Jewelry repair questions · Earrings & pendants

Can a brooch be turned into a pendant or necklace?

Usually, yes. A jeweler adds a bail at the top of the back so the brooch hangs level on a chain, either keeping the pin and catch so it can still be worn as a brooch, or removing them. Antique and signed brooches are often best left convertible. At JewelryRepair.com it starts with a $10 Custom Work estimate.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$10Custom Work estimate: a jeweler quotes the conversion from your photos before anything ships
$19Antique & Heirloom Restoration evaluation, credited in full toward approved work
$39Bail Repair in sterling silver, for a pendant loop the brooch already has
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers

The short version

  • Convertible: the pin stem and catch stay, and a bail is added, so the piece works both ways. The safer choice for antiques, signed pieces and anything you might sell.
  • Permanent: the pin and catch come off and a fixed bail goes on. Flatter and lighter at the neck, but metal that's removed can't always go back.
  • No tools: a slide-on brooch converter holds the pin in a tube with a loop on top. It's reversible, but it doesn't suit every brooch.
  • Hang matters: the bail has to sit above the brooch's center of gravity, and wide brooches often need two attachment points.
  • Check first: stones, enamel, pearls and cameos near the work, old solder, and plated costume metal all change the plan.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Custom Work & Modifications $10Converting a brooch into a pendant, convertible or permanent. Add photos and the chain you'll wear; you get an itemized quote with any trade-offs before anything ships.
Antique & Heirloom Restoration $19For an old or fragile brooch: metal tested, every joint, pin and stone mapped under magnification, and each step quoted with photos before any work. Credited in full.
Bail Repair from $39A pendant loop or bail the brooch already has, bent or broken, soldered, rebuilt or replaced. 14K yellow gold $63 ($39 + $20 + $4).
Stone Tightening from $50Loose stones tightened under 10x magnification before the piece starts hanging and swinging, up to eight stones per order.
Enamel Repair from $54Chipped enamel filled with color-matched enamel and polished flush. $54 for one color in one spot, small area, silver ($34 + $10 for one color + $10 for one location); more for extra colors, locations or a larger area.

Three ways to do it

1. A slide-on converter. Fire Mountain Gems, a jewelry-supply house, describes brooch converter bails as a tube the pin slides through and is latched into, with a built-in loop for the chain; they come in horizontal and vertical versions, so match yours to the way the pin runs. Nothing is cut or soldered, and the brooch is a brooch again the moment you slide it off. The drawbacks: the pin and catch now carry the full weight on a chain, the converter has to fit your pin's thickness, and one poster on the Ganoksin trade forum found that store-bought converters didn't hang the way she wanted.

2. A convertible bail. A jeweler solders a bail to the back, above the balance point, and leaves the pin and catch working. A fold-down bail, suggested on the same forum for exactly this job, tucks away when you wear the piece as a pin. This is usually the best compromise for anything with age or a maker's name.

3. A permanent conversion. The pin stem and catch are removed, the spots where they sat are cleaned up and refinished, and a fixed bail or a pair of loops is soldered on. As the Custom Work listing at JewelryRepair.com says plainly, some conversions remove metal that can't go back. For a brooch that's going into a new frame or mount rather than just gaining a bail, 3D Design & Rendering shows you the design first, from $150, credited toward making it.

Making it hang right

Pinned to fabric, a brooch is held along the length of its pin stem. On a chain it hangs from one point, and the rule bench jewelers repeat applies: attach it as far above its center of gravity as possible, or it tips forward or flips. In practice:

  • Decide which way is up. Many brooches are designed to be worn sideways. Tell the jeweler how you want it to hang.
  • Wide or horizontal pieces such as bar pins and sprays often need two attachment points, or a Y-shaped hanger with double loops; Fire Mountain Gems sells flat-backed Y bails whose double loops suspend a piece evenly.
  • Heavy pieces need a chain that can carry them. Rio Grande's chain guide for bench jewelers says to choose a chain with the strength for the pendant's weight, a width that suits the bail, and an end ring that fits through the bail.
  • Send the chain you plan to wear, or its measurements, so the bail is sized for it. If it still flips, see why pendants flip.

