Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing
Does cubic zirconia or moissanite jewelry tarnish?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Cubic zirconia doesn't tarnish. It's zirconium dioxide, a chemically stable crystal.
- Moissanite doesn't tarnish. It's silicon carbide, and GIA rates it 9.25 on the Mohs scale.
- Diamonds, zircon and rhinestones don't tarnish either; rhinestones are glass or acrylic.
- What does tarnish is the metal. Sterling silver darkens, brass and copper discolor, and gold plating wears thin and lets the metal underneath show and react.
- A cloudy stone is almost always grime on the back of it, not tarnish, and it washes off.
- A CZ that stays dull or turns yellowish after cleaning is worn or aging, and the fix is a new stone.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Jewelry Spa | from $44 | Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish clear the buildup behind stones set in solid silver or gold, followed by a written inspection report. Silver necklace or bracelet $56 ($44 + $12). Glued or plated pieces: free quote first. |
| Rhodium Plating | from $69 | For sterling CZ jewelry that keeps tarnishing: polished, cleaned and re-plated. Silver ring $69, earrings $89 ($69 + $20), necklace $109 ($69 + $40). |
| Gemstone Replacement | from $23 | Setting labor $23 for one side stone in silver ($5 + $18); the replacement stone is priced separately, and you approve it and its price before setting. |
| Stone Tightening | from $50 | Loose stones tightened under 10x magnification, up to eight per order. |
| Gold Plating | from $60 | Fresh gold over worn plating. A sterling silver ring is $60; a brass base adds $113, so a brass ring is $173. |
Why the stone stays clear but the setting darkens
Tarnish is a reaction between a metal and the air. The Sheffield Assay Office explains that in sterling silver, both the silver and the copper alloyed with it react with sulfur-containing gases to form dark sulfides. Jewelers Mutual explains gold-plated pieces the same way: when the plating thins, the metal underneath meets oxygen, moisture and sulfur, and the color change comes through. Tarnish needs a reactive metal, and the stones don't offer one.
- Cubic zirconia is the cubic crystal form of zirconium dioxide, held stable by an added oxide such as yttrium or calcium oxide. It's chemically stable enough that industry uses it as a window for monitoring corrosive liquids, as its Wikipedia entry notes.
- Moissanite is silicon carbide (SiC), which is insoluble, and GIA rates it 9.25 on the Mohs scale; it has no reactive metal to tarnish.
- Zircon is a different stone: a natural mineral, ZrSiO4, that GIA says is often confused with cubic zirconia. It isn't a metal either, so if zircon jewelry darkens, look at the setting. GIA puts it at 6 to 7.5 on the Mohs scale, softer than CZ, so it scratches more easily.
- Diamond is carbon and doesn't tarnish either, so "do diamonds tarnish" has the same answer: look at the metal.
- Rhinestones are glass, or sometimes acrylic, with a metallic coating on the back that gives them their sparkle. The glass doesn't tarnish; the base metal of a costume piece does. Wipe rhinestone pieces rather than soaking them, and see how to clean tarnished costume jewelry.
The metal decides how a CZ piece ages
- Sterling silver, often stamped 925, darkens over time, and faster with humidity, lotion, perfume and hairspray, says the Sheffield Assay Office. Much silver CZ and moissanite jewelry is rhodium-plated, which keeps tarnish off until the plating wears through; our rhodium plating guide puts that at about 1 to 3 years on a ring, and 12 to 24 months on engagement rings and wedding bands worn daily. See does rhodium-plated jewelry tarnish?
- Gold-plated brass or copper is the base of a lot of fashion CZ jewelry. Jewelers Mutual notes that plated pieces discolor sooner when they're worn often and get wet, and that chlorine, bleach and harsh cleaners speed it up; see does brass or copper costume jewelry tarnish? The copper in these alloys is also what can mark skin green; see why a ring turns your finger green.
- Gold vermeil is gold over sterling silver, so it behaves like plating over a metal that tarnishes; see does gold vermeil tarnish?
- Solid gold, platinum and stainless steel settings are far less prone to it; see does real gold tarnish? and does stainless steel jewelry tarnish?
- Not sure what it's made of? Look for a stamp inside the band or near the clasp (what the stamps mean), or book Metal Testing & Verification, $15 per item.
Cloudy, dull or yellow? How to tell what's wrong
- The stone looks cloudy or greasy: lotion, soap and skin oil have built up on the back of the stone, where light enters and reflects back out. A proper clean fixes it.
