Both start at $29 for 1 to 4 prongs.
  • A stone that has shifted, sunk or fallen out. Reset Loose Stone, $89 flat, re-cuts the seat and sets the stone level. A stone that's loose but still in place is Stone Tightening, from $50.
  • A missing old-cut or colored stone. Old cuts aren't an off-the-shelf item, so a replacement is matched, photo-quoted and approved by you before it's set. Expect options, not a promise of an exact match.
  • A thin, cracked or cut band. Shank Repair closes a crack from $45; a band worn too thin to solder can be re-shanked with new metal across the bottom half or all the way round.
  • Faded engraving. Hand Engraving, from $250 by free quote, re-cuts worn antique engraving with a graver.
  • Chipped enamel. Enamel Repair fills chips with color-matched enamel; very large restorations are quoted. See whether chipped enamel can be repaired.
  • Lockets and bangles that won't close, clasps that won't hold. Hinge Repair, from $50 for a bangle and $60 for a necklace in silver, with gold adding a metal and karat charge, and Clasp Replacement from $48. Pins and catches are covered in brooch repair.
  • A slack pearl strand. Pearl Restringing: $15 plus $4 per inch, plus $20 for genuine pearls rather than beads, so an 18-inch pearl strand is $107 unknotted ($15 + $72 + $20) or $132 hand-knotted ($107 + $25), restrung in the original order.

Why old pieces need a slower bench

Three things make antiques harder than new pieces: metal that has grown brittle with age, earlier solder joints hidden under patina, and stones cut to standards no modern stone matches off the shelf. Trade references explain what that changes at the bench.

  • Heat and stones. Writing in GIA's journal Gems & Gemology, gemologist and former bench jeweler Deborah Dupont Martin notes that heat-sensitive stones such as emerald, tsavorite and tanzanite can be damaged by soldering near them, that any stone risks thermal shock if heated or cooled too fast, and that the stone should come out of the mounting before a repair whenever possible.
  • Solder and spring. Goldsmithing author Erhard Brepohl advises using the lowest-temperature solder available on chains, and notes that soldering softens springy parts such as a clasp tongue, which then have to be hardened again before they work.
  • Earlier repairs. An old sizing seam or a soldered joint can hide under patina and only show under magnification, which is why the examination comes before the quote.
  • Laser welding. Prong tips are rebuilt here with a laser weld, which concentrates the heat in a pinpoint at the tip rather than heating the whole setting. It isn't risk-free for the stone, so the GIA advice above still applies: a heat-sensitive stone is better out of the mounting whenever it can come out. See laser welding vs soldering.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

There's no honest single figure for restoring an antique: one ring needs a prong, another a new half shank, two prongs and its engraving re-cut. What's fixed is how it's priced: every step is quoted at the same menu prices as any other repair, before work begins, and the $19 evaluation comes off the total. Examples from the live repair pages:

  • Re-tip 1 to 4 prongs in 14K yellow gold: $53 ($29 + $19 + $5). In 18K white gold: $65 ($29 + $23 + $13). In platinum: $224 ($29 + $195). Five to nine prongs add $45.
  • Reset a shifted or fallen-out stone: $89 flat.
  • Close a crack in a 14K yellow gold band: $57 ($45 + $7 + $5). Replace the bottom half of that band with new metal: $307 ($45 + $7 + $5 + $250).
  • Fill one small enamel chip in one color on silver: $54 ($34 + $10 per color + $10 per location).
  • Re-cut worn engraving by hand: from $250, set by free quote.

The credit works like this: approve a $53 prong re-tip after the $19 evaluation and you pay the $34 difference. Shipping is $30 round trip per order, however many pieces share the box.

When restoration isn't the right call

  • When the value may lie in its original condition. Have it documented and valued before anything changes. A Jewelry Appraisal, from $105, is a written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs; see appraising antique and estate jewelry.
  • When a repair would put the piece at risk. If a requested repair looks unsafe for an antique, worn or previously repaired piece, the studio says so before working. You can choose a gentler option, or leave a condition as it is; a condition you ask to leave isn't covered by the workmanship guarantee.
  • When it can't be worn as it was. Sometimes the better path is reusing the stones or metal in something new. Custom Work & Modifications starts with a $10 estimate; see whether a jeweler can redesign your jewelry.
  • When it's a vintage watch. Watches are a separate service; see whether an old watch is worth repairing.

Before you ship an heirloom

  • Photograph it from several angles before sealing the box, and list any marks, inscriptions and earlier repairs you know of in the order notes.
  • Don't dip or scrub it first: silver dips strip patina along with the dirt. See how to clean antique silver jewelry.
  • Seal any loose stones or broken parts in a small bag inside the package.
  • $100 of coverage is included each way. To cover a $4,000 heirloom for its full value, coverage is 2.5% of the $3,900 above $100, or $97.50, one fee for both directions, up to $10,000 per package.
  • Wrap an heirloom on its own, so a brittle hinge, a loose stone or a fragile pin can't knock against other pieces, then cushion it in a sturdy small box with nothing outside naming the contents and drop it at any UPS location with the prepaid label from your account. If you're nearby, walk-ins are welcome during studio hours at 354 Lenox Avenue (Malcolm X Blvd), New York, NY 10027.

Questions

Does restoring antique jewelry lower its value?
It can, if the restoration removes what makes the piece antique. Polishing away patina, recutting an old diamond into a modern brilliant or replacing original parts without need are the usual culprits; Wikipedia's article on patina notes that removing it may dramatically reduce an antique's value. Careful structural work, like re-tipping worn prongs or closing a cracked shank, protects a piece. Here, patina is preserved unless you ask otherwise, and you approve every step first.
Can an old European or old mine cut diamond be replaced?
Sometimes, but not off the shelf. Old cuts were proportioned differently from modern brilliants, and Wikipedia notes the old European cut shows more fire but less brilliance, so a modern stone can look out of place beside them. A larger missing stone is photo-quoted with options for your approval before it's sourced, and availability varies. If the stone is still with you, a shifted or fallen-out stone is reset for $89.
How much does it cost to restore antique jewelry?
There's no typical total; it's quoted step by step after a $19 evaluation, credited in full toward the work you approve. Each step is priced at the regular menu price: re-tipping 1 to 4 prongs in 14K yellow gold is $53 ($29 + $19 + $5), resetting a shifted or fallen-out stone is $89, and closing a crack in a 14K yellow gold band is $57 ($45 + $7 + $5). Shipping is $30 round trip per order.
Should I polish antique jewelry before or after restoration?
Lightly, if at all, and only after deciding with the jeweler. Polishing works by removing a thin surface layer of metal, and on an antique it also takes away patina and softens crisp edges, engraving and milgrain. Clean it gently instead. Every repair price here includes a clean and polish, but in antique restoration the patina is preserved unless you ask for a full polish.
How long does antique jewelry restoration take?
Longer than a single repair, because the piece is examined and quoted before any work starts. Most repairs here come back in about three weeks door to door; restoration adds the evaluation and the time you take to review the itemized quote, and a piece needing several steps takes longer than one needing a single repair. If you have a deadline, such as a wedding, say so when you book.
Can vintage costume jewelry be restored too?
Often, but it's a different job from gold or silver. Plated base metal can't always take solder or polishing the way solid metal can, so plated pieces that need solder work or polishing go to a free quote first. Start with a free photo quote through the on-site chat or contact page, or the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full toward the repair.