Antique, signed and costume brooches: check first

  • Value. A jeweler on the Ganoksin trade forum raised the question of whether altering a designer brooch destroys its value as a designer piece, and a fold-down bail was suggested there as the way to keep it wearable both ways. If the brooch may be valuable, have it appraised before anything is cut; see how to tell if jewelry is antique or vintage.
  • Heat. Writing in GIA's journal Gems & Gemology, a gemologist who had worked ten years as a bench jeweler notes that heat-sensitive stones such as emerald and tanzanite can be damaged by soldering near them, and that whenever possible the stone should come out of the mounting before a repair. GIA also counts shell cameos and pearls among the organic gems that need gentle handling, and enamel is glass. The JewelryRepair.com Bail Repair listing says enameled, plated and stone-set pendants are worked with a laser to keep heat away from them; for a conversion, the method and any heat risk are set out in your Custom Work quote.
  • Age. Old metal can be brittle and old solder joints hide under patina, which is why antique pieces start with an evaluation rather than a menu price, and why patina is preserved rather than polished away.
  • Costume pieces. Plated or base-metal brooches with glued-in stones may not take solder at all; plated pieces needing solder work are quoted individually. For these, a slide-on converter is often the sensible choice. See whether costume jewelry can be repaired.
  • Fix the brooch first. A loose stone or a pin that won't stay closed only gets worse once the piece is hanging and swinging; see brooch repair.

Can I do it myself?

The converter is the do-it-yourself option, and a good one for an inexpensive brooch: buy one sized for your pin stem, make sure the catch closes fully, and test it over a soft surface before wearing it out. Glue-on bails exist too, but adhesive ages and lets go, and the glue can mark the back of an antique. Home soldering is the one to avoid. Even the forum jeweler who suggested low-temperature lead-type solder warned of some loss, and stones, enamel, pearls and old joints are exactly what a flame damages. See can I solder jewelry at home?

How it works at JewelryRepair.com, and what it costs

  • Most brooches: order the $10 Custom Work & Modifications estimate and add photos of the front, back and side, with a ruler for scale. Say whether you want it convertible or permanent, which way up it should hang, and which chain you'll wear. Nothing ships yet: a jeweler reviews it and sends an itemized quote, including any honest trade-offs, before you decide.
  • Antiques and heirlooms: Antique & Heirloom Restoration starts with the $19 evaluation, credited in full: the metal is tested, the piece is mapped under magnification, and each step is quoted with photos before any work.
  • A loop that's already there: some brooches were made with a pendant loop. If it's bent or broken, Bail Repair is $39 in sterling silver, $63 in 14K yellow gold ($39 + $20 + $4) and $69 in 18K yellow gold ($39 + $20 + $10).
  • Repairs before converting: Stone Tightening from $50, or $55 on yellow gold ($50 + $5); Enamel Repair from $54 ($34 + $10 for one color + $10 for one location), more for extra colors, locations or a larger area.

Shipping is $30 round trip by UPS per order, with the prepaid label in your account and $100 of coverage each way. To cover a valuable brooch for its full value, up to $10,000, add 2.5% of the value above $100, once for both directions: $60 for a $2,500 piece. The estimate is quoted from your photos; the brooch itself is photographed again on arrival and before it ships back. A bench jeweler does the work, a second jeweler checks it, and the work carries a 1-year guarantee. Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, runs JewelryRepair.com from its New York studio: over 50,000 repairs since 1989.

Questions

How do you turn a brooch into a necklace without damaging it?
Use a method that doesn't cut the brooch: a slide-on converter that holds the pin in a tube with a loop on top, or a bail soldered to the back that leaves the pin and catch working. Both let it go back to being a brooch. At JewelryRepair.com, a convertible conversion is quoted from your photos through a $10 Custom Work estimate before anything ships.
Does turning a brooch into a pendant lower its value?
It can, for antique, signed or collectible brooches. A jeweler on the Ganoksin trade forum raised that question about designer pieces. Keep those convertible, with the pin and catch intact, and have a valuable brooch appraised before any change. A written insurance appraisal by mail is $105 at JewelryRepair.com.
How much does it cost to turn a brooch into a pendant?
It depends on the brooch, so it's quoted rather than listed. At JewelryRepair.com, the Custom Work estimate is $10, and the quote reflects the metal, whether the pin stays, how many attachment points it needs and what's near the joins. If the brooch already has a pendant loop that just needs fixing, Bail Repair is $39 in silver. Shipping is $30 round trip per order.
Can a brooch be turned into a ring or earrings?
Sometimes, but it's a bigger project than adding a bail. A ring needs a shank built under the brooch, and the piece has to be small and sturdy enough to wear on a hand. Earrings usually need a matching pair. Both are custom work, quoted from your photos through the $10 estimate, and a jeweler will say if the brooch isn't a good candidate.