Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing

Why is my gold turning silver, or my silver turning pink or copper?

Gold that turns silver is almost always gold plating worn through to a silver or steel base; rarely, it's mercury bonding with solid gold. Silver that turns pink or copper is usually firestain exposed by polishing, or plating worn through to copper or brass. Yellow or orange silver is early tarnish. Re-plating at JewelryRepair.com starts at $60.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

0.175 micronsFTC minimum for gold electroplate; vermeil needs 2.5 microns of gold over sterling
$15Metal Testing & Verification: plated or solid, before you pay for a fix
$60Gold Plating for a ring or pendant on a silver base
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers

The short version: read the color

  • Gold-colored piece showing silver or gray where it rubs: gold plating worn through to a silver, steel or other white base.
  • Solid gold turning silver-gray all over, quickly: mercury. Rare, but it happens.
  • Sterling turning yellow, golden or orange: early tarnish.
  • Sterling turning pink or purplish in cloudy patches, often after polishing: firestain.
  • Silver-colored piece turning copper or brassy: silver plating worn through to a copper or brass base.
  • Gold looking pinker or reddish: tarnish on a copper-rich alloy, or plating worn through to copper.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Metal Testing & Verification $15Hallmarks examined under magnification and the metal and karat tested and documented, so you know whether you're looking at worn plating.
Gold Plating from $60Polished, cleaned and re-plated in yellow, rose or white gold at the thickness you choose. Brass, copper, steel and gold bases, rose or white finishes and thicker plating add to the price.
Rhodium Plating from $69Covers firestain on sterling silver with a bright white layer: $69 for a sterling ring. Like any plating, it wears with time.
Jewelry Polishing from $30Removes tarnish and shallow surface discoloration from a ring or earrings; deeper firestain is better covered than polished away.
Mail-In Evaluation $19For a color change you can't place: examined under magnification, with photos and an itemized quote, credited in full toward the work you approve.

Gold turning silver: worn plating, almost every time

Solid gold is the same color all the way through, so wearing it down only reveals more gold. A piece that goes silver where it rubs most, inside a band or along edges, had gold only on the surface. Under the FTC's Jewelry Guides, the minimum for anything marked gold electroplate is 0.175 microns, about 7 millionths of an inch, and pieces sold as gold-plated, flashed or washed can carry even less, since the FTC sets no minimum for those terms. Heavy gold electroplate needs 2.5 microns, and so does vermeil, which must be gold of at least 10 karat over sterling silver.

Stamps help. A gold-colored piece stamped 925 or sterling is gold over silver, so silver is exactly what will show through. A karat stamp such as 14K or 585 suggests solid gold, though stamps can be wrong. See what 585, 750 and 925 stamps mean.

Rose gold that turns silver is the same story. White gold goes the other way, faintly yellow when its rhodium wears, covered in does white gold tarnish.

The rare case: mercury on solid gold

If solid gold turns silvery-gray within hours or a day, mercury is the likely cause. Mercury dissolves into gold readily and forms an amalgam, a gold-mercury alloy, on the surface. It's still around in older glass thermometers, per the EPA, and in some imported skin-lightening and anti-aging creams the FDA has warned about.

Heat drives mercury out of gold, but it releases mercury vapor, and the EPA notes that metallic mercury mainly harms people when it's breathed in as a vapor. Don't heat, file or polish it. Stop wearing it, keep it in a sealed bag, and contact the studio before shipping, through the contact page or at (212) 597-2899. Mercury removal isn't a menu service; if the bench agrees to look, it goes through the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full.

Silver turning yellow, gold or orange: early tarnish

Tarnish doesn't start black. The Canadian Conservation Institute explains that silver tarnish is silver sulfide, and while the layer is very thin, light interference makes it look yellow, then red-brown, then blue, before it thickens to black. Sterling tarnishes faster than pure silver because of its copper, the institute notes.

If a silver polishing cloth lifts the color on a hidden spot, it was tarnish. See how to clean tarnished sterling silver and does sterling silver tarnish.

Silver turning pink or copper: firestain or worn plating

Firestain. When sterling silver is heated during casting or soldering, oxygen reacts with the copper in the alloy and forms copper oxide inside the surface layer. The Goldsmiths' Centre describes the result as a permanent red or purple stain within the metal, most common in sterling silver, though lower-karat golds get it too. Makers often hide it under plating or a fine-silver surface, per Wikipedia's article on firescale; when that layer wears or is polished away, pink or purplish clouds appear. Removing firestain for good means abrading below the stained layer, which costs metal; a fine layer of plating covers it, but wears off in time.

