Jewelry repair questions · Stones & settings

Can a missing cubic zirconia be replaced?

Yes. A jeweler measures the empty seat, matches a cubic zirconia to its size, shape and color, and sets it the way the mounting holds its other stones. Because CZ is inexpensive, labor is most of the cost: at JewelryRepair.com, setting one small side stone starts at $23 in sterling silver.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$23one small side stone set in sterling silver ($5 + $18)
$18each additional side stone
$75a 0.5 to 1 ct center stone you supply, set in sterling silver ($5 + $70)
50,000+repairs since 1989, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue

The short version

  • Yes, in almost any sound setting. Cubic zirconia (CZ) is mass-produced in many colors, so a replacement can be matched to the empty seat by size, shape and color.
  • Fix why it fell out first. A worn, bent or snapped prong, worn pavé beads or a spread channel will lose the new stone too.
  • Expect a close match, not a twin, or use the empty seat to upgrade to a diamond or moissanite.
  • Gold-plated and base-metal fashion pieces start with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full; for an inexpensive piece, weigh the repair plus $30 shipping against what it cost.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Gemstone Replacement from $23Matching and setting for a missing stone: one side stone under 0.5 ct in sterling silver with prongs ($5 base + $18). Each extra side stone +$18; pavé +$6, channel +$12, bezel +$17; 14K yellow gold $37 ($23 + $10 + $4), 14K white gold $44 ($23 + $17 + $4). Small accent stones are matched and set at the listed price; larger or colored stones are photo-quoted for approval before sourcing.
Gemstone Replacement & Setting from $75 center stone (silver)
from $23 side stone (silver)
Labor only, for a stone you supply: a 0.5 to 1 ct center stone ($5 + $70) or a side stone under 0.5 ct ($5 + $18), in sterling silver with prongs. 14K white gold center stone $96 ($75 + $17 + $4).
Prong Rebuild from $29The usual reason a stone goes missing: a snapped or worn-down prong rebuilt from its base before the new stone goes in. One to four prongs in sterling silver; $57 in 14K white gold ($29 + $23 + $5).
Stone Tightening from $50Neighboring stones that have started to move, tightened under 10x magnification, up to eight stones per order. Yellow gold +$5, white gold +$10.
Mail-In Evaluation $19For plated fashion pieces, bands missing several stones, or anything you're unsure about: examined under magnification, with photos and an itemized quote. Credited in full toward approved work.

Why a CZ goes missing, and why that matters for the repair

A CZ rarely drops out of a sound setting. Something let go first, and a new stone is only as secure as the metal that holds it:

  • A prong wore thin, bent or snapped. GIA notes that a stone loose in its setting can wear through a prong over time. The prong is rebuilt or re-tipped before the new stone goes in; Prong Rebuild starts at $29 for one to four prongs in silver.
  • Pavé beads wore down. Pavé stones are held by tiny raised beads of metal. GIA's study of gemstone durability warns that careless polishing of pavé pieces can weaken or remove those beads and lose stones.
  • A channel spread. A Ganoksin lesson on channel setting explains that the walls of an open-backed channel can spread apart over time until stones come loose or fall out.

When one stone in a row is gone, check its neighbors: they've often lost grip too. When the piece arrives, the jeweler checks the stones around the gap, and any that move can be tightened in the same order with Stone Tightening, from $50 for up to eight stones.

Matching a cubic zirconia: what's matched, and what varies

  • Size, in millimeters. The seat is measured across and in depth. Carat weight doesn't carry over from diamond: CZ is about 1.65 to 1.7 times as dense, so a CZ the size of a one-carat diamond weighs well over a carat. If you buy your own stone, buy it by millimeter size.
  • Shape and cut. Round, princess, pear, marquise and the rest have to match the seat's outline, or the stone won't sit level.
  • Color. Colorless is the most common, but colors are made by adding elements as the crystal grows: cerium for yellow, orange and red, chromium for green, cobalt for lilac to blue. GIA notes pink and yellow CZs are used to imitate colored diamonds.
  • Age. GIA notes CZ will yellow over time. It's also softer than diamond, about 8 to 8.5 on the Mohs scale against 10, so its facet edges wear faster. A crisp new stone beside ten-year-old ones may stand out. Replacing the whole row keeps them even, at $18 in labor for each extra side stone.

How the replacement is set

At the JewelryRepair.com bench in New York, run by Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue with over 50,000 repairs since 1989, the piece is photographed on arrival. The jeweler measures the empty seat, trues it if wear has pushed it out of shape, levels the new stone and secures it the way the mounting was built to hold it: prongs burnished over its edge, pavé beads raised and pushed, channel walls tightened, or a bezel rubbed evenly around the rim. A second jeweler checks the work, and the piece is photographed again before it ships back, so you can compare the photos in your account.

Gemstone Replacement is the matching service. JewelryRepair.com matches and sets small accent stones at the listed price; larger or colored stones are photo-quoted with options for your approval before sourcing, and if no option suits you, nothing is owed for stones. If you'd rather buy the stone yourself, Gemstone Replacement & Setting covers the labor only.

