Jewelry repair questions · Chains, clasps & bracelets

Can a broken lobster clasp be fixed, or does it need replacing?

Yes. A lobster clasp with a bent gate or a worn loop can sometimes be repaired, but a weak or broken spring is usually fixed by soldering on a new clasp sized to the chain. At JewelryRepair.com, Clasp Replacement starts at $48 for a small silver lobster, and repairing or replacing it costs the same.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$48small silver lobster clasp, repaired or replaced
$95medium 14K yellow gold lobster ($48 + $28 + $19)
$19Jump Ring Repair, when the ring holding the clasp failed
50,000+repairs since 1989

The short version

  • A lobster clasp has four parts that fail: the spring inside, the gate it closes, the loop at its base and the small jump ring joining it to the chain. Each has a different fix.
  • A tired or broken spring is usually solved with a new clasp, because the spring sits inside the body.
  • A bent gate or a stiff, gritty lever can sometimes be adjusted or cleaned back into working order.
  • If the clasp works but fell off, the jump ring joining it to the chain usually failed, a $19 repair in silver. If the clasp's own loop or the chain's end link broke instead, it's a new clasp or Chain Soldering.
  • Stop wearing it until it's fixed. Clasps let go while you're wearing them, which is how chains and pendants get lost.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Clasp Replacement from $48Your lobster clasp repaired when it's salvageable, or a new one matched to the chain's gauge and weight, soldered on and action-tested. Lobster sizes: small included, medium +$28, large +$34. Gold: 14K yellow +$19, 14K white +$21, 18K yellow +$24, 18K white +$27. Rush +$50.
Jump Ring Repair from $19The small ring joining clasp and chain soldered into a closed loop, or replaced with a heavier one. $31 in 14K yellow gold ($19 + $7 + $5).
Chain Soldering from $30For a link that broke beside the clasp: one break in sterling silver; gold, chain style and hollow links add to it.
Mail-In Evaluation $19Not sure which part failed? Examined under magnification, photographed and quoted item by item. Credited in full.

First, find out what actually failed

A lobster clasp is a fastener held closed by a spring: you press a small lever, the gate swings in, and the spring snaps it shut when you let go. Lay the chain on a table in good light, open and release the clasp a few times, and look at it from the side:

  • The gate creeps back slowly, stops short or leaves a gap. The spring is tired or broken. Light between the gate and the body when it's closed means the end ring of the chain can slip out.
  • The gate closes but sits outside the body, or wobbles. It's been bent, often by being forced open past its stop or knocked. A gate that has snapped off its pivot can't be bent back.
  • The lever feels gritty, stiff or stuck. Lotion, soap and dust can pack into the body. That's sometimes a cleaning problem rather than a broken part, and every repair here includes a clean.
  • The loop at the base looks oval or thin, or the jump ring has a gap at its seam. That ring rubs against the chain with every movement. According to Cooksongold's chain repair guide, most wear on a chain happens where the clasp joins it.
  • The body is dented, cracked or crushed. Common on light, hollow or plated clasps that were stepped on or squeezed with pliers. A crushed body usually means a new clasp.

Can't tell, or more than one thing looks wrong? The Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full) examines the whole chain under magnification and sends you an itemized quote with photos.

Repair or replace: how the decision is made

Replacement is the usual answer when the spring is the problem. The spring sits inside the clasp body, behind the gate, so it can't simply be swapped from outside. Cooksongold's guide notes that if the spring on a clasp is broken, you may need to find a closely matching clasp and reattach it. A new lobster, matched to the chain and soldered on, resets the whole mechanism.

Repairing the original makes sense when the clasp itself matters: a signed or stamped clasp, an antique piece, a clasp that matches a set, or one with a shape no stock clasp copies. It also makes sense for faults outside the spring, such as a gate that's only bent out of line or a lever jammed with grime.

At JewelryRepair.com you don't have to make that call alone, and it doesn't change the price. The Clasp Replacement configurator asks "Repair my clasp", "Replace it" or "Not sure", all at the same price. The jeweler repairs the original when it's salvageable. If you asked for a repair and the clasp can't be saved, you're told before anything changes, and you approve the new scope before work begins.

How a jeweler fixes it at the bench

The chain is photographed the day it arrives at the New York studio, before anything else. For a replacement, the old clasp comes off where it was soldered, and the new one is chosen against the chain rather than from a default size. Two things decide it: the gate has to open wide enough to take the chain's end ring without forcing, and the clasp has to suit the chain's weight, light enough not to drag a fine chain round to the front, sturdy enough that a heavy chain can't pull the gate open. The joining ring is then closed with solder rather than left as a pressed-shut gap, and the clasp is worked through its whole open-and-close action several times before the joins are polished. On white gold, solder work includes rhodium re-plating of the repaired area.

When only the ring between clasp and chain has opened, pressing it closed with pliers just puts the two ends back side by side, and the pull that parted them once will part them again. With Jump Ring Repair, the ends are lined up under magnification and soldered so the ring has no seam left to open; a ring that has stretched or was made of thin wire is swapped for a heavier one.

