Mail-in jewelry repair · James Allen

James Allen jewelry repair and ring resizing, by mail

JewelryRepair.com repairs James Allen rings by mail; in 14K white gold, resizing starts at $76, prong re-tipping is $57 and soldering a wedding set $77. James Allen now continues as a collection sold through Blue Nile. The work here is done at Sky Jewelry's New York studio, by family jewelers on Lenox Avenue with over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

$7714K white gold ring and band soldered together
$57prong re-tipping, 1 to 4 prongs, 14K white gold
$30UPS round trip per order, prepaid both ways
50,000+repairs since 1989

4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of ) · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Ring Resizing from $45Sizing stock matched to the ring's karat and color, soldered, polished and stone-checked. 14K white gold from $76 to size down; platinum from $565.
Prong Re-Tipping from $29New metal laser-welded onto worn prong tips and shaped back over the stone. For 1 to 4 prongs: $57 in 14K white gold, $224 in platinum.
Stone Tightening from $50Pavé, halo and side stones tested one at a time under 10x magnification and secured by the method each setting needs. $60 in white gold.
Diamond Setting from $5Setting labor for a missing accent diamond matched to its neighbors: one side diamond in silver from $20, $57 for one prong-set side diamond in 14K white gold. The diamond itself is quoted separately unless you supply it; lab-grown options are offered where they fit, and you approve the stone first.
Rhodium Plating from $69White gold polished, cleaned and re-plated with rhodium so it's bright white again. $79 for a 14K white gold ring, $83 in 18K.
Solder Rings Together from $62Engagement ring and band aligned as you wear them, soldered between the bands and refinished as one piece. $77 in 14K white gold, $136 in platinum.
Jewelry Appraisal from $105A written insurance-replacement-value appraisal with photographs, from an examination in hand. Send a copy of any grading report with the ring.
Mail-In Evaluation $19Our recommended first step for an eternity band, a damaged halo or anything you can't pin down: an itemized quote with photos first. The $19 is credited in full toward the repair.

Common repairs for James Allen pieces

The James Allen collection now listed at Blue Nile includes engagement rings, wedding and eternity bands and diamond earrings in 14K gold and platinum, some pieces set with lab-grown diamonds. They need the same care any daily-worn bridal ring needs, priced here by metal.

Prongs and loose stones. Worn prong tips are a common reason a center stone loosens. Prong Re-Tipping is $57 in 14K white gold and $224 in platinum for 1 to 4 prongs; a six-prong head falls in the 5 to 9 band, $102 in 14K white gold. Pavé and halo stones that rattle are Stone Tightening, from $60 in white gold.

Resizing. Ring Resizing is $76 to size a 14K white gold ring down and $81 to size it up one size; 18K white gold is $92 down and platinum $565. Most rings can go up or down about 2 to 3 sizes. For a band with stones most of the way around, or a full eternity band, we recommend starting with a Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full), because the stones change what's possible (more on resizing a ring with diamonds on the band).

White gold and missing accents. If a white gold band is turning yellow, the rhodium is wearing through: Rhodium Plating is $79 for a 14K white gold ring. A missing accent diamond is replaced with Diamond Setting: setting labor for one prong-set side diamond in 14K white gold is $57 ($5 base, $15 per side diamond, $33 white gold, $4 for 14K). If we source the matching natural or lab-grown diamond, its price is quoted separately and you approve it before it's set; a diamond you supply pays the labor only. More on repairing lab-grown diamond rings.

James Allen is now part of Blue Nile

Signet Jewelers, which agreed in 2017 to buy James Allen's parent company, said in March 2026 that the James Allen brand would shut down by the second quarter and continue as a proprietary collection sold at Blue Nile.

Where warranty service goes now. Blue Nile's James Allen FAQ says policies on previously purchased James Allen jewelry continue to be honored under the Blue Nile brand, and that service requests go through Blue Nile's standard repair channels, including Blue Nile stores. If your ring is still under a James Allen warranty or service plan, check with Blue Nile first, because outside service can void that coverage. Blue Nile's current warranty, for comparison, says repairs by anyone other than Blue Nile void it. See our Blue Nile repair page for what that coverage includes.

Keep your records. With James Allen now sold through Blue Nile, keep your receipt, order number and any diamond grading report somewhere safe. If your insurer scheduled the ring from the original receipt, a Jewelry Appraisal ($105) gives a written replacement value with photographs; send a copy of the grading report with the ring.

