Jewelry repair questions · Earrings & pendants

How do you clean a cameo or an old brooch without damaging it?

Gently, and mostly dry. Dust it with a soft brush, then wipe the carving with a cotton swab barely dampened with lukewarm water and a trace of mild soap, and dry it at once. Never soak a cameo or use an ultrasonic cleaner, silver dip or vinegar: shell is calcium carbonate, which acids dissolve.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$19Antique & Heirloom Restoration evaluation for a brooch or pin, credited in full toward approved work
$44Jewelry Spa for an all-metal sterling silver brooch (not for the cameo itself)
$50Stone Tightening in silver, up to eight loose stones in the frame
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers

The short version

  • Dry first: a soft, clean brush (a makeup or watercolor brush) lifts dust from the carving without water.
  • Damp, not wet: a cotton swab barely moistened with lukewarm water, with a drop of mild soap only for grime. Dry it straight away.
  • Never: soaking, ultrasonic or steam cleaners, silver dip, vinegar, lemon, abrasive pastes or oil.
  • Clean the frame separately, with a polishing cloth on the metal only.
  • Look while it's clean: a crack, a cameo that moves in its frame, a loose stone or a weak pin catch means a jeweler, not another wash.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Antique & Heirloom Restoration $19For a cameo, a cracked or loose carving, or a fragile old brooch: the metal is tested, every joint, pin and stone is mapped under magnification, and each step is quoted with photos before any work, with patina preserved. The $19 is credited in full.
Stone Tightening from $50Loose stones in a brooch frame tightened under 10x magnification, up to eight stones per order. $50 in silver, $55 in yellow gold ($50 + $5).
Enamel Repair from $54Chipped enamel on a brooch frame filled with color-matched enamel and polished flush. $34 base plus at least one color and one location at $10 each: $54 in silver ($34 + $10 + $10).
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic, steam and hand-polish clean with a written inspection report. Right for an all-metal brooch with sturdy stones such as diamonds; not for a cameo, coral, pearls or glued stones.

First, work out what your cameo is carved from

The material decides how much cleaning it can take.

  • Shell. Wikipedia notes that cheaper modern cameos are more often shell or glass, that Torre del Greco in Italy is the world center of shell cameo carving, and that cameos cut from conch shell fade over time. GIA, reporting on hand-carved cameos from Italy, notes that hand-carved pieces tend to keep the natural curvature of the shell, while machine-carved ones tend to be flat.
  • Hardstone. Agate and onyx, the usual material of ancient and Renaissance cameos, and sturdier than shell.
  • Lava. Matte cameos from off-white or yellowish to gray, some dyed darker, sold as souvenirs of the Vesuvius region since the 1700s. Antique Jewelry University notes that most are probably tuff, welded tuff or volcanic breccia, and some a soft southern Italian limestone, rather than true lava. Treat them gently.
  • Coral. An organic gem, on GIA's list of materials to keep out of ultrasonic cleaners alongside shell cameos and pearls.
  • Glass and plastic. Glass cameos go back to Roman times, and glass and plastic copies turn up in costume brooches, often glued into base-metal frames.

Not sure? Clean it as if it were shell, the safe default.

Step by step: cleaning the carving

  • 1. Work over a towel on a table, never over a sink, with the pin closed.
  • 2. Dust it. Sweep a soft dry brush along the carving, following the contours, to lift dust from the undercuts.
  • 3. Swab the grime. Dip a cotton swab in lukewarm water, squeeze it almost dry, and roll it over the surface. A cameo carver and restorer on the Ganoksin jewelers' forum recommends exactly this. For stubborn grime add a drop of mild dish soap, then follow with a swab of plain water.
  • 4. Keep water out of the mount. Work from the center outward and stop short of the frame. Water that wicks behind a cameo sits against the back of the carving and can weaken any adhesive holding it.
  • 5. Dry immediately with a soft lint-free cloth, then leave it face up to air-dry.
  • 6. For a little luster on shell, the same restorer suggests buffing lightly with the smoothest side of a four-sided nail buffer. Skip this on lava and hardstone.

What never to use, and why

  • Ultrasonic and steam cleaners. GIA says organic materials, shell cameos included, are porous and can be damaged by the heat of an ultrasonic cleaner and the chemicals in most cleaning solutions.
  • Silver dip, vinegar and lemon juice. Shell and limestone are calcium carbonate, which acids dissolve. Canada's Conservation Institute describes silver dips as an acid plus a complexing agent and says dips aren't appropriate for objects made of mixed materials. A cameo brooch is exactly that.
  • Soaking. Water gets behind the carving and into joints and hollow frames.
  • Oil. The Ganoksin restorer warns that mineral oil attracts dirt and gives only a temporary luster.
  • Abrasive pastes, including toothpaste and baking soda. They scour fine detail.
  • Hairspray, perfume and lotion. GIA warns that cosmetics can permanently damage the surface of delicate or porous gems. Put the brooch on last.
  • Sunny windowsills and hot cars. GIA lists shell cameos among the gems that light and heat can fade or damage. Store it in a closed box.

