Repair questions · Watches

Can you overwind a watch?

No, not in normal winding. An automatic's mainspring slips inside its barrel once it's full, and a hand-wound watch simply stops turning at full wind. A watch that stops while fully wound, or a hand-wound crown that spins with no resistance, has a fault, not too much winding. A mechanical Watch Overhaul at JewelryRepair.com is $295 for most brands.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

$295Watch Overhaul for a mechanical watch of most brands ($195 + $100)
$19Mail-In Evaluation when a watch won't run after a full wind, credited in full
$30round-trip UPS shipping per order, with $100 of coverage each way
50,000+repairs since 1989 by Sky Jewelry's family of jewelers

The short version

  • An automatic can't be overwound. Its mainspring ends in a slipping bridle that slides around the barrel wall once the spring is full, so extra turns do nothing.
  • A hand-wound watch stops you at full wind. The crown gets harder to turn, then stops. That stop is the full point, not a sign you've gone too far; just don't force past it.
  • A watch that feels overwound usually needs service: it's fully wound but stopped by dirty or dried oil or a broken part, or its spring has broken.
  • At JewelryRepair.com: a Watch Overhaul is $295 for a mechanical watch of most brands, Stem & Crown Replacement starts at $75, and the $19 Mail-In Evaluation sorts out which one you need.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Watch Overhaul $295 mechanical
$195 quartz
The fix for a watch that stops at full wind or runs down within hours: the movement is taken apart, cleaned ultrasonically, inspected for wear in the train, mainspring and jewels, then lubricated, regulated and resealed. Worn parts are flagged before anything proceeds. Brand surcharges apply; overhauls can't be rushed.
Stem & Crown Replacement from $75For a crown that pulls out, spins without setting the time or was damaged by forcing: a new stem cut to your case and a matched crown with a fresh gasket where the design calls for one; winding, setting and date tested. TAG Heuer +$120, Rolex +$200.
Mail-In Evaluation $19Not sure whether it's the spring, the movement or the crown? A jeweler examines the whole watch under magnification and sends an itemized quote with photos. Credited in full toward the work you approve.

Where the overwinding myth comes from

The myth has a real history. Wikipedia's article on the mainspring explains that before modern alloys, mainsprings broke from metal fatigue long before other parts of a watch wore out, and often at full wind, right after the owner had wound it. So the winding got the blame. Since 1945, carbon steel has increasingly given way to alloys with a higher elastic limit, which watchmakers call white metal springs, and breaks have been rare since the 1960s.

Older watches did have one real overwinding problem: knocking, or banking, where a spring wound with excess force drove the balance so far that the impulse pin knocked against the back of the fork horns. Modern movements prevent it with a click that lets the arbor back off about two ratchet teeth after you stop winding.

On the rest, the article is blunt: a watch stopped at full wind is never stopped by overwinding. The usual cause is dirt and dried oil raising friction until the spring can no longer drive the movement, or a balance staff broken in a drop. The winding only revealed the problem.

Why an automatic can't be overwound

An automatic winds itself with a weighted rotor that keeps turning as long as your wrist moves, long after the spring is full. Without a way to let go, it would overwind itself every day. The answer is the slipping bridle, a circular spring at the outer end of the mainspring that holds it to the barrel wall by friction until the mainspring is fully wound, then slides along the wall. Wikipedia credits the slipping mainspring to a patent by Adrien Philippe on 16 June 1863, long before self-winding wristwatches existed.

That's why an automatic never gives you a hard stop when you wind it by hand. You keep turning and the crown keeps turning; past the full point, the bridle is simply slipping. Seiko's 4R instructions say so plainly, add that a fully wound watch of that family runs about 41 hours, and suggest wearing it more than 10 hours a day to keep it running accurately. Day-to-day technique is covered in how to wind an automatic or hand-wound watch.

One caution: Wikipedia calls the "unbreakable mainspring" label misleading. The bridle protects the spring from winding, not from age; springs still tire and can break, which is a service matter.

Why a hand-wound watch stops at full wind

In a hand-wound mechanical watch, winding coils the mainspring tighter around its arbor, so the crown gets harder to turn until it won't go further. That point is full. Don't force the crown beyond it, and wind with the watch off your wrist, with any screw-down crown unscrewed first. Some makers' manuals also ask you to turn the crown back slightly once you feel resistance; if yours does, follow it.