Upgrading instead: a diamond or moissanite in the CZ's seat

An empty seat is also the cheapest moment to put in something harder. A diamond, natural or lab-grown, rates 10 on the Mohs scale against CZ's 8 to 8.5, so it keeps a crisp edge far longer; see lab-grown diamond and moissanite for how those compare.

  • A diamond: Diamond Setting is $65 for one center diamond in sterling silver ($5 + $60), $78 in 14K yellow gold ($65 + $9 + $4), or $20 for a side diamond in silver ($5 + $15). The diamond is supplied by you or sourced and quoted separately.
  • Moissanite or another stone you supply: Gemstone Replacement & Setting, $75 for a 0.5 to 1 ct center stone in silver.
  • Fit comes first. A stone of the same width can be deeper or shallower than the CZ it replaces, so the jeweler confirms the fit on arrival. If the head has to change, that's quoted first under Custom Work & Modifications ($10 estimate).

Thinking of a diamond in a silver ring? Read can a diamond be set in sterling silver? first.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

Prices from the live repair pages, Nov 18, 2026. Labor is priced by the metal, the number of stones and the setting style; prongs add nothing.

  • One small side stone, sterling silver, prongs: $23 ($5 + $18). In pavé, $29 ($23 + $6); in a bezel, $40 ($23 + $17).
  • Three side stones in silver: $59 ($23 + $18 + $18).
  • One side stone in 14K gold: $37 in yellow ($23 + $10 + $4), $44 in white ($23 + $17 + $4); channel-set in 14K yellow, $49 ($37 + $12).
  • A center stone you supply, 0.5 to 1 ct: $75 in silver ($5 + $70), $89 in 14K yellow gold ($75 + $10 + $4), $96 in 14K white gold ($75 + $17 + $4).

Shipping is $30 round trip per order, the same however many pieces are in the box, so one silver side stone comes to $53 door to door ($23 + $30). Every price includes a clean and polish and the 1-year workmanship guarantee, which covers a stone the bench set that later loosens. Our stone replacement cost guide shows how labor and stone prices combine for pricier stones.

When replacing it isn't worth it, or can't be done

  • The piece is gold-plated or base metal. Start with the Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full). Weigh the repair plus $30 shipping against what the piece cost; for an inexpensive fashion piece, replacing it can be the better buy. See can costume jewelry be repaired?
  • There's nothing left to hold a stone. If the prongs are worn to stubs or the seat is broken, the setting is rebuilt first and priced as its own line.
  • You're tempted to glue it. Glue isn't a setting, and it has to come off before a stone can be set properly; see can I glue a stone back into my ring?
  • Several stones are missing from a pavé or channel band. That usually points to a worn or bent band. Start with the Mail-In Evaluation, $19 and credited in full toward the repair.
  • The piece is under a maker's or retailer's warranty or care plan. Check with them first, because outside work can void it.

Before you ship

If you found the stone that fell out, send it sealed in a small bag. Setting a side stone you supply is $23 in silver labor under Gemstone Replacement & Setting, so reusing it makes sense unless it's chipped or dull; the jeweler tells you on arrival. A photo of the piece when it was complete helps with color matching, and a note on which stone is missing saves a question.

$100 of UPS coverage is included each way, which covers many CZ pieces; a gold setting worth more can be insured in full for 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions. Details are on shipping and insurance.

Questions

How much does it cost to replace a cubic zirconia stone?
At JewelryRepair.com, setting labor starts at $23 for one small side stone in sterling silver with prongs ($5 base + $18); 14K gold costs more, and each extra side stone adds $18. Setting a 0.5 to 1 carat center stone you supply is $75 in silver. Shipping is $30 round trip per order, and every price includes a clean and polish. The full breakdown is in the cost section on this page.
Can I buy my own cubic zirconia and have it set?
Yes. Gemstone Replacement & Setting at JewelryRepair.com covers labor only for a stone you supply: $23 for a side stone or $75 for a 0.5 to 1 carat center stone, both in sterling silver. Buy by millimeter size and shape rather than carat weight, since CZ is about 1.7 times as dense as diamond. Seal the stone in a small bag and pack it with the piece.
Will a new cubic zirconia match the old stones?
Closely, but often not perfectly. GIA notes CZ will yellow over time, and years of wear dull its facet edges, so a new stone can look whiter and sharper than its neighbors. If one bright stone bothers you, replacing the row keeps them even; at JewelryRepair.com each extra side stone adds $18 in labor, and larger or colored stones are quoted for your approval before sourcing.
Can a cubic zirconia be replaced with a real diamond?
Yes, if the diamond fits the seat. Diamond Setting at JewelryRepair.com is $65 to set one center diamond in sterling silver ($5 + $60) and $20 for a side diamond, with the diamond supplied by you or quoted separately. The jeweler confirms the fit on arrival; if the head has to change, that's quoted first under Custom Work & Modifications, which starts with a $10 estimate.