Mail-in jewelry repair · Blue Nile
Blue Nile jewelry repair and resizing, by mail
JewelryRepair.com repairs Blue Nile rings and diamond studs by mail: resizing a 14K white gold ring from $76, re-tipping up to four prongs in 14K white gold for $57. Sky Jewelry's New York studio does the work: family jewelers on Lenox Avenue, over 50,000 repairs since 1989, with UPS shipping at $30 round trip.
4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of ) · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Ring Resizing | from $45 | Sized up or down with sizing stock matched to the ring's karat and color, soldered, polished and stone-checked. 14K white gold from $76, platinum from $565. |
| Prong Re-Tipping | from $29 | New metal matched to the setting laser-welded onto each worn prong tip, then shaped back over the stone. For 1 to 4 prongs: $57 in 14K white gold, $224 in platinum. |
| Stone Tightening | from $50 | Every stone tested for movement under 10x magnification and the loose ones secured by the method their setting needs, such as prongs re-seated over the stone or a bezel burnished tight. |
| Diamond Setting | from $5 | Setting labor for a lost accent diamond matched to its neighbors in color and cut: one side diamond in silver from $20, and $57 for one prong-set side diamond in 14K white gold ($5 base, $15 per side diamond, $33 white gold, $4 for 14K). If we source the diamond, its cost is quoted separately and you approve it before anything is set; a stone you supply pays labor only. |
| Earring Post Repair | from $30 | A bent or snapped stud post removed flush and a new post soldered or laser-welded on, never glued. Per pair: $45 in 14K white gold, $104 in platinum. |
| Earring Back Conversion | from $40 | Changes the back mechanism, for example from friction backs to screwbacks, while leaving the earring itself untouched. |
| Rhodium Plating | from $69 | White gold polished, cleaned and given a fresh rhodium layer so it's bright white again. $79 for a 14K white gold ring. |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | Our recommended first step for an eternity band, a tension ring, a tungsten carbide or tantalum ring, or anything you can't pin down: the whole piece examined under magnification and an itemized quote with photos. The $19 is credited in full toward the repair. |
Common repairs for Blue Nile pieces
Blue Nile sells engagement rings, wedding and eternity bands and diamond studs in 14K and 18K gold and platinum, plus silver, pearl and alternative-metal pieces (its warranty names stainless steel, tungsten carbide and tantalum). The repairs below are the ones these pieces need after years of daily wear.
Worn prongs. Prong tips wear flat with everyday contact, and a ring that starts catching on sweaters is the usual early sign. Prong Re-Tipping builds new metal onto each worn tip: from $29 for 1 to 4 prongs, $57 in 14K white gold and $224 in platinum ($29 plus $195 for platinum). A prong that has snapped off needs a Prong Rebuild, priced the same way.
Resizing after the free window. Blue Nile includes one free resize, up or down two sizes where the design allows, within 6 months of a ring purchase. After that, or for a bigger change, Ring Resizing is $76 to size a 14K white gold ring down ($45 base, $24 white gold, $7 for 14K) and $81 to size it up one size. Platinum is from $565, bands 4mm and wider add $46, and each full size up beyond the first adds $35.
White gold turning yellow. White gold gets its bright white from rhodium plating, which wears through with time. Rhodium Plating is $79 for a 14K white gold ring and $83 in 18K. Platinum is naturally white, so a scuffed platinum band usually needs Jewelry Polishing instead, $125 for a ring.
Diamond studs. A bent or snapped post is Earring Post Repair: $30 a pair in silver, $45 in 14K white gold, $104 in platinum, and $10 less for a single earring. If the backs keep loosening, Earring Back Conversion changes them to a more secure style; screwbacks in 14K white gold come to $142 ($40 base, $61 white gold, $11 for 14K, $30 screwback). Send both earrings so posts and backs match.
What Blue Nile covers first, and what voids it
Blue Nile's warranty covers manufacturing defects in gold and platinum jewelry priced at $1,000 or more, for as long as you own it, and its services page describes complimentary cleaning and inspection, recommended every six months. The warranty excludes pieces under $1,000, pearl, silver and alternative metals, lost or chipped diamonds and gemstones, and normal wear.
One rule to know before you send it anywhere. Blue Nile's warranty says repair, modification or alteration by anyone other than Blue Nile voids it (more on whether resizing voids a warranty). If your piece qualifies, or you're inside the 6-month free-resize window, contact Blue Nile first. An independent bench makes sense when the problem falls outside that coverage, such as a lost accent diamond or prongs worn by normal wear, and you accept that the Blue Nile warranty ends for that piece.
Rings outside Blue Nile's free resize. Its free resize excludes eternity bands, tension rings and alternative-metal rings. For an eternity band, a tension ring or a tungsten carbide or tantalum ring, we recommend starting with a Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full toward the repair), because what's possible depends on the ring: a full eternity band has stones all the way around, a tension ring holds its stone by the pressure of the band, and tungsten carbide generally can't be resized at all (why tungsten can't be sized). A stainless steel ring is on the Ring Resizing menu: $103 to size down ($45 base plus $58 for stainless). After an evaluation, you see the options and the price, with photos, before any work. If you decline, the ring comes back with the findings, and the $30 round trip already covers the return.
Bought it from James Allen? Blue Nile is owned by Signet Jewelers, which said in March 2026 that its James Allen brand would close and continue as a collection sold at Blue Nile. Our James Allen repair page covers how those rings are serviced now.
Before you ship your Blue Nile piece
- Check your coverage first. If the piece is under Blue Nile's warranty, a Blue Nile service plan or the 6-month resize window, contact Blue Nile before sending it to anyone else.
- Insure the full value. $100 of coverage is included each way. Full-value coverage is 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions: a $5,000 engagement ring costs 2.5% of $4,900, or $122.50. The limit is $10,000 per package; above that, contact us before shipping. Details: shipping and insurance.
- Not sure of the size? Add a note when you order; the size is confirmed at intake before any work.
- Plain box, no branding. Leave the Blue Nile ring box at home and pack the piece padded in a plain, sturdy box. Nothing on the outside or on the label names the contents. Drop it at any UPS location with the prepaid label from your account.
- Signed for both ways, photographed on arrival. Coverage runs from UPS's first scan until the package is signed for, at our studio and at your door. Your piece is photographed the day it arrives and again before it ships back, and the photos are in your account. The work carries our 1-year workmanship guarantee.
More on packing: how to ship a ring safely and whether it's safe to mail jewelry. The full process is on how it works.
Before you ship
- Choose the repair Pick the service, metal, karat and options on the repair page. The full price and your promised-by date show before checkout; for an eternity or tension ring, we recommend booking the $19 evaluation first.
- Ship it insured Your prepaid UPS label is ready in your account within minutes. Add full-value coverage before checkout, pack the ring in a plain box and drop it at any UPS location. US addresses only.
- Photographed, repaired, checked Your piece is photographed the day it arrives at our New York studio. A bench jeweler does the work and a second jeweler checks it.
- Back by UPS, signed for It's photographed again before it ships, comes back with a signature at your door, and carries a 1-year workmanship guarantee. Most repairs are back in about three weeks door to door.
Questions
Will resizing my Blue Nile ring somewhere else void the warranty?
Does Blue Nile's warranty cover worn prongs?
How much does it cost to replace a missing diamond in a Blue Nile ring?
Can you fix a bent post on Blue Nile diamond studs?
Can you resize a Blue Nile eternity band?
Does Blue Nile resize rings for free?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
All jewelry brands we repair · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list