Repair questions · Earrings & pendants

How to fix a broken earring hook, and when to have it replaced

A snapped, kinked or worn ear wire is cut away and a new one in the earring's metal is soldered or laser-welded on, or simply swapped if it hangs from an open loop. At JewelryRepair.com, new wires under Earring Post Repair are $50 a pair in sterling silver and $60 in 14K yellow gold.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$50new ear wires for a pair in sterling silver ($30 + $20 for the wire style)
$40one earring in sterling silver, $10 less than the pair
$19Jump Ring Repair when the drop, not the hook, came off
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers

The short version

  • Yes, it's replaceable, and the earring itself usually isn't touched: the broken wire comes off and a new one goes on in the same metal.
  • How it's attached decides the job. A hook on an open loop can be swapped with two pairs of pliers; a soldered hook is bench work.
  • Check what actually broke. If the hook is fine but the drop fell off, the small ring between them opened, a cheaper fix.
  • Never glue a hook. It flexes every time the earring goes in or out.
  • At JewelryRepair.com: Earring Post Repair with the wire style is $50 a pair in sterling silver, $40 for one earring and $60 a pair in 14K yellow gold.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Earring Post Repair from $50 a pair (ear wire style)A broken, bent or worn ear wire removed and a new one in your earring's metal soldered or laser-welded on, never glued. One earring is $10 less. 14K yellow gold $60 a pair; 14K white or rose gold $65.
Earring Back Conversion from $80 to leverbackReplace open hooks with leverbacks, which lock behind the lobe, while the earrings are on the bench. $146 in 14K yellow gold ($40 + $55 + $11 + $40).
Jump Ring Repair from $19The small ring between the hook and the drop soldered closed, or replaced with a heavier one, so the drop can't slide off again. A second ring adds $20.
Mail-In Evaluation $19For a hook formed as part of the design, a kidney-wire catch, or anything you can't identify: an itemized quote with photos, credited in full.

Find where it broke

Zoom in with your phone's camera. Where the wire failed tells you what the repair involves:

  • At the coil or small loop where the hook meets the drop. It's the spot that flexes every time the earring swings, and the most common break.
  • Along the curve. Usually at a place that was bent open and pushed back before; repeated bends at one spot end in a crack (more on why under hardness, below).
  • At a solder joint, where the wire meets a bead, a pad or the earring's frame. The joint failed rather than the wire.
  • Worn thin where the wire rests in your piercing.
  • The hook is whole, but the drop came off. The small jump ring between them opened. That's Jump Ring Repair, from $19, and the hook can stay.
  • A leverback whose lever won't snap, or a hinged hoop that won't close, is a mechanism repair: see leverback earring repair and a hoop earring that won't close.

How the hook is attached decides the fix

  • Hung from an open loop. Common on fashion and handmade earrings: the hook's small loop was twisted open, slipped through the drop and twisted shut. Swapping it needs no heat (see below).
  • Soldered on. On most fine jewelry the hook's loop is soldered closed, or the wire is soldered straight to the earring. The stub is removed flush and a new wire soldered or laser-welded on. A laser beam is a concentrated heat source with a small heat-affected zone, so it's the tool of choice beside pearls, opals, enamel or plating.
  • Part of the design. Some earrings are made from one continuous wire, with the hook formed from the same piece as the decoration. Replacing it means rebuilding part of the earring, so it starts with a look rather than a set price.
  • Stones near the joint. Pearls and delicate stones have to be identified before any heat goes near them, which is why you're asked to name them in your order.

Getting the new wire right

  • Thickness. On Ganoksin's Orchid forum for jewelers, one maker gives 21 gauge as the industry standard for factory-made French hooks and 22 gauge for kidney wires; others on the same thread call 20 gauge standard, and some use wire of about 0.8 mm. Thicker wire may not pass comfortably through a piercing, and thinner wire bends open too easily. Sending both earrings lets the new wire match its partner.
  • Hardness. Soldering heat anneals, or softens, wire; Wikipedia's work hardening article notes that annealing reverses the hardening that working gives metal. Jewelers on the same forum describe hammering the top curve or twisting the wire to harden it again, so the new hook holds its shape.
  • Metal, for sensitive ears. The ear wire is the part that sits in your piercing. The American Academy of Dermatology names earrings and earring backs among the biggest sources of nickel exposure and suggests surgical-grade stainless steel, 18K, 22K or 24K yellow gold, sterling silver or platinum instead. Note that the AAD list doesn't include white gold or gold below 18K; if you react to nickel, tell us in your order note. The repair page prices the wire in the metal you choose.
  • Shape and length. The curve and the tail behind the lobe decide how securely an open hook stays in. If yours slipped out, read how to keep fish hook earrings from falling out, and consider leverbacks instead of another open hook.

