Repair questions · Engraving & appraisals

Laser, machine or hand engraving: what's the difference for jewelry?

All three put lettering into the metal; the tool is the difference. Machine engraving drags a diamond stylus at an even depth, hand engraving pushes a steel graver for lines that swell and taper, and a laser removes or marks metal without touching it. JewelryRepair.com machine-engraves rings from $60, and hand engraving starts at $250 by quote.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$60machine ring engraving in sterling silver, inside or outside the band
$250hand engraving, from, by free quote
$21to remove an existing laser engraving on a hand-engraving order
50,000+repairs since 1989 at Sky Jewelry's New York studio

The short version

  • Machine engraving pushes a diamond tip through the metal along a path the machine controls, so every stroke has the same width and every repeated letter is identical. It's the usual method for names, dates and initials.
  • Hand engraving is cut stroke by stroke with a steel graver. The line swells and tapers like calligraphy, which is why it's chosen for monograms, crests, ornament and restoring old engraving. It takes the longest and costs the most.
  • Laser engraving uses a focused beam, with nothing touching the piece. It copies a digital file exactly, but the result ranges from a real groove to a shallow surface mark, and the shallow ones wear fastest.
  • At JewelryRepair.com, rings, pendants, bracelets and case backs are machine-engraved, and hand engraving is quoted individually. Laser engraving isn't offered, but an existing laser inscription can be removed. For how a mail-in engraving order works, see how jewelry engraving works; this page compares the methods.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Ring Engraving from $60Machine engraving with a diamond stylus, inside or outside the band, script or block lettering. Tungsten and titanium are listed but have no metal choice of their own, so send photos for a free quote first. A custom image or font adds $50.
Necklace & Pendant Engraving from $60Pendants, bar necklaces, dog tags and lockets, machine-engraved in script or block lettering.
Watch & Bracelet Engraving from $35Bracelets, bangle interiors and clasps from $35; a watch case back adds $35.
Hand Engraving from $250Graver-cut lettering or ornament, and re-cutting worn antique engraving, by free quote. Ornamental +$50, black antiquing +$50, removing an existing laser engraving +$21.
Engraving Removal from $40An old inscription cut out and the surface refinished to match; if it's too deep to remove safely, you're shown options first.

Side by side: how the three compare

  • How the line looks. Machine: an even groove of constant width, in the lettering the machine carries (script or block here). Hand: the burin, or graver, produces a distinctive quality of line, and round and flat gravers are used on silver for bright cuts that flash in the light (both points from Wikipedia's engraving article). Laser: lines follow the file exactly and can be extremely fine; some laser marks aren't grooves at all but a change of color on the surface.
  • Depth, and how it wears. Every polish takes a little metal off the surface, so depth decides how long an inscription stays readable. Machine engraving here is cut deep enough to stay legible through years of polishing and wear, and shallow enough to leave the band's strength alone. Hand engraving's depth is controlled stroke by stroke, and deep ornamental cuts last. For lasers, the distinction is between engraving, which removes material and can reach 100 µm (a tenth of a millimeter) and beyond, and laser marking, which is typically shallower. A shallow mark has little to lose.
  • Detail. In high-grade work, such as game scenes and scrollwork, professional hand engravers can cut up to 40 lines per millimeter. A laser's strength is reproducing a scan, such as handwriting or a logo, without any interpretation.
  • Surfaces. Specialized laser machines can engrave the inside of a ring or the back of a watch, though metals are harder to laser-engrave than most materials because they resist heat and conduct it away. Engraving machines, which Wikipedia says are commonly used for inscriptions on rings, lockets and presentation pieces, reach the same surfaces with a cutting tip; the one used here carries a diamond stylus.
  • Time and cost. Machine engraving is the quickest; Wikipedia notes a simple item can take under ten minutes, which is why it's the least expensive. Hand engraving starts from a layout drawn for your piece, and it's priced by quote.

How to tell which method was used on a piece you own

Use a loupe or your phone camera's zoom, and look at a letter that appears more than once.

  • Hand-engraved: lines change width within a single letter, each stroke starts and ends in a fine point, the walls of the cut are bright and faceted, and no two copies of a letter are exactly alike.
  • Machine-engraved: a clean groove of the same width everywhere, letters that repeat exactly, and spacing that's perfectly regular.
  • Laser: no tool marks at all, very fine or filled-in shapes, and sometimes only a darker or colored area with almost no depth when you run a fingernail over it.