More in are ultrasonic cleaners safe for jewelry? and is silver dip safe?

The rest of the brooch: frame, stones and pin

  • The frame. Victorian cameos were often set in gold, with silver and the gold-look alloy pinchbeck for less costly pieces. Rub the metal with a polishing cloth, working away from the carving. Conservators warn that polishes damage gilding, so go very lightly on a frame that might be gilded or pinchbeck, and leave the darker recesses alone; see how to clean antique silver jewelry.
  • Marcasite brooches. The sparkling gray stones are faceted pyrite, often glued. Use a dry brush, no ultrasonic, which knocks them loose, and no long soaking, which can soften old glue. Missing marcasites are quoted after the $19 Antique & Heirloom Restoration evaluation; see marcasite repair and cleaning.
  • Rhinestone and paste brooches are often glued too; see how to clean costume jewelry.
  • The pin. While it's clean, open and close the catch. A catch that won't stay shut, a loose hinge or a bent pin stem is how brooches get lost; see brooch repair and keeping a brooch from drooping.

When to stop, and what a jeweler costs

Stop cleaning and get it looked at if you see a crack in the carving, a cameo that rocks in its frame, an empty stone seat, or a pin that won't hold. The Ganoksin restorer's view on cracks is reassuring: old shell has dried as much as it ever will, so if it hasn't cracked by now it's unlikely to unless it's dropped or damaged while being reset. Prices from the live repair pages, Nov 18, 2026:

  • A cameo or an old brooch: Antique & Heirloom Restoration starts with the $19 evaluation, credited in full. A jeweler tests the metal, maps every joint, pin and stone under magnification, and quotes each step with photos before any work.
  • Loose stones in the frame: Stone Tightening, $50 in silver or $55 in yellow gold ($50 + $5), up to eight stones.
  • Chipped enamel: Enamel Repair from $54 in silver ($34 base + $10 color + $10 location).
  • An all-metal brooch with no cameo, pearls, coral or glued stones: the Jewelry Spa, from $44 in sterling silver; it uses ultrasonic and steam, so never for a cameo.
  • Insuring it first: Jewelry Appraisal starts at $105.

Sky Jewelry runs JewelryRepair.com; its family jewelers on Lenox Avenue have completed over 50,000 repairs since 1989. Shipping is $30 round trip by UPS, with $100 of coverage each way; covering a $1,000 brooch in full adds 2.5% of the $900 above $100, or $22.50, for both directions. It's photographed on arrival and before it ships back, a second jeweler checks the bench jeweler's work, and the work carries a 1-year workmanship guarantee.

Questions

Can you get a cameo wet?
Briefly, yes; soaked, no. A cotton swab barely dampened with lukewarm water is the safe way to lift grime from a shell, coral or lava cameo, followed by drying right away. Don't submerge it or rinse it under a tap, because water collects behind the carving and in the mount.
How do you clean a cameo ring?
The same way as a brooch, with one extra habit: take it off before washing your hands or putting on lotion, because a ring collects both. Swab the carving barely damp, clean the band with a soft dry brush, and keep it out of ultrasonic cleaners. If the cameo moves in its setting, stop and have it checked.
How can I tell if my cameo is shell or stone?
Look at the curve and the surface. Shell cameos are cut from the wall of a shell, and GIA notes hand-carved ones tend to keep its natural curvature, though machine-carved shell is often flat, so flatness alone proves nothing. Hardstone cameos are carved from layered agate or onyx. If you can't tell, clean it as shell, the more delicate material.
Can a cracked cameo be repaired?
It depends on the crack, so it starts with a look under magnification rather than a promise. Stop cleaning and wearing it until then, since a knock or pressure while the cameo is reset is what spreads a crack. At JewelryRepair.com, Antique & Heirloom Restoration begins with a $19 evaluation, credited in full, and each step is quoted with photos before any work.
Will cleaning an antique brooch lower its value?
Over-cleaning can. GIA warns that standard cleaning solutions can damage delicate gem materials and surface finishes, and stripping darkened recesses or polishing a gilded frame removes what makes a piece look its age. Gentle dusting and a damp swab won't hurt. If a brooch may be valuable, have it appraised before restoration; Jewelry Appraisal at JewelryRepair.com starts at $105.