Can I replace an earring hook myself?

Yes, if the old hook hangs from an open loop and the earring isn't precious. You need two pairs of smooth flat-nose or chain-nose pliers and replacement ear wires in a metal your ears tolerate.

  • Open the loop sideways. Grip either side of the gap and twist one side toward you and the other away. Pulling the ends apart distorts the circle and weakens the wire.
  • Slip the drop on facing forward, then twist the loop closed the same way until the ends meet flush.
  • Leave alone: anything soldered, anything with pearls, opals or enamel near the joint, and any loop that's already been opened and closed many times.

Don't glue a broken hook back on: the joint flexes every time the earring goes in or out, and glue gives no warning before it lets go. Don't solder at home near stones or plating either; see whether you can solder jewelry at home.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

Ear wires are booked under Earring Post Repair with the current style set to Wire; the configurator adds metal and karat and shows the exact total before checkout. Each price includes a clean and polish and the 1-year workmanship guarantee.

  • New ear wires (Earring Post Repair, current style Wire), per pair: sterling silver $50 ($30 + $20); 14K yellow gold $60 ($30 + $6 + $4 + $20); 14K white or rose gold $65 ($30 + $11 + $4 + $20); platinum $124 ($30 + $74 + $20). One earring is $10 less.
  • A drop that came off its hook: Jump Ring Repair, $19 in sterling silver or $31 in 14K yellow gold ($19 + $7 + $5).
  • Switching to leverbacks: Earring Back Conversion, $80 in sterling silver ($40 + $40) or $146 in 14K yellow gold ($40 + $55 + $11 + $40).
  • Gold-plated or fashion pairs: the page lists gold-plated at +$16, but plated pieces that need solder work go to a free quote first, and you see the price before anything ships.
  • A hook formed as part of the design, or a kidney-wire catch that won't hold: the Mail-In Evaluation, $19, credited in full.

Compare other earring jobs in how much earring repair costs.

Before you ship

  • Send both earrings, even if only one hook broke, so the new wire is bent to match its partner. Bag the pair with any broken pieces of wire.
  • Name any pearls, opals, enamel or plating in your order note, so the jeweler plans the joint around them, and say if your ears react to nickel.

Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, with the prepaid label in your account; coverage options are on shipping and insurance. Your earrings are photographed when they reach the New York studio and again before they ship back, and a second jeweler checks the bench jeweler's work. Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, runs JewelryRepair.com. Its bench has handled over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

Questions

Can you glue a broken earring hook back on?
No, glue won't hold it. The hook flexes every time the earring goes in or out and carries the earring's full weight, and a glue joint gives no warning before it lets go. Residue also has to come off before a proper repair. A hook on an open loop can be swapped with pliers; a soldered one is replaced at the bench, $50 a pair in sterling silver at JewelryRepair.com.
Can a bent earring hook be straightened?
Once, gently, by hand, if it's a soft bend in a wire that hasn't been bent before. Bending work-hardens the metal, making it stronger but less ductile, so a hook bent back and forth eventually cracks at the bend. A sharp kink, a crack or a hook that won't hold its shape should be replaced: $50 a pair in sterling silver or $60 in 14K yellow gold at JewelryRepair.com.
Should I replace both earring hooks or just the broken one?
Usually both, so the pair matches in shape, length and color. A new wire is bright beside a hook with years of wear, and a hand-formed curve rarely matches another exactly. At JewelryRepair.com the difference in sterling silver is $10: $40 for one earring, $50 for the pair. Send both either way, so the new wire can be matched to its partner.
Can fish hook earrings be changed to leverbacks?
Yes, and it's the better fix if your hooks keep slipping out. A leverback closes behind the lobe with a hinged lever, so the wire can't ride up and out of the piercing. At JewelryRepair.com that's Earring Back Conversion: $80 in sterling silver ($40 + $40) or $146 in 14K yellow gold ($40 + $55 + $11 + $40), shown in the configurator before checkout.