Jewelry repair questions · Rings & sizing
Which wedding band and ring metals resist scratches best, and what is the trade-off?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Most scratch-resistant: tungsten carbide, about 9 to 9.5 on the Mohs scale, so only materials at least that hard, such as diamond, can cut it.
- Middle: titanium (about 6) and stainless steel. They pick up fine scuffs on a polished finish.
- Softest: platinum (3.5) and gold and silver (2.5 for the pure metals). They scratch first, though on platinum much of the scratched metal is displaced rather than lost.
- The trade-off is repair. GIA warns tungsten can crack or shatter under high impact, and it can't be resized. Gold, silver and platinum can be polished, resized and re-shanked many times.
- Nothing is scratch-proof. GIA notes a diamond can scratch any of the precious metals used for settings, so a band worn next to a diamond ring will mark.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Jewelry Polishing | from $30 | Mirror, satin or brushed finish restored. For a ring: sterling silver $30, stainless steel $50, 14K yellow gold $55, 14K white or rose gold $60, 18K yellow gold $63, platinum $125. Tungsten, titanium and ceramic aren't listed metals. |
| Rhodium Plating | from $69 | Polish, clean and fresh rhodium to bring white gold back to bright white: $79 for a 14K white gold ring ($69 + $8 + $2). |
| Ring Resizing | from $45 | Gold, sterling silver, platinum, stainless steel and gold-plated rings, with sizing stock matched to the ring's karat and color. Sizing a 14K yellow gold band down: $65 ($45 + $13 + $7). No tungsten, titanium or ceramic option. |
| Shank Repair | from $45 | Cracks and ER cuts soldered and refinished; a band worn thin can be re-shanked with new metal (in gold, half band +$250, full band +$375). |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | For a damaged tungsten, titanium or ceramic band, or anything you're unsure about: photos and an itemized quote, credited in full toward approved work. |
The hardness ladder, and what it doesn't tell you
Scratch resistance is mostly about hardness, which for gems and metals is ranked on the Mohs scale: a material scratches anything below it and is scratched by anything above it. These figures come from Wikipedia's Mohs scale and element pages and are for pure materials; ring alloys vary.
- Diamond: 10, the top of the scale.
- Tungsten carbide: about 9 to 9.5.
- Sapphire and ruby: 9.
- Titanium: 6. Rhodium, the plating on most white gold, is also 6.
- Ordinary steel: 4 to 4.5.
- Platinum: 3.5.
- Gold and silver: 2.5.
Two cautions. The scale is ordinal, not evenly spaced: Wikipedia notes diamond is about four times as hard as corundum in absolute terms, though they're one step apart. And hardness isn't toughness. Tungsten carbide approaches diamond in hardness, yet GIA warns it can crack or shatter under high impact. Gold is soft: it bends, dents and scratches, but it can be worked back into shape.
Metal by metal: how each one wears
- Tungsten carbide. GIA says it's highly resistant to scratches, keeps its look with daily wear and needs little polishing. The rings are pressed from powder and sintered into one hard piece, so they can't be resized, and a crack can't be soldered; see can a cracked tungsten ring be repaired?
- Ceramic. Ceramic isn't a listed material for resizing or polishing at JewelryRepair.com, so a damaged ceramic band starts with the Mail-In Evaluation.
- Titanium. About 6 on the Mohs scale. GIA calls it durable and resistant to corrosion, wear and tarnish, and light to wear, but a polished titanium band still shows fine scuffs, and GIA puts its resizing limit at about half a size.
- Stainless steel. Harder than gold and inexpensive, it shows light scuffs on a polished finish. Unlike tungsten and titanium, it's a listed metal for both resizing and polishing at JewelryRepair.com.
- Platinum. It scratches, but JCK explains that when platinum is scratched the metal is displaced rather than lost, settling into a satiny patina, while white gold loses a little metal with every scratch. GIA says platinum won't lose shape or abrade over decades of wear.
- White gold. The bright white is usually rhodium plating, harder than the gold but thin; our rhodium plating guide puts its life at about 1 to 3 years on a ring.
- Yellow and rose gold. GIA notes that higher-karat gold is softer, with 24K the most prone to scratches and dents and too soft for everyday wear. 14K and 18K scratch readily but polish back beautifully.
- Sterling silver. GIA calls it softer than gold and platinum and more prone to scratches and dents, and it tarnishes. It's also the least expensive metal to refinish.
The trade-off: scratch resistance vs a ring you can repair
Over decades fingers change size, bands wear thin and accidents happen, and that's where hardness costs you:
- Resizing. GIA's ring-metal guide says 14K and 18K gold and sterling silver can be resized up to two sizes, platinum can be resized but at a higher cost, titanium is limited to about half a size, and tungsten can't be resized at all. JewelryRepair.com's Ring Resizing page lists gold, silver, platinum, stainless steel and gold-plated rings, with no tungsten, titanium or ceramic option.
- Refinishing. Gold, silver, platinum and stainless steel go back on the polishing wheel and come off like new. Following the Mohs rule, only abrasives at least as hard as tungsten carbide, such as diamond, can cut it, so it isn't polished like precious metal.
- Rebuilding. A gold or platinum band worn thin can be re-shanked with new metal, and a crack can be soldered closed. Tungsten carbide's bonds, formed when the powder is sintered, don't join with added material.
- Emergencies. Wikipedia notes that special tools such as locking pliers may be needed if a tungsten ring must come off quickly. A gold or platinum ring cut off in an emergency room can be soldered back together; Shank Repair fixes ER cuts from $45.
How to choose, and how to keep any ring looking good
- If you never want to think about scratches and your size is stable, tungsten carbide will stay shiny longest. Accept that a hard knock can crack it and a size change means a new ring.
- If you want one ring for life, choose gold or platinum. They will scratch, but they can be refinished, resized and rebuilt for decades, and JCK notes platinum never needs re-plating.
- Choose the finish too. A brushed or satin surface hides fine scratches better than a mirror polish, on any metal, and Jewelry Polishing can restore either.
- Stacking with a diamond? Because a diamond scratches every setting metal, a band worn beside an engagement ring will mark. Soldering the pair together stops them rubbing.
- Take it off for the gym, gardening and moving furniture. Grit and metal handles do more scratching than a normal day.
What it costs at JewelryRepair.com
Prices from the live repair pages, Nov 18, 2026, for a ring:
- Jewelry Polishing: $30 in sterling silver, $50 in stainless steel ($30 + $20), $55 in 14K yellow gold ($30 + $17 + $8), $60 in 14K white or rose gold, $63 in 18K yellow gold ($30 + $17 + $16) and $125 in platinum ($30 + $95).
- Rhodium Plating for white gold: $79 for a 14K ring ($69 + $8 + $2), polish included.
- Ring Resizing: sizing a 14K yellow gold band down is $65 ($45 + $13 + $7).
- A damaged tungsten, titanium or ceramic band starts with the Mail-In Evaluation: $19, credited in full, with photos and an honest, itemized answer.
Every repair carries the 1-year workmanship guarantee, and shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS. The bench work happens at Sky Jewelry in New York, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.
Questions
What is the most scratch-resistant wedding band?
Is tungsten really scratch-proof?
Does platinum scratch more than gold?
Do titanium rings scratch?
Is 14K or 18K gold more scratch-resistant?
Which ring metal is best if I might need resizing later?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list