Worn silver plating. Silver-plated jewelry is a thin coat of silver over a base metal, and under the National Stamping Act, cited in the FTC's guides, silver-plated articles can't be stamped sterling. When it wears through, a copper or brass base shows as pink, coppery or yellow-brass patches, first on high points and edges.

Gold turning pink or reddish. Chris Corti, writing for the World Gold Council, notes that copper oxides on tarnished gold range from red to black, and that tarnish mostly affects low-karat golds. A 10K piece with a pinkish cast is often that. Gold plating worn through to a copper base shows the same pink.

How to tell which one you have

  • Where is the color? Only on high-wear spots points to worn plating. Evenly all over points to tarnish or, on solid gold, mercury.
  • Does a silver cloth lift it? Tarnish comes off; firestain and exposed base metal don't.
  • What's stamped on it? No mark at all on a silver-colored piece suggests plating.
  • Still not sure? Metal Testing & Verification tests the metal and karat directly, $15 per item; testing is included at no charge when you choose "Not sure" for the metal on a repair.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

Prices from the live repair pages, Nov 18, 2026, each with the 1-year workmanship guarantee; shipping is $30 round trip per order.

  • Gold-plated silver or vermeil worn through: Gold Plating is $60 for a ring or pendant with a yellow flash, $110 for a necklace ($60 + $50). Thicker gold lasts longer: 3 to 4 microns, which clears the 2.5-micron vermeil standard, adds $400 ($460 for a ring).
  • Rose gold plating gone silver: $112 for a ring on silver ($60 + $52 for the rose finish), or $263 on stainless steel ($60 + $151 + $52).
  • Firestain on sterling: Jewelry Polishing from $30 for a ring if it's shallow. If polishing would remove too much metal, Rhodium Plating covers it: $69 for a ring, $109 for a necklace ($69 + $40). The rhodium plating cost guide covers how long it lasts.
  • Reddish tarnish on gold: Jewelry Polishing for a yellow gold ring is $47 in 10K ($30 + $17) or $55 in 14K ($30 + $17 + $8).
  • Plating worn through to copper or brass: Gold Plating on a copper base is $240 for a ring ($60 + $180); on brass, $173 ($60 + $113). Silver re-plating isn't a listed service. A white gold finish over brass is $238 for a ring ($60 + $113 + $65), which can cost more than an inexpensive piece did.

Plating and testing happen at the New York studio of Sky Jewelry, the Lenox Avenue family jewelers behind over 50,000 repairs since 1989. Pieces are photographed on arrival and before return, and a second jeweler checks the work.

Questions

Can real gold turn silver?
Not from wear. Solid gold is the same color all the way through. A gold piece turning silver is almost always plating worn through to a silver or steel base. The rare exception is mercury, which bonds with solid gold and turns the surface silvery-gray; stop wearing the piece and contact a jeweler rather than heating or polishing it yourself.
Why is my sterling silver turning gold or yellow?
Usually it's early tarnish. The Canadian Conservation Institute explains that a very thin layer of silver sulfide looks yellow, then red-brown and blue, before it thickens to black, and sterling tarnishes faster than pure silver because of its copper. A silver polishing cloth usually lifts it. If it doesn't, Jewelry Polishing for a sterling silver ring is $30 at JewelryRepair.com.
Why did my silver ring turn pink after polishing?
That's most likely firestain, copper oxide that formed inside the surface when the silver was heated during manufacture or repair. Polishing removed the top layer and exposed it. Removing it means polishing below the stain, which costs metal; plating hides it for a while. Rhodium Plating for a sterling silver ring is $69 at JewelryRepair.com.
Can gold plating be fixed once it's worn off?
Yes, by re-plating: the piece is polished, cleaned and given a new layer of gold. At JewelryRepair.com, Gold Plating starts at $60 for a ring or pendant on a silver base, and a necklace is $110. Thicker plating lasts longer; 3 to 4 microns makes a sterling ring $460. Brass, copper and steel bases cost more.
Why is my gold jewelry turning copper or pink?
Either the alloy is tarnishing or plating has worn through. Copper oxides on tarnished gold range from red to black, and tarnish mostly affects low-karat golds such as 10K. Pink only where the piece rubs points to plating over copper or brass. Metal Testing & Verification, $15 per item, settles which; polishing a yellow gold ring is $47 in 10K or $55 in 14K.
Is it safe to wear gold that turned silver from mercury?
It's best not to. The mercury sits in the surface of the gold, and the EPA notes metallic mercury is mainly harmful when breathed in as a vapor, which heating releases. Don't heat, file or polish it yourself. Keep it in a sealed bag and contact the studio before shipping, at (212) 597-2899 or through the contact page.