Repair questions · Chains, clasps & bracelets
Laser welding vs soldering: what's the difference in jewelry repair?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Soldering adds a filler alloy that melts below the metal it joins, so the piece itself never melts. Jewelers' hard solders flow above 450 °C, so a torch heats the whole area around the joint.
- Laser welding melts the metal itself at a pinpoint in short pulses, often adding wire of matching metal. The heat stays where the beam lands.
- The laser wins near heat-sensitive stones and enamel, on hollow chains and on worn prong tips.
- The torch still wins on solid, larger joins: ring sizing, solid chains, two rings soldered into a set.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Prong Re-Tipping | from $29 | Laser: new metal welded onto worn prong tips. 1 to 4 prongs: $29 silver, $53 in 14K yellow ($29 + $19 + $5), $57 in 14K white or rose ($29 + $23 + $5). |
| Chain Soldering | from $30 | Torch solder for solid chains, laser weld for hollow ones (+$20). One break: $30 silver, $41 in 14K yellow ($30 + $7 + $4); a hollow 14K yellow chain is $61. |
| Jump Ring Repair | from $19 | Solder flowed through the seam so the ring becomes a closed loop, or a heavier ring fitted. $19 silver, $31 in 14K yellow ($19 + $7 + $5). |
| Charm & Pendant Soldering | $69 | The link closed by solder, or by laser for delicate, enameled or stone-set charms so heat never reaches them. |
| Earring Post Repair | from $30 | New post soldered or laser-welded, never glued. $30 a pair in silver, $40 in 14K yellow ($30 + $6 + $4); a single earring is $10 less. |
| Shank Repair | from $45 | A cracked or cut band closed by laser where stones sit near the seam, by torch where the piece allows, then refinished. |
What actually happens at the bench
Soldering. The jeweler closes the gap so the edges touch, brushes on flux to keep oxides from blocking the bond, and brings the whole joint up to heat with a torch; the solder liquefies and capillary action pulls it into the seam. Gold and silver are joined with hard solder, which melts well above 450 °C, the conventional dividing line between soldering and brazing: even extra-easy silver solder (56% silver) melts at 618 °C, and extra-hard (80% silver) at 740 °C. Easy, medium and hard describe melting temperature, not strength. Jewelers start with the hardest solder and step down for later joints so the earlier ones don't reopen. Done well, a silver-solder joint can be stronger than the metal around it.
Laser welding. A bench laser concentrates light into a tiny spot (one jeweler in a Ganoksin trade article sets his from about 0.2 mm to 2 mm across) and fires it in short pulses. Because the energy is packed into so small an area the metal heats and cools almost at once, the weld is narrow, and the zone affected by heat stays small. The metal at the spot melts and fuses in milliseconds. Where a joint needs material, the jeweler melts in matching wire and builds it up. Another jeweler in the same article reports working as close as half a millimeter from heat-sensitive stones.
Which method for which repair
At JewelryRepair.com the bench chooses for each piece. This is how the common repairs divide:
- Worn or missing prongs: laser. Prong Re-Tipping welds new metal onto worn tips, and Prong Rebuild welds new wire and raises a complete prong from it, which is why a worn prong can usually be fixed with the stone in place.
- Hollow chains: laser. Hollow rope and herringbone links collapse under torch heat. Solid cable and box chains take a conventional torch solder through Chain Soldering.
- Charms and pendants with stones or enamel: laser. Closing the link with a pinpoint weld keeps torch heat away from enamel and delicate stones hanging right next to it.
- Jump rings: solder. Solder flowed through the seam turns an open ring into one continuous loop.
- Earring posts: either. The broken post is removed flush and a new one is soldered or laser-welded on straight, depending on the earring. Posts are never glued.
- Cracked or cut ring shanks: either. Laser where stones or delicate details sit near the seam, torch where the piece allows.
- Ring sizing, sizing beads and soldered sets: solder. Ring Resizing uses sizing stock matched to the ring's karat and color, soldered into the band.
There's no separate laser fee. Each repair page prices the job from the metal and options you pick; on Chain Soldering a hollow chain, which is laser-welded, adds $20. The jeweler uses whichever tool the piece calls for.
Where each one falls short
- Torch heat spreads. Stones that can't take heat may have to come out before a torch job, and heat softens metal across the whole area. The Ganoksin article notes that a laser, by heating only the target, avoids undoing earlier heat treatment (see annealing). On antique pieces, torch heat can oxidize the surface and shift colors. One jeweler in the Ganoksin article notes there's only a fine line between platinum's melting point and the heat a diamond can take, which is why a torch can frost a diamond during platinum prong work.
- Firestain on silver. Heating copper-bearing alloys such as sterling can leave firestain, a permanent red-purple discoloration that only comes out by removing surface metal, usually by polishing.
- Solder is a second alloy. The seam is a different alloy from the piece, so it's matched to the metal and color and finished flush.
- A laser isn't harmless to stones. Its heat is local, not absent. A jeweler quoted in the same article warns that lasers will damage diamonds the beam reaches. A stone sitting right at the joint can make any method risky, and if that's your piece, you hear it before any work.
- Some metals need special handling. Titanium has to be welded under argon or helium, and no solder repair page here lists it, so titanium pieces start with a free quote. Stainless steel is hard to solder, but Chain Soldering, Jump Ring Repair and Earring Post Repair list stainless prices, and the latter two list gold-plated or fashion pieces too. See soldering plated or stainless jewelry.
Is a laser weld stronger than solder?
Not automatically. Strength comes from a good fit and a sound joint more than from the heat source. Silver solder is partly absorbed by the surrounding metal, so a well-made hard-solder joint can be stronger than the metal it joins. A laser weld fuses the piece's own metal, but it's only as sound as the joint it closes. Jewelers also use the laser to fill porosity and to tack parts in place before soldering them, so plenty of repairs use both tools.
What matters to you is that the joint holds. At JewelryRepair.com a joint that reopens within a year of the piece coming back is redone at no charge under the 1-year workmanship guarantee, whichever method the bench used.
What it costs at JewelryRepair.com
Each repair is priced on its own page from the metal and options you pick, with the option arithmetic shown in the table on this page; platinum prong tips are the outlier at $224 for 1 to 4 prongs ($29 + $195). Weighing a home torch or hobby welder instead? Read whether you can solder jewelry at home first.
Not sure which repair your piece needs? The Mail-In Evaluation is $19, credited in full toward approved work. Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS with $100 of coverage each way, and a second jeweler checks every joint before it ships back. Sky Jewelry, the family jewelers on Lenox Avenue behind JewelryRepair.com, has done over 50,000 repairs since 1989, and the bench chooses torch or laser per piece, not per price list.
Questions
What is laser soldering in jewelry?
Can a jeweler laser weld a ring without removing the stones?
Does laser welding cost more than soldering?
Can a hollow gold chain be soldered?
Can tungsten or titanium rings be welded or soldered?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list