Wikipedia puts the common one-day movement at 36 to 40 hours on a full wind, so winding once a day, at about the same time, leaves spare hours for a late wind. Winding a modern hand-wound watch all the way is what it's built for.

If it feels overwound, here's what's usually wrong

  • The crown won't turn and the watch isn't running. On a hand-wound watch the spring is full and the movement can't use it: dirty or dried oil, a worn part, or a balance staff broken in a drop. Winding harder won't help. Check first that a screw-down crown is actually unscrewed.
  • The crown turns and turns with no resistance, and the watch won't start. On a hand-wound watch that usually points to a broken mainspring or a fault in the winding parts. On an automatic, endless turning is normal, but a watch that won't start after a good wind isn't. See why a watch won't wind.
  • It runs, but stops within hours of a full wind. A tired spring, which Wikipedia says should be replaced during servicing, or a dirty movement causes it. See also why an automatic stops overnight.
  • The crown is stiff or gritty, pulls out, or spins without setting the time. That's the crown and stem, not the spring: Stem & Crown Replacement, or read why a watch crown gets stuck or stiff.
  • It's a quartz watch that stopped. Winding has nothing to do with it; start with a Watch Battery & Pressure Check, from $30.

If you can't tell which it is, stop testing the crown. The Start a Repair wizard sends a watch that stops to a free diagnosis first, or book the $19 Mail-In Evaluation, credited in full.

What it costs at JewelryRepair.com

The configurator on each repair page shows the exact total before checkout, and every price carries the 1-year workmanship guarantee.

  • Watch Overhaul: $295 for a mechanical watch of most brands ($195 + $100 for a mechanical movement); $195 for quartz. Brand surcharges show before checkout: a mechanical Omega is $310 ($195 + $15 + $100) and a mechanical Rolex $495 ($195 + $200 + $100). Overhauls can't be rushed and take longer than the roughly three weeks most repairs take.
  • Stem & Crown Replacement: from $75 for most brands; TAG Heuer adds $120 and Rolex $200.
  • Mail-In Evaluation: $19, credited in full toward the work you approve. If you decline, the watch ships back with nothing more to pay.

Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, with the prepaid label in your account. In your order note, say whether it's hand-wound or automatic, how long it runs after a full wind, and whether the crown screws down; coverage options are on shipping and insurance. The watch is photographed when it reaches the New York studio and again before it ships back.

Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue since 1989, runs JewelryRepair.com as its mail-in service. Its bench has completed over 50,000 repairs since 1989. We're an independent repair service, not affiliated with, authorized by or endorsed by Seiko or any other watch brand. If your watch is under the maker's warranty or a service plan, check with the maker first, because outside service can void it.

Questions

What happens if you overwind a watch?
On a modern watch, nothing, because normal winding can't go too far: an automatic's mainspring slips once it's full, and a hand-wound watch stops at firm resistance. What does cause damage is forcing a hand-wound crown past that point, winding on the wrist, or turning a screw-down crown before it's unscrewed. If the crown now feels wrong, the $19 Mail-In Evaluation at JewelryRepair.com is credited in full toward the repair.
Why won't my watch crown turn anymore?
Usually because a hand-wound watch is already fully wound, or a screw-down crown is still locked. If it's fully wound but not running, the movement is the problem, often dirty or dried oil or a part damaged in a drop, not overwinding. A crown that's stuck or gritty in every position is a crown or stem fault: Stem & Crown Replacement at JewelryRepair.com starts at $75.
How much does it cost to fix an overwound watch?
It depends on what's actually wrong, because a watch that seems overwound is usually stopped by dirty oil or a worn or broken part. At JewelryRepair.com, a Watch Overhaul is $295 for a mechanical watch of most brands and $195 for quartz, with worn parts flagged before anything proceeds. Stem & Crown Replacement starts at $75, and the $19 Mail-In Evaluation is credited in full. Shipping is $30 round trip.
Can you overwind a pocket watch?
Not by winding it fully, but an old pocket watch deserves gentle hands. Its mainspring may be decades old, and Wikipedia notes that older springs broke from metal fatigue, often at full wind, with breaks becoming rare only after metallurgy improved in the 1960s. Wind until you feel resistance and stop. If it won't hold a wind, start with the $19 Mail-In Evaluation at JewelryRepair.com, credited in full.