It matters when the piece needs work. Worn hand engraving is re-cut by hand, following the original lines, rather than replaced with machine type; see re-engraving a worn or misspelled inscription. A shallow laser mark may not survive the polish that comes with resizing or refinishing, so mention it in your order notes.

Which method suits which job

  • A name, date or short message inside a wedding band: machine engraving. It's legible, durable inside the band and the least expensive. Ring Engraving here starts at $60 in silver.
  • Handwriting or a small drawing: a custom image, +$50 on any machine engraving service here. Laser isn't offered here, so for very fine detail such as a fingerprint, send the image for a free quote and the jeweler will say whether it works machine-cut. More in engraving handwriting or a fingerprint.
  • A monogram, crest or signet: hand engraving, for line weight a font can't imitate. See engraving a signet ring.
  • Restoring worn antique engraving: hand engraving, re-cut along the original design. Hand Engraving covers this.
  • Tungsten or titanium bands: both are listed on Ring Engraving, but neither has its own metal choice in the order form, so send photos for a free quote before ordering. See engraving tungsten or titanium.
  • Gold-plated pieces: any cut deep enough to last can go through thin plating and show the base metal inside the letters. Ring Engraving lists gold-plated and fashion rings at $92 ($60 + $32); for other plated pieces, ask for a free quote first.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

Machine engraving is priced by metal, with a karat charge for gold:

  • Ring Engraving: $60 in sterling silver; $68 in 14K yellow gold ($60 + $6 + $2); $70 in 14K white or rose gold ($60 + $8 + $2); $72 in 18K yellow gold ($60 + $6 + $6); $113 in platinum ($60 + $53).
  • Necklace & Pendant Engraving: the same metal prices, from $60 in silver. A silver pendant with handwriting as a custom image is $110 ($60 + $50).
  • Watch & Bracelet Engraving: $35 for a silver bracelet; a stainless steel watch case back is $85 ($35 + $35 + $15).
  • Hand Engraving: from $250 by free quote. Ornamental work and black antiquing are $50 each, removing an existing laser engraving is $21, and metal surcharges run up to +$158; the quote sets the exact price.
  • Engraving Removal: $40 in silver, $48 in 14K yellow gold ($40 + $6 + $2). Removing an old inscription during a machine engraving order adds $21.

Rush Service (+$50) ships eligible machine engraving back 2 to 3 days sooner. Before cutting, the jeweler confirms the layout; the piece is photographed when it arrives and before it ships back, a second jeweler checks the inscription, and shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS. The work carries a 1-year workmanship guarantee, from Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

Questions

Is laser engraving better than machine engraving on a ring?
Neither is better across the board; they suit different jobs. A diamond-tip machine cuts a clean groove of even depth, ideal for names, dates and initials in standard lettering. A laser copies a digital file exactly, which suits handwriting or very fine detail, but a shallow laser mark has little depth to lose under polishing. JewelryRepair.com machine-engraves rings from $60 and doesn't offer laser engraving.
Why is hand engraving so much more expensive?
Because every line is cut by a person, from a layout drawn for your piece. The engraver pushes a hardened steel graver through the metal stroke by stroke, changing depth and angle so lines swell and taper, and a crest or ornament takes far longer than typing an inscription into a machine. At JewelryRepair.com hand engraving starts at $250 by free quote, against $60 for machine ring engraving in silver.
Can a laser engraving be removed or replaced?
Usually, yes: the old mark is taken out first, then the new one is cut. Engraving Removal at JewelryRepair.com starts at $40 and cuts the surrounding surface down past the deepest point of the old lettering before refinishing it; if an inscription is too deep to remove safely, you're shown options first. On a hand-engraving order, removing an existing laser engraving adds $21.
What kind of engraving is used inside wedding bands?
Mostly machine engraving, because an engraving machine cuts names and dates quickly at an even, legible depth; Wikipedia says such machines are commonly used for inscriptions on rings, lockets and presentation pieces. Hand engraving is chosen for ornament or a traditional script look, and a laser for copying a file such as handwriting. JewelryRepair.com machine-engraves bands inside or outside from $60.
Can a gold ring be laser engraved inside the band?
Yes, with the right equipment: specialized laser machines can engrave the inside of a ring, though metals are harder to laser-engrave than most materials. JewelryRepair.com doesn't laser-engrave; it machine-engraves inside the band with a diamond stylus, from $68 in 14K yellow gold ($60 + $6 + $2) or $70 in 14K white gold. For a handwriting file, a custom image adds $50.