Wedding sets: soldered together, or apart

An engagement ring and band worn side by side rub against each other every day, wearing metal, engraving and eventually prongs. Solder Rings Together aligns them the way you wear them and solders the join between the bands, where the seam doesn't show on the finger, then refinishes the set as one piece: $62 in silver, $77 in 14K white gold, $80 in 18K white gold and $136 in platinum, with a third ring adding $20. Once soldered, the set is sized as one ring. If you're deciding, read whether to solder your wedding rings together.

If you later want to wear them separately, Ring Unsoldering cuts the set apart along the old seam, removes the solder and rounds each band: from $55, $70 in 14K white gold (more on separating soldered rings).

For a ring worn every day, the Anniversary Service ($199 a year) is a deep clean, a magnified inspection of every prong and stone, tightening of loose stones and a refinish, timed to your date.

Before you ship your James Allen ring

  • Ask Blue Nile about coverage first. If the ring is still under a James Allen warranty or service plan, contact Blue Nile before sending it anywhere else.
  • Insure the full value. $100 of coverage is included each way. Full-value coverage is 2.5% of the value above $100, one fee for both directions: a $3,000 ring costs 2.5% of $2,900, or $72.50. The limit is $10,000 per package; above that, contact us before shipping. Details: shipping and insurance.
  • Plain box, signed both ways. Pack the ring padded in a plain, sturdy box; nothing on the outside or on the label names the contents. Drop it at any UPS location with the prepaid label from your account. UPS needs a signature at our studio and at your door.
  • Photographed on arrival. The ring is photographed the day it arrives and again before it ships back, so you can compare the stones in your account. The work carries our 1-year workmanship guarantee.

The full process is on how it works.

Before you ship

  1. Choose the repair Pick the service, metal and karat on the repair page. The full price and your promised-by date show before checkout; for an eternity band, we recommend booking the $19 evaluation first.
  2. Ship it insured Your prepaid UPS label is ready in your account within minutes. Add full-value coverage before checkout, pack the ring in a plain box and drop it at any UPS location. US addresses only.
  3. Photographed, repaired, checked Your ring is photographed the day it arrives at our New York studio. A bench jeweler does the work and a second jeweler checks it.
  4. Back by UPS, signed for It's photographed again before it ships, comes back with a signature at your door, and carries a 1-year workmanship guarantee.
Independent service. JewelryRepair.com is an independent repair service, not affiliated with, authorized by or endorsed by James Allen. If your piece is covered by the brand's own warranty or service program, check with the brand first.

Questions

Is my James Allen warranty still honored?
Yes, according to Blue Nile: its James Allen FAQ says policies on previously purchased James Allen jewelry continue to be honored under the Blue Nile brand, and service requests go through Blue Nile's standard repair channels, including its stores. If your ring is still covered, start there, because outside service can void that coverage. For repairs outside it, JewelryRepair.com is an independent option by mail, with 14K white gold prong re-tipping at $57.
Can I resize my James Allen engagement ring after James Allen closed?
Yes. An independent bench can resize it; if the ring is still under a James Allen warranty or service plan, ask Blue Nile first. Our Ring Resizing is $76 to size a 14K white gold ring down, $81 to size it up one size and $565 in platinum, with the full price shown before you ship. For an eternity band, we recommend starting with a $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full.
Can you solder my James Allen engagement ring and wedding band together?
Yes. Solder Rings Together is $77 for two rings in 14K white gold, $72 in 14K yellow gold and $136 in platinum. The rings are aligned exactly as you wear them, joined between the bands where the seam doesn't show, and refinished as one piece. If the set also needs sizing, it's sized as one ring afterward.
Can you replace a lab-grown diamond in a James Allen ring?
Yes for accent stones: setting labor for one prong-set side diamond in 14K white gold is $57 with our Diamond Setting ($5 base, $15 per side diamond, $33 white gold, $4 for 14K). The diamond itself is quoted separately unless you supply it; lab-grown options are offered where they fit, and you approve the stone and its price before it's set. A center stone is quoted with options first.
Can a soldered James Allen wedding set be taken apart?
Yes. Ring Unsoldering cuts the set apart along the old seam, removes the leftover solder from each band and rounds each one true: $70 for two rings in 14K white gold, from $55. Each band is checked for loose stones and refinished, so they can be worn separately. If you want them joined again later, Solder Rings Together is $77 in 14K white gold.