- The metal around the stone is gray, brown or black: tarnish on the setting. Clean it, then polish the metal.
- The stone stays dull after cleaning, and its facet edges look rounded or scratched under magnification: likely wear. GIA puts CZ at 8.5 on the Mohs scale, below diamond, which tops the scale at 10. Because CZ is softer, its facet edges are less sharp than a diamond's from the start, and Wikipedia notes they can look dull and rounded; a softer stone also takes scratches more readily in daily wear.
- The CZ has turned faintly yellow: GIA says CZ will yellow in color over time. That's in the stone, so no cleaning removes it.
- A colored or rainbow coating has worn patchy: Wikipedia describes precious-metal iridescent coatings on CZ as not durable, because they're soft and wear poorly. A worn coating can't be polished back.
- A stone moves, rattles or sits crooked: it's loose. Stop wearing the piece until it's tightened, or you may lose the stone.
Cleaning CZ jewelry without losing a stone
The general method for stone-set silver is in how to clean silver jewelry with stones. What changes with CZ is the kind of piece it usually sits in:
- Check the stones before you clean. Look for a stone that sits crooked or moves when you touch it; a loose CZ can drop out in the wash. GIA notes ultrasonic and steam cleaners can loosen stones in their settings, which is why a bench checks first.
- Inexpensive fashion CZ may be glued. No soaking, no ultrasonic: wipe the stones and work around them with a soft brush and a little soapy water, then dry at once.
- Rainbow, "mystic" or colored-coated CZ: the coating is the soft part, as the Wikipedia entry on CZ notes, so keep polishing cloths and abrasives off the stone and clean the metal only.
- Silver around the stones: a polishing cloth on the metal, not a dip. Jewelers Mutual warns commercial silver cleaners may damage stones.
- Gold-plated settings: a soft cloth and mild soap, nothing harsh, as Jewelers Mutual advises for plating.
When a professional fix is worth it, and when it isn't
JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, a family of jewelers on Lenox Avenue in New York with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. For CZ and moissanite pieces:
- Grimy, dull or lightly tarnished: Jewelry Spa, $44 for a silver ring, earrings or pendant, $56 for a silver necklace or bracelet ($44 + $12), $68 for a 14K white gold ring ($44 + $19 + $5). Ultrasonic, steam and hand polish, with a written inspection report, for stones set in solid silver or gold (prong, bezel or pavé). For glued or plated fashion pieces, ask for a free quote first or book the $19 Mail-In Evaluation.
- Sterling that keeps tarnishing: Rhodium Plating, $69 for a silver ring, $89 for earrings ($69 + $20), $109 for a necklace ($69 + $40). The piece is polished and cleaned before the fresh rhodium goes on.
- A worn, yellowed or missing CZ: Gemstone Replacement, setting labor from $23 for one side stone in silver ($5 + $18); you approve the stone and its price before setting. Re-polishing a mounted stone through Gemstone Polishing starts at $95 ($65 + $30 mounted), so for CZ a new stone is usually the better value. See can a missing cubic zirconia be replaced?
- Loose stones: Stone Tightening from $50, under 10x magnification.
- Worn gold plating: Gold Plating starts at $60 over sterling, but a brass base adds $113, so a brass ring is $173. On inexpensive fashion jewelry that can be more than the piece cost, and you should hear that before you pay for it.
Not sure what the piece is made of, or whether it's worth it? Ask for a free quote through the on-site chat or the contact page, or book the Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full). Plated pieces that need polishing are priced by quote. Shipping is $30 round trip by UPS per order. Each piece is photographed when it's unpacked and again before it's boxed for return, and a second jeweler checks the stones. Repairs carry a 1-year workmanship guarantee.
Questions
Does cubic zirconia turn your finger green?
Does sterling silver with cubic zirconia tarnish?
Does moissanite get cloudy over time?
How long does cubic zirconia jewelry last?
Can a cloudy cubic zirconia be fixed?
Do rhinestones tarnish?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list
Sources
- www.gia.edu
- www.gia.edu
- en.wikipedia.org
- en.wikipedia.org
- en.wikipedia.org
- en.wikipedia.org
- assayoffice.co.uk
- ode3.jewelersmutual.com
- ode3.jewelersmutual.com
- www.canada.ca
- www.gia.edu
- sciencenotes.org
- jewelryrepair.com
- jewelryrepair.com
- jewelryrepair.com
- jewelryrepair.com
- jewelryrepair.com
- jewelryrepair.com
- jewelryrepair.com
- jewelryrepair.com
- jewelryrepair.com