A bench jeweler does the work and a second jeweler checks it, and the whole chain is cleaned and polished. It's photographed again before it ships back, and the work carries a 1-year workmanship guarantee: if the new clasp or a solder joint fails within a year of delivery, it's redone at no charge. JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

From the live Clasp Replacement page, Nov 18, 2026. A lobster clasp is priced by size and metal, and the same price applies whether yours is repaired or replaced:

  • Sterling silver: $48 small, $76 medium ($48 + $28), $82 large ($48 + $34).
  • 14K yellow gold: $67 small ($48 + $19), $95 medium ($48 + $28 + $19), $101 large ($48 + $34 + $19).
  • 14K white gold: $69 small ($48 + $21), $97 medium, $103 large.
  • 18K yellow gold: $72 small ($48 + $24), $100 medium, $106 large.
  • 18K white gold: $75 small ($48 + $27), $103 medium, $109 large.
  • Rose gold, platinum, stainless steel or plated chains: ask for a free quote through the contact page first; a jeweler replies with an itemized price within 1 business day.

Related fixes: a failed jump ring is $19 in silver or $31 in 14K yellow gold ($19 + $7 + $5); a link broken beside the clasp is Chain Soldering from $30. Thinking of a different style? On the same page a small silver spring ring is also $48 and a box clasp starts at $130 in silver ($48 + $82); note the change you want in your order and the jeweler confirms it at intake, or ask for a free quote first. Rush is $50 and ships it back 2 to 3 days sooner. Shipping is $30 round trip per order, and a clasp job comes back in about three weeks door to door.

Can I fix a lobster clasp myself?

Partly, and only as a stopgap on fine jewelry:

  • An open jump ring can be closed with two pairs of flat or snipe-nose pliers, twisting the ends back together until the join is flush, the same way Cooksongold describes closing a chain link. It will hold for a while, but an unsoldered ring can open again under the same pull.
  • A gritty lever sometimes frees up after a soak in warm water with a drop of mild dish soap, a soft brush and a thorough dry.
  • A weak spring isn't a home repair. Prying the gate, bending it inward or adding glue usually jams the clasp for good or snaps the gate off its pivot.
  • Swapping in a new clasp on an open jump ring is fine for costume jewelry. On gold or a chain you'd hate to lose, that open ring becomes the weakest point; soldering it closed is what makes it permanent. Thinking of doing that yourself? See can I solder jewelry at home?

Before you ship

  • Leave the clasp attached if it still is, and put the chain and any loose parts, including a detached clasp or pendant, in a small sealed bag. Don't knot or tape the ends.
  • In the configurator, pick the clasp size and metal, and choose "Repair my clasp" if you want the original kept, or "Not sure" to let the jeweler advise.
  • Pack it in any sturdy small box with nothing on the outside naming the contents, pad the bag so it can't move inside the box (coverage requires it), print the prepaid label from your account, and drop it at any UPS location.
  • $100 of coverage is included each way. To cover a $1,500 gold chain in full, the fee is 2.5% of the $1,400 above $100, or $35, one fee for both directions. A signature is required at both ends, and coverage runs from the first UPS scan until the package is signed for.

Questions

How much does it cost to replace a lobster clasp?
At JewelryRepair.com, $48 for a small sterling silver lobster clasp, soldered on and action-tested. Size and metal add to it: a medium 14K yellow gold lobster is $95 ($48 + $28 + $19) and a large 18K white gold lobster $109 ($48 + $34 + $27). Repairing your original costs the same as replacing it, and shipping is $30 round trip per order.
Can you replace just the spring in a lobster clasp?
Sometimes, but a new clasp is usually the sound fix. The spring sits inside the clasp body behind the gate, and Cooksongold's repair guide suggests a closely matching new clasp when the spring is broken. At JewelryRepair.com, choose "Repair my clasp" and the jeweler repairs the original if it's salvageable, telling you before anything changes if it isn't.
Why does my lobster clasp keep coming open?
Usually because the spring has weakened and the gate no longer closes fully, leaving a gap the end ring can slide through. A bent gate does the same thing. A clasp too light for a heavy chain is another cause, which is why replacements are matched to the chain's weight. Stop wearing the piece until it's fixed; Clasp Replacement at JewelryRepair.com fits a clasp matched to the chain's weight, from $48.
Should I switch from a spring ring to a lobster clasp?
If you struggle with a spring ring's tiny tab, or the chain is heavy or worn daily, a lobster is often the easier and sturdier choice; many people find its lever easier to work than a spring ring's small pull. In sterling silver, a small lobster is the same $48 as a small spring ring at JewelryRepair.com. Choose Lobster in the configurator and note the switch in your order; the jeweler confirms it at intake.
Can the lobster clasp on a bracelet or anklet be replaced?
Yes. Chain-style bracelets and anklets use the same Clasp Replacement service as necklaces at JewelryRepair.com, from $48 for a small silver lobster, sized to the bracelet's chain and soldered on. A box clasp, common on tennis bracelets, is priced on the same page from $130 in silver, and a hinged bangle clasp goes to Hinge Repair.
How do you fix a lobster clasp that won't close?
It depends on why it won't close: a weak or broken spring usually means a new clasp, while a gate that's only bent out of line can sometimes be eased back. Check from the side whether the gate stops short (spring) or sits outside the body (bent). At JewelryRepair.com, Clasp Replacement is $48 for a small silver lobster whether the original is repaired or replaced, and it comes back in about three weeks door to door.